Which Peacekeeper is best? - Page 2

Cammie · #16 03-25-2004, 12:21 AM

Definitely the original ACLU Version! It has
a message and a punch which is masculine
and makes the whole tune more meaningful!!!
COME has Great Guitar work...a Guy Song!Sky

dissention · #17 03-25-2004, 12:10 PM

Solo. By far.

I think the SYW version is the only Lindsey song that has been ruined by Stevie's vocals. For some reason, I find them quite grating and WAY too loud. In some spots, she's louder and more up front in the mix than Lindsey. The only part that I enjoy with her vocals is the verse "You know all of our friends are Gods," even though I like it even more on the solo version. I wish she hadn't been put on that song.

It was slowed down way too much for SYW and it really hindered the song. It doesn't have nearly the same punch and kick that it had on the ACLU version.

Cristian · #18 03-25-2004, 12:52 PM

The solo Lindsey version, always. It has a lot of more identity. I still like the SYW version anyway.

Song of the moment - Welcome To The Room... Sara

CarneVaca · #19 03-25-2004, 01:30 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by dissention
I think the SYW version is the only Lindsey song that has been ruined by Stevie's vocals. For some reason, I find them quite grating and WAY too loud. In some spots, she's louder and more up front in the mix than Lindsey.

Yes. I was quite disappointed when I first heard it. Really, it made me stop listening to a song that I had fallen in love with. Now I go back to the solo version when I'm in the mood for Peacekeeper.

It would have been great if they had just added the FM rhythm section to the song and done some Stevie harmonies way in the background on the chorus.

No one's picked the Louisville slugger yet, eh?

dissention · #20 03-25-2004, 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by CarneVaca
Yes. I was quite disappointed when I first heard it. Really, it made me stop listening to a song that I had fallen in love with. Now I go back to the solo version when I'm in the mood for Peacekeeper.

It would have been great if they had just added the FM rhythm section to the song and done some Stevie harmonies way in the background on the chorus.

Exactly. If they had kept her harmony as low as it is on SYHA, it would have been perfect and tolerable.

wildangel · #21 03-25-2004, 05:13 PM

I like stevie on it but I like the solo version better, the mac version has too many wooo ooh oooh hoos

I also think that Lindsey is singing way too loud on EFO during the chorus ( the I do have him part especially

) and should be taken off the song or mixed into the background more