Did a Reporter Have a Stroke on TV?

[HejiraNYC]

New York Times
February 15, 2011
http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/0...tv/?ref=health

Tara Parker-Pope

It began as a typical segment on the local news — a beaming television journalist preparing for a live report from the Grammy Awards. But as Serene Branson, a Los Angeles CBS reporter, began to speak, she uttered a few real words that turned into a stream of gibberish.

The video quickly went viral as bloggers mocked her slurred words and strange speech. “Somebody call an exorcist,” joked the celebrity blogger Perez Hilton. (He later removed the post.)

But now it appears that the Emmy-nominated Ms. Branson had suffered a stroke or related health problem that impaired her ability to speak.

“What a terrifying event,” said Dr. Daniel Labovitz, assistant professor of neurology at Einstein School of Medicine and attending stroke neurologist at Montefiore Medical Center in the Bronx. “I very strongly suspect this was a stroke or transient ischemic attack.”

Ischemic strokes and T.I.A.’s are caused when a blood clot blocks blood flow to part of the brain. In the case of T.I.A., the blockage clears before permanent damage occurs, and the patient may quickly return to normal.

He said her speech problem suggests she had a blockage in the part of the brain that involves speech comprehension, but not speech production. Her speech pattern was characteristic of a condition called Wernicke aphasia. “The patient is pretty much unaware of the problem they’re having, and they are speaking fluently, with normal musicality of speech, but the words that come out are completely wrong,” he said. “Everything that’s coming out is unintelligible even though it sounds like language.”

Dr. Labovitz noted that because he doesn’t know Ms. Branson’s full medical history, he can’t be certain of her diagnosis, but the video is strongly suggestive of a stroke or T.I.A. He said it is highly unusual for such a problem to be captured on video. “This is more information than I’m usually going to get when someone has had a T.I.A.,” he added.

“I don’t think we saw the stroke start,” he said. “I think it may have begun before the camera started rolling. She was standing there smiling, completely unaware there was a problem until she attempted to speak, and even then she was not really aware she was making no sense because she kept talking.”

Ms. Branson couldn’t be reached, and KCBS officials didn’t return phone calls. The station issued a statement about Ms. Branson, saying she had experienced “some health-related problems” during the newscast and was examined by paramedics immediately. The station said her vital signs were normal, she was not hospitalized and a colleague gave her a ride home.

“And while Serene says she is feeling better today, she wants us to know she followed up with a visit to the doctor for some medical tests,” the statement said.

Dr. Labovitz said he was “shocked” to hear Ms. Branson went home, because anyone displaying strokelike symptoms should go to the hospital immediately. He said it’s possible that the symptoms disappeared quickly, and that given her young age and apparent good health, the event no longer seemed like an emergency after it was over.

“That’s exactly the wrong thing,” he said. “Even if it wasn’t a stroke, you need to get it checked out. It’s a tremendous opportunity for her to talk about what stroke is and what T.I.A. is, and what to do. You don’t go home. This is a 911 scenario. Her risk of stroke for the first few days after an event like that is extremely high.”

Dr. Labovitz said the kind of aphasia Ms. Branson displayed is less common than other stroke symptoms like weakness on one side, vision loss or balance problems, but it’s not rare either. He said he hopes Ms. Branson will eventually talk about the experience to get the message out about how to recognize and respond to strokelike symptoms.

“The nature of this kind of injury is that the patient is the last to know there is a problem,” he said. “I would guess that until she saw the video she wasn’t aware of how bad it was. You can only feel for her. She’s got a real chance here to get a message out.”

[estranged4life]

and unlike some people online, I didn't laugh at her being I had 'similar issues' in the past few years with my health...Once while in front of my physician, which led to a CT scan which showed some brain damage in my right temporal lobe (Not from the arachnoid cyst, but from what two separate neurologists had called "recent strokes")

Had another one of those "strokes" back in November 2008 as I was driving East-bound on I-40 at 70MPH, and just lucked out that I was at an area near Geary, OK. where there is a picnic area for me to pull off the highway...and call for help.

Even a small TIA can cause brain cells to die, and can be a sign that something worse could be coming (ie massive stroke).

I wish her the best and hope she gets to a neurologist to prevent any further health issues.

[TerraRhiannon]

Awh I feel so bad for her, especially after being mocked by Perez. That's down right cruel.. I wanted to cry not laugh at her when I watched it. Here's to hoping she's alright.

[DefDumbandBlond]

Yeah that was definitely not normal, hopefully she gets things checked out.

[jannieC]

I didn't realize she was being made fun of- that is appalling. I watched the video on the news this morning and felt horrible for this woman. She must have been so scared. Hope she takes care of herself.

[Lindsfan]

Originally Posted by jannieC

I didn't realize she was being made fun of- that is appalling. I watched the video on the news this morning and felt horrible for this woman. She must have been so scared. Hope she takes care of herself.

Jannie, please check your PMs...not related to this topic, but important - thanks.

[Enchanted_Stevi]

i saw this on the news tonight....that is too bad for her!!! I hope everything is okay and she gets everything figured out!!! That must be really embarassing

[Musicman408]

Oh, I hope she's alright! That's so scary. I wish her the best! What a beautiful young woman.

[cristochango]

I like how she tries to keep her composure during it.. I thought I heard a "Back to you" trying to get the camera to cut back.

She sounds scared though during it :/

[Meowi]

This brings up the classic battle between morality and entertainment.
A lot of people, upon seeing a disabled or sick person will mock them - does that mean it is their fault? As humans it is natural to laugh at something that seems strange or different in human ability. Sure, it may offensive to the person of question, but I still put the question up all the time.

[Nico]

Originally Posted by Meowi

This brings up the classic battle between morality and entertainment.
A lot of people, upon seeing a disabled or sick person will mock them - does that mean it is their fault? As humans it is natural to laugh at something that seems strange or different in human ability. Sure, it may offensive to the person of question, but I still put the question up all the time.

With the sudden onset of popular blogs and other related sites, people now have the ability to mask themselves in the anonymity of a user name and say the most obscene things about anything- whether they be the handicapped, the elderly, little children, etc. It's very sick, but it's become a massive trend and you can see glimpses of such horrible behavior in any of those popular popular blog websites like Perez, Dlisted, ONTD, or The Superficial. My friend's job requires her to look through these types of sites and she's told me some of the stuff people say about others...pretty disturbing. What is wrong with people?

Instead of trying to be a more civilized society with actual compassion for people who may be going through something traumatic (like the lady above) they choose to laugh and ridicule people for no good reason. Puzzling and very sad.

[LukeA]

I already posted this video in the Grammy thread (like, over a day ago), but guess we needed a separate thread to suss this out?

IMO, she was aware she was having difficulty speaking. She seemed more flustered than anything else.

[jannieC]

Originally Posted by LukeA

I already posted this video in the Grammy thread (like, over a day ago), but guess we needed a separate thread to suss this out?

IMO, she was aware she was having difficulty speaking. She seemed more flustered than anything else.

Since many wouldn't know that this journalist was reporting at the Grammys, I can see the idea behind a separate thread. Not everyone is interested in the Gramnys, but may want to weigh in on this.

I still find it appalling that people would make fun of this woman. Is it because she's pretty? So disturbing. But then again, I find a lot of things disturbing.

[GODDESS6]

Originally Posted by jannieC

I didn't realize she was being made fun of- that is appalling. I watched the video on the news this morning and felt horrible for this woman. She must have been so scared. Hope she takes care of herself.

there were some real cruel comments out there, made me sick~ god bless her~

[Ghost_Tracker]

There's now a little more information;
her tv station (KCBS) said that she did
go to the doctor and had some tests done.

i.m.o., the EMT's screwed up royally.
They should have gotten her to the hospital
immediately.

There's some speculation from some physicians that she might not
have actually had a stroke or a TIA, it might have been "aphasia"
(a problem with language) due to a heart condition or something
along those lines.