What song is the biggest suprise for you on IYD, in a good or bad way?

[Sleepless-Child]

You do really love Everybody Loves You, don't you? ).
Hmm, probably Italian Summer. there's something so haunting about this song, i can't even explain it. It might not be my favorite track (but, for example, i'm not surprised by Wide Sargasso Sea or Moonlight because i just knew they were going to be epic), but i thought it will be one more painful ballad : i don't like HAEWAFY, the Highwayman, Love is, and even BATB at times, but this...this, my friend, is brilliant.

I can't even believe that Stevie wanted to retire after TISL, saying that she couldn't do anything better...