Live vs. Album

skcin · #1 06-02-2005, 01:01 PM

I noticed a lot of us were metioning our picks in the "album battles" would be different if we were talking about live versions. I am not going to list every single tune that she's ever done live (solo tours only, btw), but I've picked several to see what people prefer.

Do you prefer the album version of the following songs, or live (whether it be from an official release or a boot or hearing it at a show.)

Outside the Rain
SDMHA
Edge of 17
Stand Back
Blue Denim
Sorcerer
How Still My Love
Talk To Me
Leather & Lace
Rooms on Fire
Alice
Fall From Grace
HAEWAFY
B&tB
If Anyone Falls
Rhiannon
Landslide
GDW
Gypsy
Dreams
Sara

skcin · #2 06-02-2005, 01:05 PM

Outside the Rain - live
SDMHA - album
Edge of 17 - too close to call - probably live
Stand Back - live (more recent versions)
Blue Denim - live
Sorcerer - album
How Still My Love - live
Talk To Me - album
Leather & Lace - live with the girls on harmony
Rooms on Fire - album
Alice - live
Fall From Grace -live
HAEWAFY - live
B&tB - album with the exception of Vegas '05
If Anyone Falls - album
Rhiannon - live 75 or 03/04/05
Landslide - live on The Dance
GDW - live
Gypsy - album
Dreams - album
Sara - album

dudden22 · #3 06-02-2005, 01:07 PM

[QUOTE=skcin]

Outside the Rain - Live
SDMHA - Album
Edge of 17 - Both
Stand Back - Live
Blue Denim - Neither
Sorcerer - Sheryl Crow Edit
How Still My Love - Live
Talk To Me - Neither both are lame
Leather & Lace - Album
Rooms on Fire - Album
Alice - Live
Fall From Grace - Live
HAEWAFY - Live
B&tB - Both
If Anyone Falls - Neither
Rhiannon - Rosebud
Landslide - The Dance
GDW - The Dance
Gypsy - Album
Dreams - Album
Sara - Tusk Doc

Rickypt · #4 06-02-2005, 01:09 PM

Outside the Rain-live
SDMHA-album
Edge of 17-live
Stand Back-a no-brainer, live, live, live
Blue Denim-never heard live, never care to
Sorcerer-album, doesn't work live without high notes
How Still My Love-album
Talk To Me-album
Leather & Lace-album
Rooms on Fire-album
Alice-can't remember live version, but probably prefer album
Fall From Grace-live
HAEWAFY-live
B&tB-album
If Anyone Falls-album
Rhiannon-album
Landslide-album
GDW-album
Gypsy-album
Dreams-album

vermicious knid · #5 06-02-2005, 01:10 PM

I was not a fan of Fall From Grace until I downloaded her performance of it on the Blockbuster awards. I was an instant convert.
Gypsy is strange because it is one of my favorites, but the magic can never be reproduced live.
Alice has that lovely twinkly intro in live versions.

GypsySorcerer · #6 06-02-2005, 01:10 PM

Outside the Rain -- Live
SDMHA -- Album
Edge of 17 -- Either
Stand Back -- Live
Blue Denim -- Album
Sorcerer -- Album
How Still My Love -- Live
Talk To Me -- Neither

Leather & Lace -- Live
Rooms on Fire -- Album
Alice -- Album
Fall From Grace -- Live
HAEWAFY -- Live (esp. Storytellers)
B&tB -- Album
If Anyone Falls -- Live.
Rhiannon -- Live (pre 1979)
Landslide -- Album
GDW -- Live (Dance)
Gypsy -- Album
Dreams -- Album
Sara -- (Live, pre-SYW tour)

ontheEdgeof17 · #7 06-02-2005, 01:13 PM

Outside the Rain live
SDMHA album
Edge of 17 live
Stand Back With FLEETWOOD MAC
Blue Denim Box Set Version
Sorcerer album
How Still My Love live
Talk To Me HOB version...so live
Leather & Lace album
Rooms on Fire album
Alice live

Fall From Grace album
HAEWAFY live
B&tB live
If Anyone Falls album
Rhiannon live...most def
Landslide live
GDW live...a la The Dance
Gypsy extended Box Set version
Dreams live
Sara Cleaning Lady version

chiliD · #8 06-02-2005, 01:16 PM

Outside the Rain- studio
SDMHA-studio
Edge of 17-live
Stand Back-Fleetwood Mac live
Blue Denim-studio
Sorcerer-studio
How Still My Love-studio
Talk To Me-both
Leather & Lace-studio
Rooms on Fire-studio
Alice-neither
Fall From Grace-studio
HAEWAFY-both (especially the 1987/88 Fleetwood Mac tour versions)
B&tB-both
If Anyone Falls-studio
Rhiannon-live Fleetwood Mac 1975-79 only
Landslide-live Fleetwood Mac only
GDW-live with Sheryl Crow's Band
Gypsy-Fleetwood Mac studio only
Dreams- Fleetwood Mac studio only
Sara-live Fleetwood Mac only

CreepingDeath · #9 06-02-2005, 01:21 PM

Outside The Rain- live
SDMHA- album
Edge of 17- both
Stand Back- live
Blue Denim- live
Sorcerer- album
How Still My Love- live
Talk To Me- album
Leather & Lace- live: without Henley
Rooms On Fire- album
Alice- live
Fall From Grace- live
HAEWATFY- live
B&tB- live '05
If Anyone Falls- album
Rhiannon- live
Landslide- live: The Dance
GDW- live
Gypsy- album
Dreams- album
Sara- album

dissention · #10 06-02-2005, 01:27 PM

Outside the Rain- live on the Street Angel tour
SDMHA- studio because it sucks without Petty
Edge of 17- live
Stand Back- Storytellers live
Blue Denim- studio
Sorcerer- STUDIO! When sung live, it's

.
How Still My Love- studio
Talk To Me- both
Leather & Lace- neither
Rooms on Fire- studio
Alice- eh...studio
Fall From Grace- studio
HAEWAFY- neither, I never listen to it
B&tB- live
If Anyone Falls- studio
Rhiannon- Fleetwood Mac live from '75-'79
Landslide- studio
GDW- live during the Rumours tour
Gypsy- STUDIO, it's awful live
Dreams- neither, I'm sick of it
Sara- definitely live

SapphireSister · #11 06-02-2005, 01:28 PM

Outside the Rain So over it, but if I have to chose, live
SDMHA album
Edge of 17 both
Stand Back both
Blue Denim album
Sorcerer album
How Still My Love LIVE (I fell in love with the song when I heard it live)
Talk To Me neither
Leather & Lace album
Rooms on Fire both
Alice live (Another I fell in love with after hearing it live)
Fall From Grace live
HAEWAFY live
B&tB both
If Anyone Falls album
Rhiannon live
Landslide live
GDW live, the Dance
Gypsy album
Dreams live
Sara album

StevieNicksEO17 · #12 06-02-2005, 01:34 PM

Outside the Rain - Live
SDMHA - Album
Edge of 17 - Live
Stand Back - Live
Blue Denim - Album
Sorcerer - Album
How Still My Love - Neither
Talk To Me - Album
Leather & Lace - Album
Rooms on Fire - Both
Alice - Neither
Fall From Grace - Both
HAEWAFY - Live
B&tB - Live
If Anyone Falls - Album
Rhiannon - Both
Landslide - Both
GDW - Live
Gypsy - Both
Dreams - Both
Sara- Both

skcin · #13 06-02-2005, 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vermicious knid

I was not a fan of Fall From Grace until I downloaded her performance of it on the Blockbuster awards. I was an instant convert.
Gypsy is strange because it is one of my favorites, but the magic can never be reproduced live.
Alice has that lovely twinkly intro in live versions.

You read my mind.

David · #14 06-02-2005, 01:43 PM

Outside the Rain - 1983 live
SDMHA - 1985 live
Edge of 17 - 1986 live
Stand Back - 1983 live
Blue Denim - 1994 TV
Sorcerer - don't care
How Still My Love - 1983 live
Talk To Me - 1994 live
Leather & Lace - 1983 live
Rooms on Fire - don't care
Alice - don't care
Fall From Grace - Blockbuster Award TV
HAEWAFY - studio
B&tB - 1983 live
If Anyone Falls - 1983 live
Rhiannon - 1978-1982 live
Landslide - 1982 live & 1990 rehearsal
GDW - studio
Gypsy - studio
Dreams - studio
Sara - studio

JazmenFlowers · #15 06-02-2005, 01:51 PM

Outside the Rain - live
SDMHA - album
Edge of 17 - live
Stand Back - live
Blue Denim - live
Sorcerer - album
How Still My Love - live
Talk To Me - album
Leather & Lace - live (circa early 80s)
Rooms on Fire - album
Alice - album
Fall From Grace - live
HAEWAFY - live
B&tB - live
If Anyone Falls - album
Rhiannon - live
Landslide - live
GDW - live
Gypsy - album
Dreams - album
Sara - live