Mirage Face Off: Round 9

[nailatixela]

Straight Back and Eyes Of The World have been voted off!


Vote for your LEAST favorite song from this album. I'll start a new poll within 24 hours with the next round. At the end we will have a winner, and move on to the next album. This is just for the rumours like up (hence being in the rumours section) so we will only be doing albums with all 5 members present. (mick, john, christine, stevie, lindsey) Studio albums only: Fleetwood Mac, Rumours, Tusk, Mirage, Tango In The Night.

Vote for your least favorite song from the Mirage Album



Mirage Album
That's Alright
Gypsy
Hold Me

Previous Winners:
Rhiannon
The Chain
Sisters Of The Moon

[Peestie]

I'm torn between wanting Gypsy or Hold Me to win. If EOTW had made it this far then I'd have had a really, really tough time picking between all three so i guess this lessens my work by a third

[jbrownsjr]

Sonically Hold Me is the best tune on this album...

I remember putting it on my JVC turntable and it sort of punched you in the face with a great wall of sound....

[strandinthewind]

I voted for Hold Me only because I think the other two are just stunning vocals from La Nicks and Gypsy is one of the better group efforts of all time. They were just all spot on on Gypsy.

The thing about Hold Me is that to me it needs another stanza rather than the repeat shuffle - repeat. LB is, however, magnificent on the guitar on this song and CM's words are a delight.

In the end, all three are winners to me.

[wolfontherun]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

I voted for Hold Me only because I think the other two are just stunning vocals from La Nicks and Gypsy is one of the better group efforts of all time. They were just all spot on on Gypsy.

The thing about Hold Me is that to me it needs another stanza rather than the repeat shuffle - repeat. LB is, however, magnificent on the guitar on this song and CM's words are a delight.

In the end, all three are winners to me.

Agree with all you said. They repeat the chorus on Hold Me for far too many times. It kinda goes on and on and on. I do like the interplay between Chris and Linds and have always loved the Put your hand inside of my glove lyric.

Gypsy is a fuller more complete song with a beginning middle and end. And the sentiment alone behind this song makes it outshine anything else on thsi CD.

Oh and RIP Straight Back! Sniff sniff. :-)

[Moz]

Where's the Hold Me love?

[macpai]

Originally Posted by Moz

Where's the Hold Me love?

I always liked Hold Me, but I don't think I really started appreciating it until more recently.
It's such a great visual jukebox now... with Stevie painting Stevie and the camera looking right at the sun for the late guitar wail and Mick and John uncovering all the guitars and Chris singing her little heart out. Oh yeah, Linds looked pretty good in that too.

[strandinthewind]

Hold Me Live



Pretty good - but not the tight album cut, which stuns.

Vocally, it drives me nuts. LB and La Nicks walk all over CM's vocal and that lush harmony on the chorus is, sadly, nonexistent. Again, the end of an era.

[strandinthewind]

Also - who are these people and why wasn't I there for this

[SmileAtYou]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

Also - who are these people and why wasn't I there for this

This is SO funny... it looks like they are having a lot of fun. I watched it about half way through, but the "hold me, hold me, hold me" part of the song is so annoying I just couldn't take it anymore...

I voted for Hold Me

[macpai]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

Also - who are these people and why wasn't I there for this

Great ending!

[jbrownsjr]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

Hold Me Live



Pretty good - but not the tight album cut, which stuns.

Vocally, it drives me nuts. LB and La Nicks walk all over CM's vocal and that lush harmony on the chorus is, sadly, nonexistent. Again, the end of an era.

Strand... what concert is this?... that's actually pretty damn good... CM really does a great job, piano and vocally... those harmonies are tight... especially to do them live...

[strandinthewind]

Originally Posted by jbrownsjr

Strand... what concert is this?... that's actually pretty damn good... CM really does a great job, piano and vocally... those harmonies are tight... especially to do them live...

I have it as Alpine Valley - but it could be mis labeled.

CM is lovely, as usual, on it.

La Nicks is out in the ozone with that vocal - but it works.

LB shines too.

They clearly are having fun on stage.

[jbrownsjr]

Originally Posted by strandinthewind

I have it as Alpine Valley - but it could be mis labeled.

CM is lovely, as usual, on it.

La Nicks is out in the ozone with that vocal - but it works.

LB shines too.

They clearly are having fun on stage.

this is better than any other version i've heard to date....

yeah nicks is doing her mega vibrato.... and it doesn't work here... need straight tone...