Favorite Song From the "Buckingham Nicks" Album

[WalkAThinLine.]

Originally Posted by greendaze5

There was actually a 1977 disco version of 'Don't Let Me Down Again' by Canadian singer Shirley Eikhard.

Interestingly, Shirley Eikhard also covered "Say You Love Me", which was actually released as a single in Canada before the original recording by Fleetwood Mac. At one point, both versions were actively competing with each other on the charts. On the August 28, 1976 chart, Fleetwood Mac's version jumped up from #69 to #55, surpassing Eikhard's version in the process, which dropped from #45 to #58.

Fleetwood Mac's "Say You Love Me" performed considerably worse in Canada compared to the other singles from the White Album ("Over My Head: peak position of #9; "Rhiannon": peak position of #4; "Say You Love Me": peak position of #29). It's pretty likely that the moderate chart success of Eikhard's version (peaked at #34) tempered the chart run of Fleetwood Mac's original.

[Macfan4life]

Originally Posted by WalkAThinLine.

Interestingly, Shirley Eikhard also covered "Say You Love Me", which was actually released as a single in Canada before the original recording by Fleetwood Mac. At one point, both versions were actively competing with each other on the charts. On the August 28, 1976 chart, Fleetwood Mac's version jumped up from #69 to #55, surpassing Eikhard's version in the process, which dropped from #45 to #58.

Fleetwood Mac's "Say You Love Me" performed considerably worse in Canada compared to the other singles from the White Album ("Over My Head: peak position of #9; "Rhiannon": peak position of #4; "Say You Love Me": peak position of #29). It's pretty likely that the moderate chart success of Eikhard's version (peaked at #34) tempered the chart run of Fleetwood Mac's original.

Wow. Wait. Say You Love Me was covered and released by another artist before Fleetwood Mac? How did that happen?
Anyway here it is. Not too shabby.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V31Xim1Im5A

[WalkAThinLine.]

Originally Posted by Macfan4life

Wow. Wait. Say You Love Me was covered and released by another artist before Fleetwood Mac? How did that happen?
Anyway here it is. Not too shabby.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V31Xim1Im5A

Fleetwood Mac's "Say You Love Me" had already been on the White Album for roughly one year before it was released as a single.

Timeline:
July 1975: The White Album is released, which includes "Say You Love Me"

June 1976: Eikhard's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

July 1976: Fleetwood Mac's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

[aleuzzi]

Originally Posted by WalkAThinLine.

Fleetwood Mac's "Say You Love Me" had already been on the White Album for roughly one year before it was released as a single.

Timeline:
July 1975: The White Album is released, which includes "Say You Love Me"

June 1976: Eikhard's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

July 1976: Fleetwood Mac's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

And it wasn’t covered by just anyone. Shirley Eikhard is a great songwriter herself. She is best known for penning “Something to Talk About,” which Bonnie Raitt made famous in the early 90s.

[Villavic]

Originally Posted by WalkAThinLine.

Timeline:
July 1975: The White Album is released, which includes "Say You Love Me"

June 1976: Eikhard's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

July 1976: Fleetwood Mac's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

I was going to ask How did the band allow that? I mean, at that time Fleetwood Mac was re emerging as a popular band so any "interference" could have been harmful for their popularity. There have been better covers (specially according to the public) than the original. Close to You, What's Love Got To Do It, Nothing Compares 2 U, etc.

On the other hand, it could help to impulse the band songs, but it was a risky move. Anyway, my doubt was, she needed the band permission, didn't she? Or just the record company? Or just Christine (and BN in the case of DLMDA)?

[BigAl84]

Originally Posted by WalkAThinLine.

Fleetwood Mac's "Say You Love Me" had already been on the White Album for roughly one year before it was released as a single.

Timeline:
July 1975: The White Album is released, which includes "Say You Love Me"

June 1976: Eikhard's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

July 1976: Fleetwood Mac's version begins to appear on the Singles Chart

How the heck have I have a been a fan of this band for 25 years (a good 15 of those years practically a fanatic!) and i'm just learning about this now. Mind blown.