Why have "Tusk" and "So Afraid" gotten the old man treatment?

[chiliD]

Originally Posted by mylittledemon

So Afraid is one of my all time favourites and I didn't like the lower key at first. What I wish is that they'd play the song (if they must) in the lower key but as they did on The Dance tour with Christine's keys and that bluesy intro.

He HAD to lower the key, he couldn't sing it in Fm anymore and obviously, he couldn't sing it in the Gm it originally was recorded in. Nothing wrong with changing keys.

Nobody's complained about "Big Love" being a whole step lower than The Dance version

Heck, "Landslide" is about 5 half steps lower these days than the original recording.