Two More Lists

[darklinensuit]

What are Stevie's happiest and saddest songs?

My picks:

Happiest:
1) Say You Will
2) Think About It
3) Cathouse Blues (At least playful if not happy)

Saddest:
1) Storms
2) Silver Springs
3) Beautiful Child
4) Love Is


- Jake

[skcin]

I love all of your choices, I'll try to pick different songs:


Happiest:

I Don't Wanna Know
Seven Wonders
That's Alright

Saddest:

Rose Garden
Beauty & the Beast
POTU (the version on the remastered Rumours bonus disc)

[laurie816]

Hmm...let's see if I could pick even more different ones

Happy:

Juliet
Angel
Rhiannon
Fireflies

Sad:

Nightbird
Goodbye Baby
I Miss You
Sable On Blond

[dissention]

Happiest:

• Say You Will
• Destiny Rules
• Rooms On Fire
• Every Day
• Gate & Garden

Saddest:

• Storms (reads like a suicide note)
• Trouble In Shangri-La
• Doing the Best That I Can
• Space Needle
• Sable On Blonde

[darklinensuit]

Originally Posted by skcin

I love all of your choices, I'll try to pick different songs:


Happiest:

I Don't Wanna Know
Seven Wonders
That's Alright

Saddest:

Rose Garden
Beauty & the Beast
POTU (the version on the remastered Rumours bonus disc)

I agree with all of your saddest, especially POTU. Let's throw in Mistaken Love as well.

None of your happy choices seem happy to me. They're all about reflecting on break-ups in a bittersweet way, IMO.

- Jake

[darklinensuit]

Originally Posted by laurie816

Hmm...let's see if I could pick even more different ones

Happy:

Juliet
Angel
Rhiannon
Fireflies

Sad:

Nightbird
Goodbye Baby
I Miss You
Sable On Blond

Again, I can see Juliet as happy, but none of the others seem very happy to me.
And IMO Nightbird doesn't strike me as very sad in relation to the tragedy of some of Stevie's songs. Can you explain your picks?

- Jake

[darklinensuit]

Originally Posted by dissention

Happiest:

• Say You Will
• Destiny Rules
• Rooms On Fire
• Every Day
• Gate & Garden

Saddest:

• Storms (reads like a suicide note)
• Trouble In Shangri-La
• Doing the Best That I Can
• Space Needle
• Sable On Blonde

Destiny Rules does not sound happy to me. Can you explain the pick?
I agree about Storms. When I first heard it, I thought the "another test" line was "a matter of death."

- Jake

[cliffdweller]

This is hard because a lot of times Stevies lyrics don't match the mood of her songs or vice versa. So with that in mind...

Happiest:
Think About It
Angel
I Don't Wanna Know (it's upbeat, as for the lyrics, they're not too serious either)
Seven Wonders
SYW
Enchanted

Saddest:
Storms
Beauty and The Beast
Goodbye Baby
Belladonna
How Still My Love
Nightbird (because it's all about Robin's death)

[dissention]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

Destiny Rules does not sound happy to me. Can you explain the pick?

She's singing about being with her love for eternity in another life, because her destiny right now doesn't have it in the cards. When they were together in a beautiful setting, however, it was bliss and nothing else mattered. Even though they're no longer on the same path as each other, neither regrets what they had because it was beautiful while it lasted; even though it's over, they still have the memories. Sounds happy to moi.

Just look at the lyrics:

Maybe we were together in another life
Maybe we are together in a parallel universe
Maybe our paths are not supposed to cross twice
Maybe your arms are not supposed to go around me

When I see you again,
As I always do
It appears to me that
Destiny rules
And the spirits are ruthless with the paths they choose
It's not being together,
It's just following the rules
No one's a fool...

Just following the rules... no one's a fool
Just following the rules... no one's a fool
Just following the rules... no one's a fool
No one's a fool...

[dissention]

Originally Posted by cliffdweller

Goodbye Baby

I never considred this a sad song. If anything, it's a very hopeful song. She's saying that she wishes someone's (let's not get into who that someone is ) heart isn't broken because she'll be in their company again and forever eventually.

[skcin]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

I agree with all of your saddest, especially POTU. Let's throw in Mistaken Love as well.

None of your happy choices seem happy to me. They're all about reflecting on break-ups in a bittersweet way, IMO.

- Jake

Screw you, Jake.

Just kidding. I guess it's the music & delivery more than the actual lyrics that make me feel happy:

IDWK: her vocal sounds really happy to me, like she's smiling while she's singing them. Plus, there's CLAPPING, for God's sake, CLAPPING! (sorry, I'm a sucker for clapping. I also clap along to Jack & Diane and Take the Money & Run.)

SW: It sounds like she's remembering a great time in her life - like when you first meet someone & you get those butterflies, it's so exciting. And the video is great, love LB's antics & expressions.

That's Alright: Sounds pretty hopeful to me - "I hope you find a love, your own designs of love" Also empowering "I'm through waiting for you" and "I decided yesterday that I would leave you, I'm alright"

Paula

[cliffdweller]

Originally Posted by dissention

I never considred this a sad song. If anything, it's a very hopeful song. She's saying that she wishes someone's (let's not get into who that someone is ) heart isn't broken because she'll be in their company again and forever eventually.

Yeah, but "Don't take me to the tower/and take my child away" just gets me every time. I guess it's hopeful by the end, but the first part of that song is a real tear-jerker.

I guess it could be read either way.

[xdreamsunwindx]

Happy Songs-

Say You Will
Enchanted
Everyday
Angel
Juliet
Violet and Blue (not for the lyrics, but for the beat)

Sad Songs-

Gypsy (sadness covered up by a pop beat)
Doing the Best I Can
Storms
Beautiful Child
Silver Springs
The Highway Man
Goodbye Baby
I Miss You
Sleeping Angel

-Kate

[TheBlueLamp]

Happiest:
Enchanted
If I Were You
If Anyone Falls
Sister Honey

Saddest:
Destiny
When I See You Again
Battle Of The Dragon
Kick It
Sara

I would have added Outside the Rain to the sad list but "Love is a word some entertain, If you find it, You have won the game" seems too happy/hopeful to make OTR one of the saddest.

Nick

[terrivac]

Happiest:
1. Stand Back
2. Gypsy

Saddest:
1. Has Anyone Ever Written Anything For You
2. Landslide

Terri