Green Manalishi - Mistake?

[HomerMcvie]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTvKaLW5bu8
I was listening on GM on the way home from a gig tonight, and had to play it over and over(no pun intended).
At 1:42 ish... I SWEAR where John plays the rundown from the D, that the C he plays is a mistake. It should be a C#(IMHO), and they just left it on the recording, or didn't notice, or....?
Sorry, that note was driving me crazy(and it's a short trip), that I kept playing it over again and again....
Your thoughts?

[dino]

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTvKaLW5bu8
I was listening on GM on the way home from a gig tonight, and had to play it over and over(no pun intended).
At 1:42 ish... I SWEAR where John plays the rundown from the D, that the C he plays is a mistake. It should be a C#(IMHO), and they just left it on the recording, or didn't notice, or....?
Sorry, that note was driving me crazy(and it's a short trip), that I kept playing it over again and again....
Your thoughts?

Never noticed, but to add to the question, Peter also plays bass on that track iirc.

[THD]

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTvKaLW5bu8
I SWEAR where John plays the rundown from the D, that the C he plays is a mistake. It should be a C#(IMHO), and they just left it on the recording, or didn't notice, or....?

I've just listened to this a few times I don't know what you mean by the run down from D If I'm listening to the right part ,then the harmony is mainly E min leading to C (or C maj 7 )so why would there be a run down which starts on D and secondly ,as the key is E min you wouldn't expect to find a C# at all , surely ?

[THD]

Originally Posted by dino

Never noticed, but to add to the question, Peter also plays bass on that track iirc.

Dino ,does he play instead of McVie or as well as .. ?

[dino]

Originally Posted by THD

Dino ,does he play instead of McVie or as well as .. ?

There are 2 bass parts; they both play.

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by THD

I've just listened to this a few times I don't know what you mean by the run down from D If I'm listening to the right part ,then the harmony is mainly E min leading to C (or C maj 7 )so why would there be a run down which starts on D and secondly ,as the key is E min you wouldn't expect to find a C# at all , surely ?

Again, EXACTLY at 1:42.

It just sounds like it should be a C# instead of a C.

[LesPaul7]

Are you referring to the bass panned right? I believe that is Peter Green on the Fender VI. I believe McVie's bass part to be centered. It sounds in place to me, very gothic or medieval.

On a side note, listening in quality headphones I can really hear some awesome lead work Green played around the edges... I would have bumped that solo up a few db's at the end!