What's wrong with this picture?

[catinthedark]

I get the Google Alerts everyday for Stevie and FM (as I'm sure many of you guys do). This article was in today's San Fran Chronicle.

SHORELINE STEALS SHOW FROM NICKS
- Joel Selvin
Sunday, July 24, 2005



Rock music got a somewhat sorry introduction to Bill Graham's spanking-new Shoreline Amphitheatre on Monday by Stevie Nicks, but the miracle of Mountain View is a promising gift to South Bay music fans.

Performing under the tent top that someone has said looks like the world's biggest brassiere, Nicks sounded as if she had ground off the top half of her vocal range, growling and rasping her way through a listless and ineffective performance.

The former lead vocalist of Fleetwood Mac still boasts an enormously loyal following, more than 10,000 strong Monday, a crowd littered with young women dressed in quirky layers of lace like Nicks. She clearly strikes a heartfelt chord with her fans.

But to her more discriminating admirers, what a disappointment the show must have been. Three background vocalists covered the high notes for Nicks, who seems to have lost power as well as range in her singing.

She treated the crowd to a program of pop-rock specialities from her solo albums, interspersing a few oldies from the big Mac, but emphasizing selections from her latest LP, which spawned the big hit, "I Can't Wait."

Her crack band functioned flawlessly, if a bit heavily on the bottom end of the massive sound, wrapping her vocals in an alternately billowing and thunderous cloud.

Ever the eccentric diva, Nicks danced absentmindedly between vocals, dropping into deep knee bends and skipping off the stage for frequent costume changes. She gushed about her early days in the South Bay with former paramour and Mac associate Lindsey Buckingham. ("We opened for everybody.") The precious poetic content of her lyrics read more like Hallmark than Dylan Thomas, but the romantic soap operas she spins obviously find their mark with her audience.

Opening the show was Peter Frampton, hard on the comeback trail. The audience called him back for an encore after his inevitable extended version of "Do You Feel Like I Do," which took up almost an entire side of his 1976 supersmash album, "Frampton Comes Alive."

That year, he headlined Day on the Green concerts at the Oakland Stadium, supported by Fleetwood Mac.

It is rather amazing that both Frampton and Nicks are still around 10 years later, regardless of the condition they're in.

The real star of show was the amphitheater itself, opened only two weeks ago. Sculpted out of a former garbage dump, the steeply banked grass and concrete arena is surrounded by cloth windbreaks, the stage covered by the giant tent top hoisted on two poles.

Sound quality throughout the facility appeared excellent, and the bowl is surprisingly well protected from the winds sweeping the area. Traffic entering the amphitheater from the nearby freeway moved swiftly into the dirt parking lot a half-hour before show time.

Too bad the Nicks show proved so lame, but the concertgoers had no problem enjoying the spacious grounds and the open-air comfort of Graham's new amphitheater, sure to be a major cultural blessing to the South Bay for years to come.

This review was published in The Chronicle on July 16, 1986.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alrighty then. What exactly is the use of a newspaper publishing nearly 20 year old reviews? I don't get it. For a not so on-the-ball fan, they might read the first few paragraphs and think, oh, that Stevie Nicks put on a lame show the other night. So glad we didn't go. It's only when you get to the "I Can't Wait" part that a knowledgable fan would clue in. (The Peter Frampton then gives it away).

But seriously! WTF??? Can someone in San Fran clue me in? Does this paper do this regularly?

[xxxmx]

Originally Posted by catinthedark

But seriously! WTF??? Can someone in San Fran clue me in? Does this paper do this regularly?

i have no clue what's up with this being put up, but i was two paragraphs in before i finally had to skip to the bottom. i've never been to CA so i don't really know the lay of the land, i only know that she's out there. well as soon as i got to the "growling and rasping her way through a listless and ineffective performance" i knew it wasn't right.

no idea?

[DrummerDeanna]

That is weird - I was totally lost myself until the "I Can't Wait" graff too - that is weird. Hopefully someone there can shed some light on what that's all about

[Johnny Stew]

Wow, if they thought she was listless in 1986....

[StevieNicksEO17]

What the heck? This review is wayyy off... Nothing like the others!

[saradorna]

Originally Posted by StevieNicksEO17

What the heck? This review is wayyy off... Nothing like the others!

It's soooo wayyy off that its from almost 20 years ago.

The media has become so lazy but this just took the price. Dumbasses!!!

Isabel

[MacMan]

Someone in SF said it was printed in the paper along side the OTHER Chronicle article about Stevie which there is a thread going on already. A little odd given that there is no intro to say this is a vintage review.... Maybe in the print form there is.

[nwestohiofan]

....wtf? Wtf???

[Somajoseph]

Originally Posted by nwestohiofan

....wtf? Wtf???

Joel Selvin has always had a love/hate relationship when it comes to Stevie Nicks.
I was at Stevie's Shoreline concert back in 86, and I dont remember it being as bad as this review claims it was. In fact, I was in the last couple of rows of the reserved seating section, and what I do remember, is that everyone was standing up having a great time. It was the last gasp of her cocaine fuled performances, and I remember loving it.!

Joseph

[Serrart]

I don't mind reading old reviews (even negative), but they should have put the original date at the top. This way those who know she's on tour could be misled, IMO.

Romy

[sarafield]

Oh sheesh, some people are so quick to jump all over the press! (Sorry, I work at a paper.)

The Sunday Datebook Editor explains it:
"Don's spoof pretty much says it all about the Pink section, but here's my shtick: Lots of great stuff to read today, including Bill Picture on a hip new art gallery (Page 21) and the divine Stevie Nicks (Page 40), who plays the Chronicle Pavilion on Saturday. (Stevie was the opening rock act for Shoreline Amphitheatre in 1986 -- Joel Selvin's review is our Chronicle Classic today, on Page 15. Don't read it if you're Stevie Nicks!)."

[DeeGeMe]

Well Bill Graham's been dead for quite awhile now so uhm--unless he's figured out how to come back from the grave. . . I don't think he's built a new venue! My big clue came in line one that this was a dated and/or bogus article!

[catinthedark]

Originally Posted by sarafield

Oh sheesh, some people are so quick to jump all over the press! (Sorry, I work at a paper.)

The Sunday Datebook Editor explains it:
"Don's spoof pretty much says it all about the Pink section, but here's my shtick: Lots of great stuff to read today, including Bill Picture on a hip new art gallery (Page 21) and the divine Stevie Nicks (Page 40), who plays the Chronicle Pavilion on Saturday. (Stevie was the opening rock act for Shoreline Amphitheatre in 1986 -- Joel Selvin's review is our Chronicle Classic today, on Page 15. Don't read it if you're Stevie Nicks!)."

Don't worry - it wasn't personal. I've worked for the press for 13 years. But in the online version, there was no explanation. Thus, my question... if someone in San Fran could explain it. So, thanks! That explains it.

[sarafield]

Originally Posted by catinthedark

Don't worry - it wasn't personal. I've worked for the press for 13 years. But in the online version, there was no explanation. Thus, my question... if someone in San Fran could explain it. So, thanks! That explains it.

Oh yes! I didn't think the original question was anti-press... just so ya know.