TISL vs. IYD Track by Track BONUS ROUND

[RavenOfRhiannon]

So we've done all the album tracks, let's do one last round...

[KarmaContestant]

The TISL outtake is *so* much better.

[StevieNicksfann]

What are the differences would you say?

[whitewingdove]

Not a huge fan of the song myself, but i prefer TISL version over IYD by far.

[whitewingdove]

Originally Posted by StevieNicksfann

What are the differences would you say?

Well for one, in TISL her voice is in much better condition, if you will.

[ShangriLaTroubl]

There are parts that I like about the IYD version, but I think it's a little over produced.

[Christopher]

There are parts I like about each version. For instance the chorus feels more dymanic and punchier on the IYD version, plus I like the little mandolin breakdown part. But the verses and original lyrics on the TISL version are soooo much better. Overall I prefer the TISL version and it's a shame TMMS wasn't dumped in favor of this originally.

[KarmaContestant]

Originally Posted by Christopher

For instance the chorus feels more dymanic and punchier on the IYD version, plus I like the little madolin part.

Yes, exactly.

I used to skip over the IYD version fairly regularly, but I've reached a point where it no longer rubs me the wrong way.