|
Live vs. Album
I noticed a lot of us were metioning our picks in the "album battles" would be different if we were talking about live versions. I am not going to list every single tune that she's ever done live (solo tours only, btw), but I've picked several to see what people prefer.
Do you prefer the album version of the following songs, or live (whether it be from an official release or a boot or hearing it at a show.) Outside the Rain SDMHA Edge of 17 Stand Back Blue Denim Sorcerer How Still My Love Talk To Me Leather & Lace Rooms on Fire Alice Fall From Grace HAEWAFY B&tB If Anyone Falls Rhiannon Landslide GDW Gypsy Dreams Sara |
Outside the Rain - live
SDMHA - album Edge of 17 - too close to call - probably live Stand Back - live (more recent versions) Blue Denim - live Sorcerer - album How Still My Love - live Talk To Me - album Leather & Lace - live with the girls on harmony Rooms on Fire - album Alice - live Fall From Grace -live HAEWAFY - live B&tB - album with the exception of Vegas '05 If Anyone Falls - album Rhiannon - live 75 or 03/04/05 Landslide - live on The Dance GDW - live Gypsy - album Dreams - album Sara - album |
[QUOTE=skcin]
Outside the Rain - Live SDMHA - Album Edge of 17 - Both Stand Back - Live Blue Denim - Neither Sorcerer - Sheryl Crow Edit How Still My Love - Live Talk To Me - Neither both are lame Leather & Lace - Album Rooms on Fire - Album Alice - Live Fall From Grace - Live HAEWAFY - Live B&tB - Both If Anyone Falls - Neither Rhiannon - Rosebud Landslide - The Dance GDW - The Dance Gypsy - Album Dreams - Album Sara - Tusk Doc |
Outside the Rain-live
SDMHA-album Edge of 17-live Stand Back-a no-brainer, live, live, live Blue Denim-never heard live, never care to Sorcerer-album, doesn't work live without high notes How Still My Love-album Talk To Me-album Leather & Lace-album Rooms on Fire-album Alice-can't remember live version, but probably prefer album Fall From Grace-live HAEWAFY-live B&tB-album If Anyone Falls-album Rhiannon-album Landslide-album GDW-album Gypsy-album Dreams-album |
I was not a fan of Fall From Grace until I downloaded her performance of it on the Blockbuster awards. I was an instant convert.
Gypsy is strange because it is one of my favorites, but the magic can never be reproduced live. Alice has that lovely twinkly intro in live versions. |
Outside the Rain -- Live
SDMHA -- Album Edge of 17 -- Either Stand Back -- Live Blue Denim -- Album Sorcerer -- Album How Still My Love -- Live Talk To Me -- Neither :o Leather & Lace -- Live Rooms on Fire -- Album Alice -- Album Fall From Grace -- Live HAEWAFY -- Live (esp. Storytellers) B&tB -- Album If Anyone Falls -- Live. Rhiannon -- Live (pre 1979) Landslide -- Album GDW -- Live (Dance) Gypsy -- Album Dreams -- Album Sara -- (Live, pre-SYW tour) |
Outside the Rain live
SDMHA album Edge of 17 live Stand Back With FLEETWOOD MAC Blue Denim Box Set Version Sorcerer album How Still My Love live Talk To Me HOB version...so live Leather & Lace album Rooms on Fire album Alice live :shocked: Fall From Grace album HAEWAFY live B&tB live If Anyone Falls album Rhiannon live...most def Landslide live GDW live...a la The Dance Gypsy extended Box Set version Dreams live Sara Cleaning Lady version |
Outside the Rain- studio
SDMHA-studio Edge of 17-live Stand Back-Fleetwood Mac live Blue Denim-studio Sorcerer-studio How Still My Love-studio Talk To Me-both Leather & Lace-studio Rooms on Fire-studio Alice-neither Fall From Grace-studio HAEWAFY-both (especially the 1987/88 Fleetwood Mac tour versions) B&tB-both If Anyone Falls-studio Rhiannon-live Fleetwood Mac 1975-79 only Landslide-live Fleetwood Mac only GDW-live with Sheryl Crow's Band Gypsy-Fleetwood Mac studio only Dreams- Fleetwood Mac studio only Sara-live Fleetwood Mac only |
Outside The Rain- live
SDMHA- album Edge of 17- both Stand Back- live Blue Denim- live Sorcerer- album How Still My Love- live Talk To Me- album Leather & Lace- live: without Henley Rooms On Fire- album Alice- live Fall From Grace- live HAEWATFY- live B&tB- live '05 If Anyone Falls- album Rhiannon- live Landslide- live: The Dance GDW- live Gypsy- album Dreams- album Sara- album |
Outside the Rain- live on the Street Angel tour
SDMHA- studio because it sucks without Petty Edge of 17- live Stand Back- Storytellers live Blue Denim- studio Sorcerer- STUDIO! When sung live, it's :shocked: . How Still My Love- studio Talk To Me- both Leather & Lace- neither Rooms on Fire- studio Alice- eh...studio Fall From Grace- studio HAEWAFY- neither, I never listen to it B&tB- live If Anyone Falls- studio Rhiannon- Fleetwood Mac live from '75-'79 Landslide- studio GDW- live during the Rumours tour Gypsy- STUDIO, it's awful live Dreams- neither, I'm sick of it Sara- definitely live |
Outside the Rain So over it, but if I have to chose, live
SDMHA album Edge of 17 both Stand Back both Blue Denim album Sorcerer album How Still My Love LIVE (I fell in love with the song when I heard it live) Talk To Me neither Leather & Lace album Rooms on Fire both Alice live (Another I fell in love with after hearing it live) Fall From Grace live HAEWAFY live B&tB both If Anyone Falls album Rhiannon live Landslide live GDW live, the Dance Gypsy album Dreams live Sara album |
Outside the Rain - Live
SDMHA - Album Edge of 17 - Live Stand Back - Live Blue Denim - Album Sorcerer - Album How Still My Love - Neither Talk To Me - Album Leather & Lace - Album Rooms on Fire - Both Alice - Neither Fall From Grace - Both HAEWAFY - Live B&tB - Live If Anyone Falls - Album Rhiannon - Both Landslide - Both GDW - Live Gypsy - Both Dreams - Both Sara- Both |
Quote:
|
Outside the Rain - 1983 live
SDMHA - 1985 live Edge of 17 - 1986 live Stand Back - 1983 live Blue Denim - 1994 TV Sorcerer - don't care How Still My Love - 1983 live Talk To Me - 1994 live Leather & Lace - 1983 live Rooms on Fire - don't care Alice - don't care Fall From Grace - Blockbuster Award TV HAEWAFY - studio B&tB - 1983 live If Anyone Falls - 1983 live Rhiannon - 1978-1982 live Landslide - 1982 live & 1990 rehearsal GDW - studio Gypsy - studio Dreams - studio Sara - studio |
Outside the Rain - live
SDMHA - album Edge of 17 - live Stand Back - live Blue Denim - live Sorcerer - album How Still My Love - live Talk To Me - album Leather & Lace - live (circa early 80s) Rooms on Fire - album Alice - album Fall From Grace - live HAEWAFY - live B&tB - live If Anyone Falls - album Rhiannon - live Landslide - live GDW - live Gypsy - album Dreams - album Sara - live |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:54 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved