The AMERICAN IDOL Thread.

[SuzeQuze]

I agree that Constantine seems a bit unatural. I still kinda like him, but he comes off as (his mannerisms) as a Jim Morrison wanna-be. Does anyone else get that feeling? Not te way he sings, but the way he moves and stuff make me think of Val Kilmer in the Doors movie. I was thinking that last night. Could be the hair, too...

Yes, like he's doing a bad acting job. He's singing from outside of himself, too concerned about how he "looks". In other words, "posing". I did like his performance last night though! :lol: For some reason I liked that song for him.

[Kelly]

You have to watch Carrie!! :blob2: That girl rocked "Alone" hardcore and I LOVE her voice. Simon gave her mad props and predicted she would win and sell more records than any other idol winner. :nod: Personally, I felt her performance last night was one of the best I have ever seen on AI...I dug it way more than Fansuckia's Summertime. :distress: Carrie is sweet, humble, beautiful and her voice is just stunning.
Constantine is really eye fu**ing the camera way too much for me. That over the top "I know I am sexy" schtick is getting on my last nerve. I know I used to like him but I got some sense. :rolleyes: He is not great..but still cute. I like Bo but he was a schnoozefest last night.
Nadia is not my favorite and Scott? Get some humility man. He basically rolled his eyes at Simon as he was getting his critique. Listen and learn! And lose the damn greasy glasses. :p

[cliffdweller]

Carrie sang the hell out of Heart's "Alone."

She sure did and I was SCRUTINIZING her every note too. When she came out I turned to my hubby and said, yeah right, this chick is going to sing my girl Ann Wilson's song, give me a break. But she pulled it off. I was eating crow after her performance.

Poor Nadia. Can someone say wrong song choice? At least wrong rendition of a song. I hated how they up-tempoed it and turned it into some reggae sounding disaster. Ugh. That song is meant to be a heart-wrenching ballad (a la Cindy Lauper's version) not a cruise ship fiasco. I love Nadia and I hope this performance doesn't get her axed. But I hear they're going to re-perform tonight? Great...does that mean the contestants whose votes didn't get screwed up get to re-perform? Can they pick different songs? I hope so...

[cliffdweller]

Constantine is really eye fu**ing the camera way too much for me. That over the top "I know I am sexy" schtick is getting on my last nerve.

Ugh. You cannot rock out to the Partridge Family no matter how hard you try. Sorry Constantine, but that was LAME!!!!

[cliffdweller]

and Carrie's..not a fan of the big hair thing.

But it fit the 80's themed song! :laugh: I hated it too. blech.

[skcin]

Poor Nadia. Can someone say wrong song choice? At least wrong rendition of a song. I hated how they up-tempoed it and turned it into some reggae sounding disaster. Ugh. That song is meant to be a heart-wrenching ballad (a la Cindy Lauper's version) not a cruise ship fiasco. I love Nadia and I hope this performance doesn't get her axed. But I hear they're going to re-perform tonight? Great...does that mean the contestants whose votes didn't get screwed up get to re-perform? Can they pick different songs? I hope so...

I agree about Nadia - weird reggae vibe happening. I hope she stays. Mikalah was way worse anyway.

I don't think they are going to re-perform tonight, I thought it was going to be rerun with some little extras thrown in. :shrug:

[cliffdweller]

I don't think they are going to re-perform tonight, I thought it was going to be rerun with some little extras thrown in. :shrug:

Hmmm...wonder what the extras could be? Hopefully it won't be more footage of Paula maniacally kissing Simon. That triggered my gag reflex.:laugh:

[AliP]

Hmmm...wonder what the extras could be? Hopefully it won't be more footage of Paula maniacally kissing Simon. That triggered my gag reflex.:laugh:


Yeah what was up with her anyway? Was she on drugs last night or what :shrug:

[skcin]

Yeah what was up with her anyway? Was she on drugs last night or what :shrug:

My coworker commented that she seemed drunk. :nod:

[amber]

.....btw

I love it when it is post after post of Amber talking out loud. :laugh:
:lol:
Stupid time difference... :p

[ontheEdgeof17]

Thank the Idol Gods that last night is being replayed! :thumbsup:

Carrie just finished. It was a good performance, but I nothing too too special with it. Kelly's performances in Season 1 were a lot better than that, IMO.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Scott......lay off the Dollar General Bling Bling. :rolleyes:

A.O.K. performance. He will be in the bottom three, though.

[GypsySorcerer]

Ugh, Nikko. Not a fan.

[ontheEdgeof17]

VONZELL..........


She's becoming my new fav. Girl worked it! She's like Trenyce of Season 2. I would love to see Vonzell belt out Proud Mary.

[ontheEdgeof17]

I'm pulling and Amby and talking to myself but.....

My 3 favs:

Vonzell
Carrie
Jessica


Bottom 3:

Nikko
Scott
Mikala....buh bye

[SuzeQuze]

VONZELL..........


She's becoming my new fav. Girl worked it! She's like Trenyce of Season 2. I would love to see Vonzell belt out Proud Mary.

She really was great, I forgot to mention her in yesterday's post. I would be happy if she won. Bo, Carrie, Nadia, Vonzell from one to four are my favs to win it.

[skcin]

I'm pulling and Amby and talking to myself but.....

My 3 favs:

Vonzell
Carrie
Jessica


Bottom 3:

Nikko
Scott
Mikala....buh bye

I doubt Scott wil be in the bottom 3. I tried to vote for Scott, Carrie & Nadia. At 10:30, Carrie & Scott were still busy. I did finally get through for Nadia :distress: so of course, I voted for her 15 times.

I don't think she did that well this week, but Mikalah was much worse.

Who I think will be in the bottom 3:

Mikalah
Nadia :distress: :distress: :distress:
Nikko

Who I think should be in the bottom 3:

Mikalah
Anthony
Constantine

[cliffdweller]

Who I think should be in the bottom 3:

Mikalah
Anthony
Constantine

Agreed. Is the results show coming on tonight? I missed it last night cuz of softball.

:wavey:

[SuzeQuze]

I doubt Scott wil be in the bottom 3. I tried to vote for Scott, Carrie & Nadia. At 10:30, Carrie & Scott were still busy. I did finally get through for Nadia :distress: so of course, I voted for her 15 times.

I don't think she did that well this week, but Mikalah was much worse.

Who I think will be in the bottom 3:

Mikalah
Nadia :distress: :distress: :distress:
Nikko

Who I think should be in the bottom 3:

Mikalah
Anthony
Constantine

I also agree with your picks for who should go. :nod:

[WildInTheWind]

Woooohooooo!!! Mikayla is finally gone!! It's about time. She took it very well, too, she didn't shed a tear. And her performance tonight was a million times better than Tuesday night. Still not that great, but alot better. Why do so many of them sound better after they've been voted off? Strange...
I can't believe Nadia was in the bottom 3! She wasn't as good as usual, but she was a hellava lot better than Anthony, and a few others. Oh well, at least she wasn't voted off.

[Dreammms]

[QUOTE=WildInTheWind]Woooohooooo!!! Mikayla is finally gone!! It's about time.[QUOTE]

:blob1: Thank GOD! I couldnt take another week hearing her!

[ontheEdgeof17]

Well, I'm pleased with the outcome.


'Nuff said.

[skcin]

I was about to cry when my prediction came true & my Nadia was up there. Thank God the voters did have some sense & didn't vote for Mikalah.

[Sorceress]

I was about to cry when my prediction came true & my Nadia was up there. Thank God the voters did have some sense & didn't vote for Mikalah.

Yes, and Nadia was not even that bad. I guess I'd better vote for her like crazy next week. Even though she has been a little inconsistent, she's still one of the best. It would be a real shame for her to go this early.

[cliffdweller]

Who else was in the bottom three? Hopefully it was Constantine.

[wondergirl9847]

Nadia, Mikalah and Anthony.

[cliffdweller]

Nadia, Mikalah and Anthony.

I don't think Anthony has much longer. I predict next week will be his last.

[WildInTheWind]

I don't think Anthony has much longer. I predict next week will be his last.

I sure hope so...that kid bores me to tears!

[Lee]

At first I liked Anthony, but he just keeps doing his Barry Manilow type songs, & I just had to switch to Bo Bice who sings my type of music anyway.

I still like Carrie. She real did well last week, singing a Heart song. :nod:

Lee :)

[ontheEdgeof17]

At first I liked Anthony, but he just keeps doing his Barry Manilow type songs


Agreed! What happened Anthony? Spice it up or you are gone soon...... :distress:

[golden braid]

At first I liked Anthony, but he just keeps doing his Barry Manilow type songs

Lee :)
Me too. I thought he had a really good voice. But now he just keeps singing cheesy pop songs and there isn't any substance to the songs or his voice.

[skcin]

Agreed! What happened Anthony? Spice it up or you are gone soon...... :distress:


ZZZZZZzzzzzzzZZZZZZzzzzzzZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzZZZZzzz...sorry,what? :p

[ontheEdgeof17]

ZZZZZZzzzzzzzZZZZZZzzzzzzZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzZZZZzzz...sorry,what? :p


Sorry he didn't become a poser like Scott. He is actually a big laugh. Sunglasses on stage? COME ON!

[skcin]

Sorry he didn't become a poser like Scott. He is actually a big laugh. Sunglasses on stage? COME ON!


HEY! Step off my man, beyotch! :mad:

:laugh: :lol: :laugh:

I must point out that they're not dark sunglasses or anything, just those pretty tinted ones. :p But I was embarrassed for him when Ryan said they were greasy. That was just mean!

[skcin]

Once again, I want people to go before I even hear them perform. Is that so wrong? :D

Anthony has sucked major ass lately, he can go. Not a huge fan of Nikko either.

My girl Nadia had better kick it back up this week! :nod:

[ontheEdgeof17]

Once again, I want people to go before I even hear them perform. Is that so wrong? :D

Anthony has sucked major ass lately, he can go. Not a huge fan of Nikko either.

My girl Nadia had better kick it back up this week! :nod:


I want Scott and Nikko to such major ass tonight! :p

I hope Anthony does well......if not, he can go sometime. I've lost interest.

[hayley]

HEY! Step off my man, beyotch! :mad:

:laugh: :lol: :laugh:

I must point out that they're not dark sunglasses or anything, just those pretty tinted ones. :p But I was embarrassed for him when Ryan said they were greasy. That was just mean!

Okay, I've been trying to figure out who it is in the country that actually LIKES Scott, and now I know it's YOU, Paula!

He creeps me out like you wouldn't believe.

[skcin]

Okay, I've been trying to figure out who it is in the country that actually LIKES Scott, and now I know it's YOU, Paula!

He creeps me out like you wouldn't believe.


HEY! Not just me! Amber does too! :nod:

Where are you Amby, help me out here! :(

[hayley]

HEY! Not just me! Amber does too! :nod:

Where are you Amby, help me out here! :(

EWW.

He looks llike he smells.

[amber]

HEY! Not just me! Amber does too! :nod:

Where are you Amby, help me out here! :(
I'm here, doll. Yes, Scott. He just sings nicely, he doesn't make a big hairy deal out of everything...and - I can't smell him from here, so I don't care if he smells! :D Didn't see him this week, or last week, or whatever, though.

[skcin]

I'm here, doll. Yes, Scott. He just sings nicely, he doesn't make a big hairy deal out of everything...and - I can't smell him from here, so I don't care if he smells! :D Didn't see him this week, or last week, or whatever, though.

Well, he was fantastic! Sang Against All Odds - got good reviews from the judges. :thumbsup:

Yes, he looks like a serial killer. Yes, he may appear to be hygenically impaired. Yes, the stylists are wreaking havoc on him with the pink sunglasses & fake bling.

I DON'T CARE!He has a beautiful voice. So step OFF! :wavey:

[ontheEdgeof17]

Well, he was fantastic! Sang Against All Odds - got good reviews from the judges. :thumbsup:

Yes, he looks like a serial killer. Yes, he may appear to be hygenically impaired. Yes, the stylists are wreaking havoc on him with the pink sunglasses & fake bling.

I DON'T CARE!He has a beautiful voice. So step OFF! :wavey:


He doesn't deserve to be the Idol. His album would put me to sleep.

zzzzZZZZZZ

[skcin]

He doesn't deserve to be the Idol. His album would put me to sleep.

zzzzZZZZZZ

Oh, I see, you're snoring. Funny Ha-Ha. You must be speaking of Anthony. RIGHT?!?! :mad:

[ontheEdgeof17]

Oh, I see, you're snoring. Funny Ha-Ha. You must be speaking of Anthony. RIGHT?!?! :mad:


Oh. You didn't just say that.



I wish you 3 feet of snow.

[skcin]

Oh. You didn't just say that.



I wish you 3 feet of snow.


Your powers are useless here - it's 50 degrees right now. :rolleyes:

[amber]

Your powers are useless here - it's 50 degrees right now. :rolleyes:
Plus, Nadia should be the Idol, anyway...

[skcin]

Plus, Nadia should be the Idol, anyway...


Preach it, sistah!

*sistah! sistah!*

[Dreammms]

my three least fav tonight....

scott
anthony
bo

[ontheEdgeof17]

<3:

Vonzell
Constantine :eek:
Carrie


Decent:

Bo
Jessica
Nikko
Nadia


Bottom Three for me:

Scott
Anthony
Anwar

[GypsySorcerer]

<3:

Vonzell
Constantine :eek:
Carrie


Decent:

Bo
Jessica
Nikko
Nadia


Bottom Three for me:

Scott
Anthony
Anwar

I agree on all counts. :wavey:

Vonzell is my new fave. :)

[hayley]

I thought they all SUCKED except Carrie and Vonzell. I hate watching this show. I can't wait until Gilmore Girls is back so that I don't have an excuse to watch AI anymore.

I think I hate Anwar the most. He bugs.

[WildInTheWind]

I thought they were mostly pretty decent tonight. Bottom three should be...Jessica, Scott, and a tie between Anwar and Anthony. Carrie should stick to Heart :rolleyes: I thought Nadia was good, I don't know what was up with the judges. Constantine was great! :blob1: And I always love Bo. Vonzell was, I think, one of the best of the night.

[amber]

Here's Carrie in Newscope

"Carrie Underwood, American Idol Favorite

"We're sorry America," said American Idol host Ryan Seacrest last week after a classic Mercury retrograde snafu mixed up the phone numbers for voting on contestants. The scandalous error actually boosted ratings for the popular FOX TV show, with some 27.5 million viewers tuning in. Ten contestants remain, and if you believe judge Simon Cowell, the winner will eventually be Carrie Underwood.

Carrie Underwood was born during the New Moon in Pisces (March 14, 1983; Fort Smith, AR; time unknown), the sign associated with faith. She's a Southern Baptist, and according to a neighbor, she sings at the local church regularly: "I can still remember her singing ‘Jesus Loves Me' when she was only 4 or 5 in front of the whole church."

No shrinking violet, Carrie is emboldened by Venus and Mars in self-assertive Aries. Venus here is given grace and poise with a trine to Neptune, and charisma and mass appeal with the opposition to Pluto. Mars is fortified by a trine to a lucky Jupiter-Uranus conjunction in Sagittarius. With all of these planets in fire signs, she's become a show-stopping, confident, wonder woman.

The Jupiter-Uranus conjunction is often a sign of fame and sudden celebrity. Over the next two months transiting Uranus is forming a square to this planetary pair, activating the natal potential. Uranus can also bring unexpected falls, but then transiting Saturn is forming a stabilizing trine to her Sun. Also, transiting Pluto is squaring her Sun, funneling the full force of the cosmos through her being. If she can handle the pressure, she will win."

[WildInTheWind]

If she can handle the pressure, she will win."
Well I personally hope she can't handle the pressure! The last thing we need is another pop singer with a country accent. :rolleyes: I want someone interesting to win....like Bo :xoxo:

[ontheEdgeof17]

Well I personally hope she can't handle the pressure! The last thing we need is another pop singer with a country accent. :rolleyes: I want someone interesting to win....like Bo :xoxo:


As long as it is not Scott.........who WILL be going home tomorrow!

I'd like to see Vonzell get at least top 3. She's the only one that has gotten better week by week. By the finale, she will be smokin'!

[Sorceress]

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.

[WildInTheWind]

As long as it is not Scott.........who WILL be going home tomorrow!

I'd like to see Vonzell get at least top 3. She's the only one that has gotten better week by week. By the finale, she will be smokin'!

I don't think Vonzell will win...but I hope she stays for a long time, too. She is a damn good singer. I think her performance tonight will make alot of people realize that if they haven't already.

[WildInTheWind]

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.


Yea...she is totally not all there. :shrug: She has been extra nice to everybody, too. I don't think she said a bad word about anyone tonight. But yes, she's just not right lately.

[amber]

Yea...she is totally not all there. :shrug: She has been extra nice to everybody, too. I don't think she said a bad word about anyone tonight. But yes, she's just not right lately.
Her eyes are a little drifty-woozy.
oh, p.s.? Anwarzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz........

[dissention]

So, I actually braved the waters and watched it tonight...

How can anyone like ANY of the male singers? Talk about atrocious. Constantine had me praying that I would go deaf and blind. That hair looked like roadkill.

I so want to get my mitts on that Scott dude and attack the sides of his face with a Lady Bic. And that shirt! You're husky, Scott, don't wear diagonal stripes. He looked like he could eat Ryan Seacrest for a minute there at the end.

The only one that's remotely talented, IMO, was the last one. I'd never listen to her CD, but she's got killer pipes (even if she was straining). :nod:

[amber]

Nadia did well, and I love that song, but it seems like she could've done a bit better, a little more dynamic vocal for that one.... :shrug: I sure like her scratchy little rock voice, though (suprise! :p )

[dissention]

Do you guys agree that Paula is on something? She seems so out of it that I'm embarrassed for her.

There's no question that she's abusing painkillers. No wonder she hit someone with her car and drove off. Crazy beeyotch. :laugh:

[amber]

So, I actually braved the waters and watched it tonight...

How can anyone like ANY of the male singers? Talk about atrocious. Constantine had me praying that I would go deaf and blind. That hair looked like roadkill.

I so want to get my mitts on that Scott dude and attack the sides of his face with a Lady Bic. And that shirt! You're husky, Scott, don't wear diagonal stripes. He looked like he could eat Ryan Seacrest for a minute there at the end.

The only one that's remotely talented, IMO, was the last one. I'd never listen to her CD, but she's got killer pipes (even if she was straining). :nod:
I don't care for the male performers much, either.... :shrug:

[dissention]

Nadia did well, and I love that song, but it seems like she could've done a bit better, a little more dynamic vocal for that one.... :shrug: I sure like her scratchy little rock voice, though (suprise! :p )

Is she the one that sang Etheridge? Nope, thought she sucked major ass. :lol:

Talk about karaoke, sheesh. Unlike Simon, I wouldn't have shut off the microphone at the karaoke bar, I would have screamed "FIRE!"

[dissention]

I don't care for the male performers much, either.... :shrug:

They're terrible, I don't know how you guys can deal with them on a weekly basis. :laugh: I find it comical when they try to hit those high notes, though. Talk about entertainment!

[amber]

Is she the one that sang Etheridge? Nope, thought she sucked major ass. :lol:

Talk about karaoke, sheesh. Unlike Simon, I wouldn't have shut off the microphone at the karaoke bar, I would have screamed "FIRE!"
yeah, that was her. Oh, suprise, you thought she sucked ass? you're kidding?! Wow, you usually have such high praise for everyone....

[dissention]

yeah, that was her. Oh, suprise, you thought she sucked ass? you're kidding?! Wow, you usually have such high praise for everyone....

I only have high praise for that last girl. She's got a great range and anyone who can do justice to a Whitney song is a damn fine singer. :nod:

[amber]

I only have high praise for that last girl. She's got a great range and anyone who can do justice to a Whitney song is a damn fine singer. :nod:
Anyone who chooses a Whitney song sucks ass, automatically. I like Nadia, she avoids the "cheesy ballad" route continuously, she rocks, and her voice is scratchy. Plus, I love her hair, and she always has the best clothes. But, you don't watch anyway, so.... ;) I haven't heard "last girl" yet, so I don't know who you are talking about. Right this moment black guy with glasses is boring the **** out of me... :rolleyes:

[amber]

Omigosh, Anthony was slightly less boring tonight... :laugh:

[dissention]

Anyone who chooses a Whitney song sucks ass, automatically. I like Nadia, she avoids the "cheesy ballad" route continuously, she rocks, and her voice is scratchy. Plus, I love her hair, and she always has the best clothes. But, you don't watch anyway, so.... ;) I haven't heard "last girl" yet, so I don't know who you are talking about. Right this moment black guy with glasses is boring the **** out of me... :rolleyes:

Well, you can't get any more cliched once you choose a Whitney song or a Stevie Wonder song, but the same Etheridge song has been done so many times that it's just as cliched. The only one I've ever seen in the history of American Idol who chose a nice, unpredictable and eclectic mix of songs was Nikki McKibbin, and she wasn't even that good of a singer. Nikki was a cute little rocker, her voice was pretty weak, but she was certainly original. :o

The last girl that I'm talking about had some weird name, but I can't remember it.

[amber]

Well, you can't get any more cliched once you choose a Whitney song or a Stevie Wonder song, but the same Etheridge song has been done so many times that it's just as cliched. The only one I've ever seen in the history of American Idol who chose a nice, unpredictable and eclectic mix of songs was Nikki McKibbin, and she wasn't even that good of a singer. Nikki was a cute little rocker, her voice was pretty weak, but she was certainly original. :o
Oh, I've never heard anyone do that Etheridge song. But then, I've rarely watched Idol. But, I wouldn't care if it was as cliched as Stevie Wonder or Whitney, because the difference is, I really like Melissa Etheridge's songs.. :shrug: And it makes all the difference.... :)

[dissention]

Oh, I've never heard anyone do that Etheridge song. But then, I've rarely watched Idol. But, I wouldn't care if it was as cliched as Stevie Wonder or Whitney, because the difference is, I really like Melissa Etheridge's songs.. :shrug: And it makes all the difference.... :)

You probably would have liked Nikki, then. She did Etheridge, Joplin, Stevie, and a bunch of rare old songs. I liked her a lot. She had spunk and personality, the things that Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini lacked badly.

[amber]

You probably would have liked Nikki, then. She did Etheridge, Joplin, Stevie, and a bunch of rare old songs. I liked her a lot. She had spunk and personality, the things that Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini lacked badly.
Wow, yeah, I probably would've. I think a lot of them are super boring. That's why I don't usually watch. Blond Carrie girl just finished, she did well, but...she's dull, too. oh, and she has your b-day... :lol: Man, Paula has vicoden eyes if i've ever seen them! Oh, Vonzell, the other black lady, is next - is that who you said did good? She does have a good voice - she's usually a little...dull, paint by numbers, etc, but she does have a really good voice...

[dissention]

Wow, yeah, I probably would've. I think a lot of them are super boring. That's why I don't usually watch. Blond Carrie girl just finished, she did well, but...she's dull, too. oh, and she has your b-day... :lol: Man, Paula has vicoden eyes if i've ever seen them! Oh, Vonzell, the other black lady, is next - is that who you said did good? She does have a good voice - she's usually a little...dull, paint by numbers, etc, but she does have a really good voice...

I think they're all dull, so... :laugh: It's rather painful to watch because they aren't performers, they're amateur singers and it bores me to tears. And none of them really have personality (Nadia does) and it makes for bad television.

Though it's worth it to see Paula act like a crack ho. :lol:

[amber]

I think they're all dull, so... :laugh: It's rather painful to watch because they aren't performers, they're amateur singers and it bores me to tears. And none of them really have personality (Nadia does) and it makes for bad television.

Though it's worth it to see Paula act like a crack ho. :lol:
Paula is sooo not acting like a crack ho - crack ho's are jumpy, she's all relaxed and quaaluded out... :D "everythings great...ooo, did you see that cloud?" :laugh: Painkillers, baby!
But yeah, Vonzell did well, I think she actually has the best natural voice in the competition, I just don't like her best.
Yes, it is dull - I can't really watch it every week. If everyone didn't do stupid ballads, it would be so much better...

[dissention]

Paula is sooo not acting like a crack ho - crack ho's are jumpy, she's all relaxed and quaaluded out... :D "everythings great...ooo, did you see that cloud?" :laugh: Painkillers, baby!
But yeah, Vonzell did well, I think she actually has the best natural voice in the competition, I just don't like her best.
Yes, it is dull - I can't really watch it every week. If everyone didn't do stupid ballads, it would be so much better...

See her at the Oscars (or maybe it was the Golden Globes)? I swear, she had the crack pipe stuffed down her rack. She was all jumpy on the red carpet and making weird faces when she was posing for the photographers. :laugh:

And she wears the most viscerally offensive clothes known to mankind!

[amber]

See her at the Oscars (or maybe it was the Golden Globes)? I swear, she had the crack pipe stuffed down her rack. She was all jumpy on the red carpet and making weird faces when she was posing for the photographers. :laugh:

And she wears the most viscerally offensive clothes known to mankind!
:lol: :lol:
She was probably off her (painkilling) meds that night.

[Kelly]

Scott is the pits..those high notes were cringeworthy. Hubby actually thought he had a chapped lip, until I pointed out that it was his ridiculously thin mustache.

Carrie is my girl. I think she has the best voice out of all the contestants. Maybe not as much personality but she is sweet and humble and can sing like a star. I want her to win. I dig Nadia but I predict I would not like the type of music she will put out if she wins. (ala Fantasia..barf)
Vonzell is the most improved and has a great set of pipes. She will probably get a deal anyway, even if she doesn't "win"..as long as she keeps improving and picking decent songs.

[cliffdweller]

I dig Nadia but I predict I would not like the type of music she will put out if she wins. (ala Fantasia..barf)

You really think so?! I don't. I think she'd be creative and edgier than the other contestants. Actually, I was telling my hubby last night that I would actually listen to Nadia if she came on the radio---those other contestants? I don't think so. Actually, I can't think of any other Idol contestants that I'd actually listen to on the radio much less buy c.d.'s they put out. Except maybe for LaToya London--girl's got pipes! I think Carrie has a great voice but I can't stand Top 40 country music. I think if Carrie made it that's what she'd do and I wouldn't appreciate it at all. Her rendition of Alone was amazing, she should do more stuff like that. She's definitely got a voice!

[cliffdweller]

See her at the Oscars (or maybe it was the Golden Globes)? I swear, she had the crack pipe stuffed down her rack. She was all jumpy on the red carpet and making weird faces when she was posing for the photographers. :laugh:

And she wears the most viscerally offensive clothes known to mankind!

Girlfriend's definitely on something---quaaludes or alcohol or a mixture of both I'm guessing. She is soooooo out of it! At one point last night Randy and Simon tried to cover something she said. They tried to move on really fast after one of her 'luded out comments. It was embarrassing!

[cliffdweller]

I really like Melissa Etheridge's songs.. :shrug: And it makes all the difference.... :)

I know what you mean. Except sometimes is cuts both ways. I appreciate the fact that they sang a song I love but then again I kind of scrutinize their performance all the more.

[estranged4life]

"American Idiotic Idol" is Carrie Underwood still a contestant?

I saw her face mentioned daily in the newspaper during the week I was home since she is a local girl from Checotah (Only 26 miles from my hometown Muskogee)...Have to pull for the Okie for no reason other than to support another fellow Oklahoman.

Brian j.

[skcin]

<3:

Vonzell
Constantine :eek:
Carrie


Decent:

Bo
Jessica
Nikko
Nadia


Bottom Three for me:

Scott
Anthony
Anwar

I totally agree with your synopsis. But Scott will not actually be in the bottom 3. Mark my words. :nod: Oh, and I did catch what appreared to be his chocolate milk mustache - that's gotta go! :p

Nadia was much better this week, I love her rock edge. Hopefully her being in the bottm last week scared enough of her fans, forcing them to vote for her multiple times last night. :cool:

I wouldn't care if Anthony, Anwar, Jessica or Nikko go tonight.

[WildInTheWind]

I dig Nadia but I predict I would not like the type of music she will put out if she wins. (ala Fantasia..barf)
.


I didn't know Fantasia ever put anything out!? I always wondered what happened to her...

[skcin]

I didn't know Fantasia ever put anything out!? I always wondered what happened to her...


She did. It's way to R&B for my taste.

I don't think Nadia is like her at all. :shrug: She seems to be more of a cool rocker chick, not R&B diva.

[SuzeQuze]

See her at the Oscars (or maybe it was the Golden Globes)? I swear, she had the crack pipe stuffed down her rack. She was all jumpy on the red carpet and making weird faces when she was posing for the photographers. :laugh:

And she wears the most viscerally offensive clothes known to mankind!

She does, she looks awful a lot of times. She is a bit of a loon, I guess that's part of her charm. :D Simon was asked about their sexual tension on Regis and he said that it is like a dog that can't have their bone and he is the bone. :shocked: He said that Paula wants what she can't have. :laugh: Man he is arrogant. Oprah will be having him on in April and I'd like to see her give him crap for being such a bastard but she'll probably just kiss his ass.

[SuzeQuze]

Yes, Brian, Carrie is still in the competition if you haven't already read previous posts here.

I spaced last night and forgot to watch it. :eek: What did Bo sing? Diss, how could you not like Bo? I <3 Bo! I think either he or Carrie should win. But I also like Nadia and Vonzel. The rest can go before I barf any more.

[skcin]

Yes, Brian, Carrie is still in the competition if you haven't already read previous posts here.

I spaced last night and forgot to watch it. :eek: What did Bo sing? Diss, how could you not like Bo? I <3 Bo! I think either he or Carrie should win. But I also like Nadia and Vonzel. The rest can go before I barf any more.

Bo sang "Remedy" by Black Crowes. :shrug: Not bad, but not his best. Nadia did "I'm The Only One" by Melissa Etheridge. I love her. :nod: Vonzell "I Have Nothing" by Whitney. :shocked: Blew it away, she was spectacular. Carrie did Martina's "Independence Day" and rocked. :nod:

[Sorceress]

I know what you mean. Except sometimes is cuts both ways. I appreciate the fact that they sang a song I love but then again I kind of scrutinize their performance all the more.

Yeah. I love "I Can't Make You Love Me." I was so mad that Constantine sang it because I'm ready to hate anything he does. Luckily he didn't totally butcher it the way Camille did "Yellow Brick Road", so I can still like the song. It didn't make me like him any more though. :( I have to say that I'm glad Randy finally called him out and acknowledged that he's not really a rocker but a theater guy. Maybe now he can stop pretending and start to give more genuine performances.

As for Nadia/Fantasia... I wouldn't have expected quite as stereotypical an R&B album from Fantasia either after her song choices in the competition. She did Bonnie R., Johnny Cash, and Berstein for goodness sake. I was expecting variety and creativity from the album too. I think it goes to show that the winner has little control over what they make him/her put on the album. Of course, maybe Fantasia wanted to do the R&B diva thing all along but was restricted from doing so in the competition by the weekly themes. I think I'm trying to say that while Nadia does really seem to be a cool rock chick, her album could be anything but. If she did put out a rock album, I'd definitely listen. I love her voice.

Poor Anwar. What has happened to him? He started out so strong and now he's struggling every week. And Bo is going to have to step it up.

[SuzeQuze]

Bo sang "Remedy" by Black Crowes. :shrug: Not bad, but not his best. Nadia did "I'm The Only One" by Melissa Etheridge. I love her. :nod: Vonzell "I Have Nothing" by Whitney. :shocked: Blew it away, she was spectacular. Carrie did Martina's "Independence Day" and rocked. :nod:

Ah, that's kind of a lame song for him to pick. Stupid Black Crowes. :laugh:

Dammit, I would have liked to see Nadia do that, I love ME.

[SuzeQuze]

Yeah. I love "I Can't Make You Love Me."...


I love that song too but I'm so glad I didn't see Constantine do it. :eek:

Sorceress, I LOVE your Stevie quote in your sig! :D

[skcin]

I love that song too but I'm so glad I didn't see Constantine do it. :eek:

Sorceress, I LOVE your Stevie quote in your sig! :D


I was shocked that Constantine did so well. I didn't hate it. :shrug:

I think you're right, the artists def. have little to no control over what goes on their album. But Kelly Clarkson's CDs are way more rock/pop that Reuben's or Fantasia's.

[cliffdweller]

Poor Anwar. What has happened to him? He started out so strong and now he's struggling every week.

I know! Last night was painful, painful!

I predict the next to go will be Anthony. I think the competition has passed him by at this point, he's just not good enough.

And Bo? I know he can do better than last night. I think he picked the right kind of song but it just didn't do it for me. It's like he was trying too hard or something. Before, he seemed much more natural up there.

[Sorceress]

Sorceress, I LOVE your Stevie quote in your sig!

Thanks...I wish I'd paid attention to where that came from so I could credit the source properly. :)

I think you're right, the artists def. have little to no control over what goes on their album. But Kelly Clarkson's CDs are way more rock/pop that Reuben's or Fantasia's.

I think the marketers must have figured that Reuben and Fantasia would appeal more to an R&B audience and made the song decisions based on what they thought would sell the most records to that target audience. They probably thought Kelly could sell to a broader pop/rock/R&B audience. I think Nadia could have that Kelly-type appeal if they'd allow her to. It's probably a moot point anyway, because I don't think Nadia will win. The producers probably want Carrie to win so badly so they can appeal to the pop/modern country fans too. They want all their bases covered so they can make the most $$$.

Wow, I'm not getting ANY work done today. :laugh:

[Dreammms]

OMG i am so surprised with the bottom two........

wonder who the third will be

[Dreammms]

OMG i cant believe who was sent home!

[GypsySorcerer]

OMG i cant believe who was sent home!

Ditto! I disagreed with the bottom 3.

[GardenStateGirlie]

WTF. I hate Anwar. I think he's overrated. But Jessica? She had been doing fairly well and I thought over the course of the show, had to opportunity to improve. I'm dissapointed :(

[Dreammms]

WTF. I hate Anwar. I think he's overrated. But Jessica? She had been doing fairly well and I thought over the course of the show, had to opportunity to improve. I'm dissapointed :(

so am i. i'm not a major fan of jessica but she had a better voice than anwar or anthony!

[GardenStateGirlie]

so am i. i'm not a major fan of jessica but she had a better voice than anwar or anthony!

Anythony needs to go. So does the heavy set kid with the glasses and Constantine. I like Bo much better than them.

[Dreammms]

Anythony needs to go. So does the heavy set kid with the glasses and Constantine. I like Bo much better than them.

Heavy kid is Scott and I agree he isnt that good either.

Constatine I am partial too because his sister is the principal at the elementary school down the block from me. Talk on the town is that Constatine is gonna perform there. I will admitt though that Constatine's facial expressions annoy the **** outta me. lol

[GardenStateGirlie]

I will admitt though that Constatine's facial expressions annoy the **** outta me. lol

As do his grooming habits.

Brush, meet hair. Soap, meet body. :distress:

[Dreammms]

As do his grooming habits.

Brush, meet hair. Soap, meet body. :distress:

oh i have been saying to my friends from day one that he has yellow ass teeth lol

[WildInTheWind]

I don't mind that Jessica went. But, really....over Scott/Anwar/Anthony??? And he wasn't even in the bottom 3. I just don't understand how Nadia was in the bottom 3 again when people like Scott and Anthony aren't :distress:

[cliffdweller]

I don't mind that Jessica went. But, really....over Scott/Anwar/Anthony??? And he wasn't even in the bottom 3. I just don't understand how Nadia was in the bottom 3 again when people like Scott and Anthony aren't :distress:

:nod: Agreed. This does not bode well for Nadia being in the bottom three two weeks in a row. I hope she's not next to go! Anthony really should have been gone already.

[golden braid]

I think Jessica is better than some of the others still left (like Anthony and Scott) but like Simon said she doesn't seem to be really likeable like some of the other contestants and I agree with Simon. Her personality just didn't come across too much. I think people probably like Anthony because he seems all American and he overcame possibly never being able to speak again.

[GardenStateGirlie]

but like Simon said she doesn't seem to be really likeable like some of the other contestants and I agree with Simon.

But boy did Simon like her when the boys were back in town and her chest was spilling out of her shirt :rolleyes:

[SuzeQuze]

But boy did Simon like her when the boys were back in town and her chest was spilling out of her shirt :rolleyes:

Um, yeah, he's an oinker. I wonder what it is about her that puts people off. She sounded so good during her last performance it was just odd that she was leaving. She wasn't one of my favorites, but Anthony or Anwar should have been gone before her.

[ontheEdgeof17]

This voting sucks. I watched it from my hotel room last night. All the girls are leaving. :distress: If it comes down to Carrie and six guys, I will be pissed.

[wondergirl9847]

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0331051_american_idol_scott_1.html

This is unfortunate. :distress:

[amber]

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0331051_american_idol_scott_1.html

This is unfortunate. :distress:
Wow, I can't believe someone dated him!

[SuzeQuze]

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0331051_american_idol_scott_1.html

This is unfortunate. :distress:

This is no shock though, the guy has psycho http://users.telenet.be/eforum/emoticons4u/violent/sterb135.gif written all over him.

[amber]

This is no shock though, the guy has psycho http://users.telenet.be/eforum/emoticons4u/violent/sterb135.gif written all over him.
:lol: :lol: :lol:
where'd you get that little thingy?

[ontheEdgeof17]

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0331051_american_idol_scott_1.html

This is unfortunate. :distress:


He needs to go then. They have let other ppl go with criminal records.

[WildInTheWind]

Yea if they kicked that big black chick off last year for being in porn, they need to kick him off for being a wife beater. That just wouldn't be right if they let him stay. In my opinion, porn is MUCH better than abuse.

[dissention]

Gawd, his behavior is as heinous as his facial hair. :rolleyes:

[amber]

Gawd, his behavior is as heinous as his facial hair. :rolleyes:
ok, but seriously - someone actually dated him!

[dissention]

ok, but seriously - someone actually dated him!

That's what shocks you?! I'm more shocked that someone carried his seed for nine months.

[amber]

That's what shocks you?! I'm more shocked that someone carried his seed for nine months.
tomato, tamahto...either way, someone f***** him. :eek: Actually, though, I did like him as a contestant, cause he didn't oversing like those other boy b*****. :laugh:

[dissention]

tomato, tamahto...either way, someone f***** him. :eek: Actually, though, I did like him as a contestant, cause he didn't oversing like those other boy b*****. :laugh:

He didn't oversing because he can't sing. MY balls were in pain when he was hitting those high notes. His tighty whiteys were really tight the other night. :laugh:

[amber]

He didn't oversing because he can't sing. MY balls were in pain when he was hitting those high notes. His tighty whiteys were really tight the other night. :laugh:
I generally disagree, of course, but he was straining a bit more the other night. :nod:

[dissention]

I generally disagree, of course, but he was straining a bit more the other night. :nod:

My problem is that 99% of them have average voices that have no flavor or personality. The only one with any originality and power is that Nadia chick. Reuben had an average voice, nothing special. Same with Kelly Clarkson and Clay Aiken. Fantasia could sound like a cartoon character, but she had a helluva unique voice. All these damn kids sing are those awful ballads and karaoke songs that do nothing to flatter their voices (which aren't great to begin with), so I just tuned out this season. :laugh:

[amber]

My problem is that 99% of them have average voices that have no flavor or personality. The only one with any originality and power is that Nadia chick. Reuben had an average voice, nothing special. Same with Kelly Clarkson and Clay Aiken. Fantasia could sound like a cartoon character, but she had a helluva unique voice. All these damn kids sing are those awful ballads and karaoke songs that do nothing to flatter their voices (which aren't great to begin with), so I just tuned out this season. :laugh:
Totally. :nod: Last season, I only caught Fantasia's summertime, which was awesome. But generally I don't like it. Fantasia has my birthday.... :lol:
I'm always shocked by who they pick, etc. It's like they want them to be dull, no personality in their voice. Stevie would've been kicked off in two seconds :laugh: :shrug:

[skcin]

He needs to go then. They have let other ppl go with criminal records.

Wow. I pegged him for being more of a stalker or serial killer, not a wife beater...

Although it pains me to say this - I agree with you Curty. :( He should be let go.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Although it pains me to say this - I agree with you Curty. :( He should be let go.


Looks like it is not going to happen. :rolleyes:


No Ouster for 'Idol' Finalist Over Arrest


NEW YORK - Scott Savol, one of the remaining nine finalists on "American Idol," was once arrested for domestic violence, but the Fox network said the arrest won't cost Savol his shot at becoming an "Idol."


Although several past contestants have been booted for not disclosing arrests, Savol was "forthcoming to the `American Idol' producers and the network regarding his misdemeanor" and "the situation did not warrant his disqualification," Fox said in a statement Thursday.


Ohio police documents posted on The Smoking Gun Web site said Savol, now 28, had a confrontation with Michele Martin, the mother of his son, in February 2001. According to a Shaker Heights Police Department report, the couple had decided to separate, but when Savol arrived at Martin's mother's home to collect his belongings, he called Martin "several vulgar names," "pulled an engagement ring off her finger" and "stated he was also going to take their son."


When Martin threatened to call police, Savol shoved her, pulled the phone from her hand and then threw it at her, striking her in the chest and causing the phone to break, the police report said.


Savol pleaded to a reduced misdemeanor disorderly conduct charge, was fined $500, ordered to complete an anger management or domestic violence program, placed on a year's probation and sentenced to a suspended 20-day jail term, according to the Web site.


http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=494&ncid=762&e=2&u=/ap/20050401/ap_en_tv/people_scott_savol

[GardenStateGirlie]

Great, so the girl two years or a year ago (can't remember) that was an excellent singer but who posed on some website is kicked off but you're going to leave a wife beater in?? Lovely.

[skcin]

Great, so the girl two years or a year ago (can't remember) that was an excellent singer but who posed on some website is kicked off but you're going to leave a wife beater in?? Lovely.


It was Frenchie Davis. And she had one of the best voices ever. :nod:

This thing with Scott? Well, he was honest about it(apparently), and it was more than 3 years ago. Maybe he's turned his life around? :shrug:

But if he turns around this Wednesday & starts strangling Carrie Underwood, he's gotta go! :laugh:

[GardenStateGirlie]

Maybe he's turned his life around? :shrug:

But if he turns around this Wednesday & starts strangling Carrie Underwood, he's gotta go! :laugh:

It's certainly positive but what's good for the goose ought to be good for the gander. I just feel like everyone should have to adhere to the same guidelines set forth by the show.

Yes, please don't strangle Carrie...she's one of the only girls left that I like a lot.

[WildInTheWind]

Great, so the girl two years or a year ago (can't remember) that was an excellent singer but who posed on some website is kicked off but you're going to leave a wife beater in?? Lovely.


So incredibly wrong. :distress: Maybe if enough people hear about it, they will stop voting for him. You'd think his singing would have been enough to make them stop voting!

[skcin]

It's certainly positive but what's good for the goose ought to be good for the gander. I just feel like everyone should have to adhere to the same guidelines set forth by the show.

Yes, please don't strangle Carrie...she's one of the only girls left that I like a lot.

ITA - apparently the diff here is that Scott told AI about this right away. Frenchie didn't (even though that was totally legal & it was so stupid that they let her go.) That other guy from season 1 or 2 tried to hide his criminal record, so they kicked him off (I seem to recall that he actually had a warrant or something, or it was a case happening at that time, not in the past...)

Whether the show boots him or not, I'm sure he won't be getting many votes anymore :o

[Lisa1769]

I, personally dont think his actions make him a wife beater. She even states that her & the baby were not hurt in anyway.

[dissention]

I, personally dont think his actions make him a wife beater. She even states that her & the baby were not hurt in anyway.

:confused:

He employed physical violence on a woman. Around a child, no less. He should be kicked out faster than Winona Ryder at an upscale department store.

[GardenStateGirlie]

Irregardless of whether or not it's for hitting his wife, he needs to go. He's not very good.

[Lisa1769]

:confused:

He employed physical violence on a woman. Around a child, no less. He should be kicked out faster than Winona Ryder at an upscale department store.


I agree somewhat, I don't agree with abuse whatsoever. I just know that when tempers flare, sometimes you do something split second. Like throwing a phone. It could have gotten more violent, but didn't. She was not hurt, maybe her feelings but not physically, so to me thats not abuse. Just my opinion.

[dissention]

I agree somewhat, I don't agree with abuse whatsoever. I just know that when tempers flare, sometimes you do something split second. Like throwing a phone. It could have gotten more violent, but didn't. She was not hurt, maybe her feelings but not physically, so to me thats not abuse. Just my opinion.

But he physically ripped a ring off of her finger, yelled obscene names at her, attempted to take her child, and then threw a phone at her so hard that it broke when she attempted to call the police for assistance. I can't call that anything but abuse. :shrug: You don't have to be hurt badly physically in order to be abused.

[Lisa1769]

But he physically ripped a ring off of her finger, yelled obscene names at her, attempted to take her child, and then threw a phone at her so hard that it broke when she attempted to call the police for assistance. I can't call that anything but abuse. :shrug: You don't have to be hurt badly physically in order to be abused.


I see what your saying about abuse, i just wouldn't classify him as a wife beater. Too me a wife beater is someone who beats the **** out of them.

[skcin]

I see what your saying about abuse, i just wouldn't classify him as a wife beater. Too me a wife beater is someone who beats the **** out of them.


I know what you mean. I guess it was easier for me to type than "domestic abuser." :laugh:

[ontheEdgeof17]

:gag:


What a lame theme. :rolleyes:

[Dreammms]

:gag:


What a lame theme. :rolleyes:

:nod: SNORE is right!

[GypsySorcerer]

:gag:


What a lame theme. :rolleyes:

I was actually excited. :o

It beats Barry Manilow night.

[amber]

I was actually excited. :o

It beats Barry Manilow night.
What's the theme?

[ontheEdgeof17]

I was actually excited. :o

It beats Barry Manilow night.


OMG.

Thanks Krista.....I just went into Post Tramatic Stress Disorder.


:lol:

[GypsySorcerer]

What's the theme?

Musicals. :)

[GypsySorcerer]

OMG.

Thanks Krista.....I just went into Post Tramatic Stress Disorder.


:lol:

Well, being a nurse, I'm glad you're equipped to handle such things. :xoxo: ;)

[amber]

Musicals. :)
YAAAAARGHHHH!
only acceptable musicals, without dancing: Cabaret, and Grease. :laugh: Oh, wait, and....Sweet Charity? is that right? The "Big Spender" one? I would so sing Heatwave, from...TNBLSB! :p

[ontheEdgeof17]

Musicals. :)


......and they all picked the worst of the worst. There are upbeat, good musical songs!



Constantine was the best. I hate to say it...he is growing on me. He ditched the fake rocker junk and now he is good!


Anthony will go tomorrow....even though it should be Scott.

[GateandGarden]

YAAAAARGHHHH!
only acceptable musicals, without dancing: Cabaret, and Grease. :laugh: Oh, wait, and....Sweet Charity? is that right? The "Big Spender" one? I would so sing Heatwave, from...TNBLSB! :pWhat? :eek: What about A Little Night Music? Sweeney Todd? Assassins? Company? No?!? :distress:

[amber]

What? :eek: What about A Little Night Music? Sweeney Todd? Assassins? Company? No?!? :distress:
Sorry, doll. I may like them, if I saw them, but I mostly try to stay away from musicals. Too cheesy for me. Although, I love dancing. Love, love, love. So, in that way, I have seen some musicals. Or at least clips from musicals. :laugh: I love Cyd Sharise, by the way. Ooo, another one for the name thread, Cyd. yep.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Well, being a nurse, I'm glad you're equipped to handle such things. :xoxo: ;)

Thanks for being so empathetic.

:rolleyes: :lol:

[GateandGarden]

Sorry, doll. I may like them, if I saw them, but I mostly try to stay away from musicals. Too cheesy for me. Although, I love dancing. Love, love, love. So, in that way, I have seen some musicals. Or at least clips from musicals. :laugh: I love Cyd Sharise, by the way. Ooo, another one for the name thread, Cyd. yep.How can a musical about homicidal maniacs or cannibalism be cheesy? :laugh: I guess the other two I mentioned are considered cheesy to some. ALNM is my favorite musical though. <3333333

I don't know who Cyd Sharise is, though. :shrug: I'll have to google that.

[GypsySorcerer]

Thanks for being so empathetic.

:rolleyes: :lol:


I try. :) :cool:

[GateandGarden]

How can a musical about homicidal maniacs or cannibalism be cheesy? :laugh: I guess the other two I mentioned are considered cheesy to some. ALNM is my favorite musical though. <3333333

I don't know who Cyd Sharise is, though. :shrug: I'll have to google that.Oh, looks like I should have known who she is, since this website I found said she's the "definitive female icon of American dance." :o

I guess I didn't know 'cause I'm not big on dancing though. Still embarassing, though. :o

[GypsySorcerer]

......and they all picked the worst of the worst. There are upbeat, good musical songs!



Constantine was the best. I hate to say it...he is growing on me. He ditched the fake rocker junk and now he is good!


Anthony will go tomorrow....even though it should be Scott.

Constantine was very good. I enjoyed Nadia and Vonzell this week too.

[amber]

How can a musical about homicidal maniacs or cannibalism be cheesy? :laugh: I guess the other two I mentioned are considered cheesy to some. ALNM is my favorite musical though. <3333333

I don't know who Cyd Sharise is, though. :shrug: I'll have to google that.
Cyd - most beautiful dancer ever.
Well, anytime someone bursts into song in the middle of whatever, I think it's pretty cheesy. Though, you are right, the subject matter is not cheesy. Look, I just don't love musicals, ok? :laugh:
Cyd:
http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y12/antisnark/party_3.jpg

[GypsySorcerer]

I would so sing Heatwave, from...TNBLSB! :p

In Marilyn's Heatwave attire? :]

[amber]

In Marilyn's Heatwave attire? :]
shoot! I can't remember her attire! oh, i'm a bad fan. I seem to recall it was white, with tropical accents, with a slit in the skirt up to there? Is that right? No, of course I would wear black. :D

[GypsySorcerer]

shoot! I can't remember her attire! oh, i'm a bad fan. I seem to recall it was white, with tropical accents, with a slit in the skirt up to there? Is that right? No, of course I would wear black. :D

It was a black bra top and tropical skirt, with the slit up to there. And let's not forget the huge hat. :laugh:

Actually, I haven't seen that movie in forever. It's one of my least favorites of hers.

[amber]

It was a black bra top and tropical skirt, with the slit up to there. And let's not forget the huge hat. :laugh:

Actually, I haven't seen that movie in forever. It's one of my least favorites of hers.
Ah, yes. well, half right. Yeah, i'd sport that. As long as the "tropical" isn't by my face, it's gold.
I really like that performance. On the top of my Marilyn musical performances. :nod:
"In such a way that, the customers say that, she certainly CAN CAN CAN CAN!"
:lol:

[GypsySorcerer]

Ah, yes. well, half right. Yeah, i'd sport that. As long as the "tropical" isn't by my face, it's gold.
I really like that performance. On the top of my Marilyn musical performances. :nod:
"In such a way that, the customers say that, she certainly CAN CAN CAN CAN!"
:lol:



Now I'm going to have to put it the movie. :nod:

Do you think if we started a thread "What is your favorite Marilyn musical number?" anyone would respond besides us? :p :laugh:

[amber]

Now I'm going to have to put it the movie. :nod:

Do you think if we started a thread "What is your favorite Marilyn musical number?" anyone would respond besides us? :p :laugh:
No. :( hehehehe. Does the bus stop performance embarrass you? It does me. I would say my fave is "Running Wild", for sure. Oh! But "I'm Languid" or whatever it's called from TNBLSB is pretty ok. :shrug: Honestly, she is sooo mannered, that you have to view her performances from the other dimension, I think. :p

[GypsySorcerer]

No. :( hehehehe. Does the bus stop performance embarrass you? It does me. I would say my fave is "Running Wild", for sure.

Yeah, I don't care for "Bus Stop." Her accent is awful and I didn't like her love interest.

"Running Wild" is great. I also like her Gentlemen Prefer Blondes numbers, and when she sings "Down in the Meadow" from River of No Return, a dreadful flick. :distress: :cool:

[amber]

Yeah, I don't care for "Bus Stop." Her accent is awful and I didn't like her love interest.

"Running Wild" is great. I also like her Gentlemen Prefer Blondes numbers, and when she sings "Down in the Meadow" from River of No Return, a dreadful flick. :distress: :cool:
Can you believe, I've actually never seen RONR? My obsession was at a time when I didn't have much access to movies. I would scour the TV guide, and check for late playings of MM movies. Then try not to wake my parents up at four in the morning (in our tiny, tiny house :rolleyes: ) while viewing whichever movie on some super fuzzy channel. :laugh: RONR was never one of them. :(
Yes, the GPB numbers are quite good. But they are very staged, I like the "improv" quality of some of the others. :rolleyes: hehehe.

[GypsySorcerer]

Can you believe, I've actually never seen RONR? My obsession was at a time when I didn't have much access to movies. I would scour the TV guide, and check for late playings of MM movies. Then try not to wake my parents up at four in the morning (in our tiny, tiny house :rolleyes: ) while viewing whichever movie on some super fuzzy channel. :laugh: RONR was never one of them. :(
Yes, the GPB numbers are quite good. But they are very staged, I like the "improv" quality of some of the others. :rolleyes: hehehe.

I first saw RONR a fwe years ago. It was on AMC, I think. It's really bad, but some of her musical numbers are good.

[amber]

I first saw RONR a fwe years ago. It was on AMC, I think. It's really bad, but some of her musical numbers are good.
I'll have to see that one. I know way more about the behind the scenes filming than the actual movie. And I do enjoy Robert Mitchum. :)

[WildInTheWind]

.


Anthony will go tomorrow....even though it should be Scott.

I don't know....I'm thinking the recent news about Scott will turn alot of votes aways....I hope at least. :shrug:

[GypsySorcerer]

I don't know....I'm thinking the recent news about Scott will turn alot of votes aways....I hope at least. :shrug:

It will be Scott or Anthony. They both need to go.

[GypsySorcerer]

I'll have to see that one. I know way more about the behind the scenes filming than the actual movie. And I do enjoy Robert Mitchum. :)

MM and Mitchum had some good chemistry. I always thought he was attractive.

[amber]

MM and Mitchum had some good chemistry. I always thought he was attractive.
Yeah, he's slick. Like a hard boiled detective. Apparently they didn't get along great, though.
And I want AnthonyZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz to go. :p

[skcin]

It will be Scott or Anthony. They both need to go.


Agreed. :nod:

I thought the rest did great, despite the awful tunes. Esp. liked the girls. :blob1:

[wondergirl9847]

Thank goodness....he was off key the entire time he was on this show.

[Sorceress]

I'm so sad that we have to put up with Anthony for another week. And there was nothing terrible about Nikko. I can't believe America chose the "domestic abuser" over him. :rolleyes:
Okay, Vonzell fans are going to have to have to start voting again...

[GypsySorcerer]

UGH! Why are Scott and Anthony still on here? :rolleyes:

[AliP]

Well, that was dumb. Anthony is just beyond horrible. Why he wasn't in the bottom three is beyond me.

[WildInTheWind]

What a sucky result!! Nicco was 100 times better than Scott and Anthony. I just want to know who the hell votes for Anthony?!?! How can anyone who can hear vote for him? And Vonzell in the bottom three?! This show never ceases to amaze me.

[Kelly]

Lordy. Scott for another friggin week. I thought for sure the bad press would ensure his oust this week, but alas, it was not meant to be. : > ( Anthony can go after Scott. Then it will get tough, I like the rest of them. Yes, even Constantine. (except the eye fuc##ing) Bo has not done well lately but he has it in him.
I want Carrie or Vonzell to win.

Did anyone else think Fantasia sucked ass? My husband kept commenting that she looked like she has been "hitting the fried chicken"....her booty has gotten rather large!
I really just did not like her performance at all. Sorry to any Tasia fans.

[Sorceress]

Did anyone else think Fantasia sucked ass? My husband kept commenting that she looked like she has been "hitting the fried chicken"....her booty has gotten rather large!
I really just did not like her performance at all. Sorry to any Tasia fans.

No, I enjoyed her, though the first song didn't sound as good live as it does on the album and I think Tamyra's "I Believe" is unbearably cheesy. However, she displayed energy, personality and a voice that no one on this season (or any season before) has come close to. Of course she went over the top, but that's what she does. I also thought she looked fine.

Ryan Seacrest is a little guy--any female standing next to him who is tall and remotely big-framed looks huge beside him. Anyone standing next to this season's unnaturally skinny Celena, Amanda, and Nadia would look practically obese! At any rate, the size of Fantasia's booty is not a big deal; nor does it matter if she's been eating fried chicken or caviar to make it that size. :)

I know Fantasia's not for everyone, but her performance last night made me miss the fun and spunk she brought to the competition. Her "yeah yeah yeahs" got old after a while but I couldn't wait to hear what songs she'd choose and how she'd perform those songs every week. These constestants are really boring in comparison.

[cliffdweller]

My husband kept commenting that she looked like she has been "hitting the fried chicken"....her booty has gotten rather large!

I don't know about all that, but what I do know is that I couldn't STAND her performance. What was with that godawful wailing toward the end of the song? She sounded like a dying cat.

Yoda sez: screech, screech, screech, does not a good singer make. ;)

[paperdoll]

Ughhhh! Anthony go home already! I'm tired of listening to you...and looking at you too. That's all.
--Amy

[skcin]

Not too upset over Nikko being gone, but it definitely should have been Scott or Anthony. :shrug:

[wondergirl9847]

Was Fantasia being murdered on stage or something? Sheesh!! I heard a snippet on the radio this morning of it and yowza. Actually, I'd rather listen to cats dying. LOL

[golden braid]

I thought Fantasia was awful too. It was a bad song and then she wasn't even singing on it. She was yelling and screeching and sounded terrible. And the performance was so dramatic also. She has a unique voice but this was just too much.

[WildInTheWind]

I always liked Fantasia...but didn't care for her performance last night. It pretty much sucked vocally.....painful.

[Sorceress]

Yoda sez: screech, screech, screech, does not a good singer make. ;)


:laugh: Well, okay, it wasn't her best by any stretch. :laugh: She certainly was dedicated to the performance and having a good time with it though--you gotta give her that. I still wish more contestants would loosen up and just go for it he way she did, (with a little restraint, of course). :)

[WildInTheWind]

:laugh: Well, okay, it wasn't her best by any stretch. :laugh: She certainly was dedicated to the performance and having a good time with it though--you gotta give her that. I still wish more contestants would loosen up and just go for it he way she did, (with a little restraint, of course). :)

I'll give her that. She is different...and definatly not boring! That's for sure.

[Sorceress]

Ughhhh! Anthony go home already! I'm tired of listening to you...and looking at you too. That's all.
--Amy

I think Anthony was a lot better looking when he wore his glasses. Now they've got him wearing too much mascara or something!

[cliffdweller]

Now they've got him wearing too much mascara or something!

OMG! I was just about to post this!! I seriously thought it was a girl for a minute when the camera panned to him. What's with putting mascara on him anyway?!?!

[ontheEdgeof17]

Not too upset over Nikko being gone, but it definitely should have been Scott or Anthony. :shrug:


Agreed. :nod:


I finally paid for internet in my room....the last day of my vay-cay. :p

BTW....I'm loving Salt Lake City. It is not what I expected. I so want to move here. :)

[skcin]

Agreed. :nod:


I finally paid for internet in my room....the last day of my vay-cay. :p

BTW....I'm loving Salt Lake City. It is not what I expected. I so want to move here. :)


Did they convert you to Mormonism?


(is that even a word? :laugh: )

[Kelly]

No, I enjoyed her, though the first song didn't sound as good live as it does on the album and I think Tamyra's "I Believe" is unbearably cheesy. However, she displayed energy, personality and a voice that no one on this season (or any season before) has come close to. Of course she went over the top, but that's what she does. I also thought she looked fine.

Ryan Seacrest is a little guy--any female standing next to him who is tall and remotely big-framed looks huge beside him. Anyone standing next to this season's unnaturally skinny Celena, Amanda, and Nadia would look practically obese! At any rate, the size of Fantasia's booty is not a big deal; nor does it matter if she's been eating fried chicken or caviar to make it that size. :)

I know Fantasia's not for everyone, but her performance last night made me miss the fun and spunk she brought to the competition. Her "yeah yeah yeahs" got old after a while but I couldn't wait to hear what songs she'd choose and how she'd perform those songs every week. These constestants are really boring in comparison.

I don't care about the size of her booty but my man does and I felt like sharing. None of this stuff we talk about is a big deal in the big scheme of things. I did not like her 'performance'... it just wasnt for me. I see others agree with me too. I did like her last year when she was on the show and voted for her to win but uh, didnt like her vocals too much last night.

[Sorceress]

None of this stuff we talk about is a big deal in the big scheme of things. I did not like her 'performance'... it just wasnt for me.

You're absolutely right. Not that big a deal. Truth be told, when I watched the Christmas special with Kelly, Rueben and Fantasia last year, I didn't enjoy one minute of it. So I know she doesn't walk on water. Anyway, I obviously still really like what I saw of her last year and can't help but want to see her do well now. I hope someone from this season will inspire me in the same way. :nod: I'm still waiting.

ps: I didn't think she was as bad as cats dying, but I suppose there's no accounting for taste. :)

Oh, and let's hope for a better theme this week.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Did they convert you to Mormonism?


(is that even a word? :laugh: )


Naw.

Trust me. Plenty of guys for me. Plenty.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Vonzell <3



Scott. Go Home.

[GardenStateGirlie]

Why is this show hurting my everything??

I'm with you, Curtis. So far, Vonzell is my favorite.

[wondergirl9847]

Vonzell is adorable. She did a great job tonight. Ya'll gonna lose yo mind when Con sings....

SPOILER BELOW








































Bohemian Rhapsody. This will be interesting. :shocked:

[GardenStateGirlie]

GO CARRIE!!!! :thumbsup:

[ontheEdgeof17]

GO CARRIE!!!! :thumbsup:


Aw. She tried. It went great to good to eh.

[GardenStateGirlie]

Aw. She tried. It went great to good to eh.

Meeh...Carrie...why?! You should have ended the song instead of continuing
-_- Great to good indeed.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Why Curtis why?

My love for Constantine has grown from a blade of grass to those damn vines that invade the walls of your house....you like it, but you hate it at the same time. :o I. like. him. now.

[GardenStateGirlie]

Why Curtis why?

My love for Constantine has grown from a blade of grass to those damn vines that invade the walls of your house....you like it, but you hate it at the same time. :o I. like. him. now.

Honey, please tell me you're joking O_o

Paula, sit down and snort more coke. Thanks. God, she's annoying.

[GypsySorcerer]

Why Curtis why?

My love for Constantine has grown from a blade of grass to those damn vines that invade the walls of your house....you like it, but you hate it at the same time. :o I. like. him. now.

I like him now too. :nod:

[wondergirl9847]

Constantine is the most interesting person on the show and he did a decent job with BR. They desperately want a Carrie/Con finale...and I'm sure they'll get it.

From Connie to Carrie anyone? LMAO!

[ontheEdgeof17]

Honey, please tell me you're joking O_o



Guilty Pleasure Alert!

I'm Curtis and I have a love for Constantine problem.




Bottom 3:

-Girlfriend Slapper, Scott
-I can't pick a good song, Nadia
-Either one of the two Sleep Aids....Anwar/Anthony

[GardenStateGirlie]

Guilty Pleasure Alert!

I'm Curtis and I have a love for Constantine problem.




Bottom 3:

-Girlfriend Slapper, Scott
-I can't pick a good song, Nadia
-Either one of the two Sleep Aids....Anwar/Anthony

He reminds me of something out of Cheech and Chong. Seriously. I'm waiting for him to roll a joint onstage.

Agree completely with the bottom three. They're horrible and need to GO!

[WildInTheWind]

This was a pretty good night IMO. Nadia...what is she thinking?! That song?! She sang it well, and she has damn nice legs...but I think she will definalty be in the bottom 3. Rock on Bo for doing Free Bird! That was something I never thought I'd hear on AI. I think it would have been better, but the band kind of F'ed it up. Constantine...I knew there was a reason I liked him from the start! :xoxo: Vonzell....she was great. Carrie was ok. I thought she sang ok, but came off as very awkward and unnatural. Anthony or Scott had Better goooooooooo!! I will be pissed if one of them don't get voted off.

[GypsySorcerer]

This was a pretty good night IMO. Nadia...what is she thinking?! That song?! She sang it well, and she has damn nice legs...but I think she will definalty be in the bottom 3. Rock on Bo for doing Free Bird! That was something I never thought I'd hear on AI. I think it would have been better, but the band kind of F'ed it up. Constantine...I knew there was a reason I liked him from the start! :xoxo: Vonzell....she was great. Carrie was ok. I thought she sang ok, but came off as very awkward and unnatural. Anthony or Scott had Better goooooooooo!! I will be pissed if one of them don't get voted off.

Ditto to everything you said!!!

[WildInTheWind]

Agree completely with the bottom three. They're horrible and need to GO!

Well, Nadia is capable of being really good. She has potential. The other ones just suck. Except Anwar is a great singer, but he's boring.

[heyjupiter678]

He reminds me of something out of Cheech and Chong. Seriously. I'm waiting for him to roll a joint onstage. Hee. <3

I don't know which is worse - the histrionics or the voice. He's horrible.

[Sorceress]

I have a confession to make. I don't hate Constantine anymore. Whew, I'm glad I got that off my chest. :o

My bottom three:
Anthony
Scott
Probably Nadia, because yeah, she can't pick a song to save her life. She certainly looked cute though.

I thought Paula was going to miss her chair the one time she tried to sit down. Her comments have always been on the embarrassing side, but this high/drunk thing--this is really bad. Simon and Randy need to hold an intervention now. :eek: Welcome to the room, Paula.

[AliP]

What! I thought Carrie RAWKED!! She's awesome!


Constantine = cheese.


And Paula, please get some help. Drugs are bad mmmkay.

[amber]

:eek: Welcome to the room, Paula.
And Paula, please get some help. Drugs are bad mmmkay.

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

[amber]

I didn't think that was very neat how Simon directly compared Vonzell with Nadia.
Did Nadia go first? I think I missed it. :(
Ha, Scotts all aggressive about how he was the first ever to rock out. :rolleyes: :laugh:

[ontheEdgeof17]

Ha, Scotts all aggressive about how he was the first ever to rock out. :rolleyes: :laugh:


He's a dick. First to rock out, my ass.

[amber]

I'm so glad Pat B. makes an appearance in this episode. Carrie is not doing too bad! I hear the end sucks, though. :laugh: Simon was right, it was like watching a kitten trying to be a tiger. that's a hard song, though.

[golden braid]

I actually like Constantine now. I didn't think he was that great at first but the last few weeks he's been really kicking butt. I would be kinda cool if Constantine and Bo were the final two but Bo hasn't been that spectacular the last few weeks. I still really like him though.

This week Scott REALLY needs to go. He is so boring. Anthony needs to go to but at least he was better this week.

[Mageboy25]

At least Anthony is a cute bottom boy. He needs to be bent over and done like hes in jail, then maybe he will sing on key then lol.

Carrie SUCKED!!! I cringed through most of her peformance, GAG! Vonzell could have a hit with that song today. Is it me or did anyone feel like eating an icecream cone after that lol? That song just reminds me of the summertime. The wifebeater was pretty good but i cant stand him. He and his fake hip hop accent need to go! Constantine stole the whole show!

At least Nashville Star rocks everyweek. I wanted Tamika Tyler to win though damnit!

[skcin]

Honey, please tell me you're joking O_o

Paula, sit down and snort more coke. Thanks. God, she's annoying.

For a minute - just a minute - I thought you were talking about me! :p I was like "but I don't do..." Then I recalled Miss Abdul's slurring speech & stumbling gait last night & realized you were addressing that Paula. :laugh:

I *heart* Nadia & she did great, but where the hell did she pull that song out of? I've never heard it before. Doesn't bode well for my dear Nadia. :distress:

Anthony, Scott or Anwar can go. :wavey: I really hope Nadia stays cuz I don't want it to only be 2 girls. :( Constantine - shockingly good. :shocked:

[cliffdweller]

I didn't think that was very neat how Simon directly compared Vonzell with Nadia.

Yeah, that was weird wasn't it? I caught that and thought, hmmmm, poor form Simon.

I thought Carrie rocked some of the song, but those parts she took high at the end of the verse were BAD with a capital "B." Why did she do that? It almost ruined the song for me. She can rock out that's for sure, but I'm afraid she has no "rock instinct" so sometimes she screws up the rock songs a bit.

What happened to my Nadia? That song was piss-poor! No offense to Crystal Gayle or anything, but why that song? Not only was it obscure, (which is fine if the song is good) but it was BORING too! I hope this doesn't mean the end for her. :(

[skcin]

Who I think should go:

Scott
or
Anthony

Who I think will go:
Nadia :( :( :(

[SuzeQuze]

I like Constantine now too. :o But I missed last nite's episode, dammit.

[wondergirl9847]

Sesly, I don't understand that mess.

[WildInTheWind]

:distress: :distress: :distress: Wrong. Are we all crazy? Is there something wrong with everyone who posts on this board who thinks Scott and Anthony suck???? I am pissed by the results. Nadia was cool. She was interesting. She wasn't so great last night, but come on now!!! What is wrong with these people!!?? And Bo in the bottom three?!? Ok I just had to get that frustration out.

[GypsySorcerer]

I'm reminded why this show frustrates the hell out of me year after year.

[WildInTheWind]

I'm reminded why this show frustrates the hell out of me year after year.

Yet we keep on watching it week after week... :distress: YOur right...every year I ended up pissed at one time or another.


On another note....I am happy that Bo didn't go though. That may have pushed me over the edge and I'd never have watched it again.

[skcin]

:distress: :distress: :distress: Wrong. Are we all crazy? Is there something wrong with everyone who posts on this board who thinks Scott and Anthony suck???? I am pissed by the results. Nadia was cool. She was interesting. She wasn't so great last night, but come on now!!! What is wrong with these people!!?? And Bo in the bottom three?!? Ok I just had to get that frustration out.

I KNOW! :mad: :mad: :mad:

Nadia was my favorite. :( And now there's too many boys.

[Kelly]

Well that sucked. Scott is still there. .Anthony is still there and Nadia is gone? WRONG WRONG WRONG
I knew we were in for something when Ryan said "You will NOT believe who is in the bottom three" like we were gonna be shocked.
Carrie is my girl and I still like Constantine. *ducks* I like him more in the last two weeks! QUEEN!
Also, Vonzell. She has grown more than any of the other contestants.

[GypsySorcerer]

Yet we keep on watching it week after week... :distress: YOur right...every year I ended up pissed at one time or another.


On another note....I am happy that Bo didn't go though. That may have pushed me over the edge and I'd never have watched it again.

It's an addiction for me. :laugh: However, when that red-headed kid last season stayed on for so long, I was furious. I almost quit watching for good then.

[SuzeQuze]

Yet we keep on watching it week after week... :distress: YOur right...every year I ended up pissed at one time or another.


On another note....I am happy that Bo didn't go though. That may have pushed me over the edge and I'd never have watched it again.

I'm so with you on this. I love Bo. But I also loved Nadia. I am flabberghasted. :eek:

[Lisa1769]

:distress: :distress: :distress: Wrong. Are we all crazy? Is there something wrong with everyone who posts on this board who thinks Scott and Anthony suck???? I am pissed by the results. Nadia was cool. She was interesting. She wasn't so great last night, but come on now!!! What is wrong with these people!!?? And Bo in the bottom three?!? Ok I just had to get that frustration out.


I started out liking Scott in this competition, but this last few weeks his mouth & "tude" are annoying me badly. I was hoping he would be sent home tonight.

I was panicking because I didn't vote for Bo last night. He's been the only one I have voted for. I just got lax and thought aw, he'll be fine. I won't be doing that again.

[Lisa1769]

It's an addiction for me. :laugh: However, when that red-headed kid last season stayed on for so long, I was furious. I almost quit watching for good then.

Mine too...

Oh yea, Jon Stevens, is that the right name, something like that.

[GypsySorcerer]

Mine too...

Oh yea, Jon Stevens, is that the right name, something like that.

Yeah, that was him........ Nice kid, awful singer.

[skcin]

He's putting out a CD of Frank & Dean-type standards this year. :nod:

[mondaymornin1]

I was panicking because I didn't vote for Bo last night. He's been the only one I have voted for. I just got lax and thought aw, he'll be fine. I won't be doing that again.

Nevah, nevah, NEVAH let that happen again. You must vote for Bo...you must vote for Bo...you must vote for Bo... :p

Seriously, could that have actually been REAL? Bo in the bottom three? Puhleeze! I think it's rigged. :rolleyes: *ducks flying objects*

No way Bo was in the bottom three, and every week I turn on my television and Anthony Fedora/Tudora/Morona/whatever is still there. Dude, you may have done a better job last night, but that ain't sayin much! :shrug:

[golden braid]

I need to start voting for Bo. He can't be in the bottom three again, especially with all those other sucky guys left (Anthony and SCOTT.) Anwar is not my favorite either. :mad:

[WildInTheWind]

Bo is cool as hell too. He was just like..whatever...I'm here because of a bet with my mom. That guy rocks. :thumbsup:

[Sorceress]

Dude, you may have done a better job last night, but that ain't sayin much! :shrug:

I didn't think he even really did much better. I've had enough of his orange face. What is wrong with his make-up person?

I'm definitely sad to see Nadia go. I actually agreed with Paula when she said it's a treat to see what Nadia will be wearing each week (or something to that effect). She has looked great so consistently, except for the mohawk week, which wasn't even that bad. Her dress last night was gorgeous. I hope it's not the last we see of her...Hey, if John Stevens can make an album, Nadia certainly can. I might even buy it.

Even though I love Bo's style and like the songs he has chosen in their original form, I think he needs to step outside his Southern Rock mode in order to get the votes he needs. The people who are watching the show must not be big fans of that type of music. It's the only reason I can imagine that he'd be in the bottom three.

[cliffdweller]

Ugh. I am so pissed at the results. Nadia was my favorite and now she's gone. I'm only going to watch the rest of this to see what shenanigans Constantine tries to pull...he may be annoying but he sure is entertaining to watch!!

Scott SO should have gone last night. His attitude and ego are REALLY getting on my nerves.

I'm glad Bo was safe. :thumbsup:

[Livia]

Good article on Nadia - I AGREE!!!

Miami Herald (http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/living/11378965.htm)

"The theme was Songs From the Year You Were Born. Hence, Nadia, born in 1977, the year of Rumours, Linda Ronstadt and Saturday Night Fever chose . . . When I Dream. Come again? Ah, a Crystal Gale recording. Peaked at No. 84 on Billboard's Hot 100. As she explained to host Ryan Seacrest after a lukewarm response from the judges, ``It's a song about dreaming and I've always been a big dreamer.''

If Nadia had to sing a song from that year about dreaming she should have selected Fleetwood Mac's Dreams, a No. 1 hit. It would have showcased the rock edge in her voice and most voters would have recognized it. The obscure Gale song has a forgettable melody and while Nadia sang it with more soul than it deserved, judge Simon Cowell was correct as he sniffed, ``That was the equivalent of musical wallpaper.''

[skcin]

Good article on Nadia - I AGREE!!!

Miami Herald (http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/living/11378965.htm)

"The theme was Songs From the Year You Were Born. Hence, Nadia, born in 1977, the year of Rumours, Linda Ronstadt and Saturday Night Fever chose . . . When I Dream. Come again? Ah, a Crystal Gale recording. Peaked at No. 84 on Billboard's Hot 100. As she explained to host Ryan Seacrest after a lukewarm response from the judges, ``It's a song about dreaming and I've always been a big dreamer.''

If Nadia had to sing a song from that year about dreaming she should have selected Fleetwood Mac's Dreams, a No. 1 hit. It would have showcased the rock edge in her voice and most voters would have recognized it. The obscure Gale song has a forgettable melody and while Nadia sang it with more soul than it deserved, judge Simon Cowell was correct as he sniffed, ``That was the equivalent of musical wallpaper.''

I must admit I thought exactly the same thing - Dreams would have been a great song for her. Of course, I thought it was my Mac bias. :laugh:

[SuzeQuze]

Bo is cool as hell too. He was just like..whatever...I'm here because of a bet with my mom. That guy rocks. :thumbsup:

I <3 him, but he wears a wedding ring, alas. :distress: BO BICE ROCKS!!

[SuzeQuze]

Good article on Nadia - I AGREE!!!

Miami Herald (http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/living/11378965.htm)

"The theme was Songs From the Year You Were Born. Hence, Nadia, born in 1977, the year of Rumours, Linda Ronstadt and Saturday Night Fever chose . . . When I Dream. Come again? Ah, a Crystal Gale recording. Peaked at No. 84 on Billboard's Hot 100. As she explained to host Ryan Seacrest after a lukewarm response from the judges, ``It's a song about dreaming and I've always been a big dreamer.''

If Nadia had to sing a song from that year about dreaming she should have selected Fleetwood Mac's Dreams, a No. 1 hit. It would have showcased the rock edge in her voice and most voters would have recognized it. The obscure Gale song has a forgettable melody and while Nadia sang it with more soul than it deserved, judge Simon Cowell was correct as he sniffed, ``That was the equivalent of musical wallpaper.''

Well duh? 1977, a song about Dreams... Helloooooo??? :laugh: Loves it.

[wondergirl9847]

As she explained to host Ryan Seacrest after a lukewarm response from the judges, ``It's a song about dreaming and I've always been a big dreamer.''

If Nadia had to sing a song from that year about dreaming she should have selected Fleetwood Mac's Dreams, a No. 1 hit.

I've always dreamed dreams of dreaming and I'm a dreamer who dreams.

GAG.

Amen to singing FM...someone DO IT!!!

Nadia is like Tamyra...forgettable...she was a dreamer too. Blergh.

[cliffdweller]

Nadia is like Tamyra...forgettable...

Wrong! She definitely stuck out in this crowd and NOONE sounded like her. And that voice! No way is she forgettable. I'm sorry to see her go.

And yes, she should have sung Dreams. She would have done an incredible job.

[SuzeQuze]

Wrong! She definitely stuck out in this crowd and NOONE sounded like her. And that voice! No way is she forgettable. I'm sorry to see her go.

And yes, she should have sung Dreams. She would have done an incredible job.

The only problem with this song is it really isn't challenging so I'm not sure it would have gotten a great response either.

[GypsySorcerer]

Nadia should not have gone before Scott or Anthony. :rolleyes: Scott is AWFUL. He may be my least favorite contestant ever.

I think Carrie and Constantine will be the final two. Forgive me for saying this, but if you put Carrie's voice and showmanship into a less attractive girl's body, she'd be gone.

[jannieC]

Forgive me for saying this, but if you put Carrie's voice and showmanship into a less attractive girl's body, she'd be gone.

I couldn't agree more. I think Carrie is just...boring. And I almost DIED when my man Bo was in the bottom 3.

[wondergirl9847]

Nadia didn't connect with people...kind of like Tamyra. I don't know what it is, but she doesn't have what people are looking for. :shrug:

Scott sucks and has an ego problem, I think. Anthony is boring. Vonzell is adorable and is great, but she ain't gonna win. Bo is slippin' and better rock the frick out or people will go over to Con's side...they already have been.

I still say Connie is the most interesting and flexible contestant and deserves to win. They desperately want a Connie/Carrie finale.

[SuzeQuze]

Nadia should not have gone before Scott or Anthony. :rolleyes: Scott is AWFUL. He may be my least favorite contestant ever.

I think Carrie and Constantine will be the final two. Forgive me for saying this, but if you put Carrie's voice and showmanship into a less attractive girl's body, she'd be gone.

Carrie's got a confidence problem or something. She just doesn't put it out there. Her voice is phenomenal when she lets go with it. She was my favorite but I think Vonzel has passed her. Vonzel is wonderful.

Constantine is very talented and would be a deserving winner but I would rather see Bo up there. Constantine needs to get real and stop posing.

[amber]

The only problem with this song is it really isn't challenging so I'm not sure it would have gotten a great response either.
Really, she should've done GDW. :nod: That song is more challenging. And she could've rocked it with her throaty little voice. The yowl at the end alone would've gotten her major points. *sigh* she was my fave. At least now I really, really, won't feel like watching it. :D

[Stephanie]

I was just happy Bo wasn't gone last night. He is great, and he lives about 10 minutes from me (doubt he will now--will probably move to california!)

[Livia]

Carrie's got a confidence problem or something. She just doesn't put it out there. Her voice is phenomenal when she lets go with it. She was my favorite but I think Vonzel has passed her. Vonzel is wonderful.

Constantine is very talented and would be a deserving winner but I would rather see Bo up there. Constantine needs to get real and stop posing.

Did you guys not see my post waaay back in this thread about Constantine's stalking and restraining order?? I have a hard time rooting for him - and his double chin is distracting.....I wonder why the smokinggun.com hasn't dug up his dirt yet....

Dreams is on the radio right now! :thumbsup: