first critical review of ITD - Page 5

saintvox · #61 04-21-2011, 07:44 PM

I thought I found a leak,

But then I clicked it and was another survey thing disguised as a torrent.
And it was new. But it's gotta get out there soon.

Jondalar · #62 04-21-2011, 07:47 PM

Man, this album is under wraps.

saintvox · #63 04-21-2011, 07:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Man, this album is under wraps.

I know. There's no way it's not gonna leak. Every album leaks.

It's got to.

used karma · #64 04-21-2011, 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by saintvox

I know. There's no way it's not gonna leak. Every album leaks.

It's got to.

Jennifer Lopez has an album coming out on the same day, and hers hasn't leaked either. I think we'll have it by the middle of next week.

saintvox · #65 04-21-2011, 08:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by used karma

Jennifer Lopez has an album coming out on the same day, and hers hasn't leaked either. I think we'll have it by the middle of next week.

Yeah but it's out next week in Europe.

We should have it by now!

used karma · #66 04-21-2011, 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by saintvox

Yeah but it's out next week in Europe.

We should have it by now!

Whens it out in Europe? What date?

saintvox · #67 04-21-2011, 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by used karma

Whens it out in Europe? What date?

I thought April 29th is what people were saying but now I'm seeing other dates.

Did it get pushed back? I'll cry. D:

jrpjr · #68 04-21-2011, 09:32 PM

i read this persons review and i pray to god its not true...BUT "secret love" ...i bet will fall off the charts very soon...i think its a crappy first single for a "first album in 10 years" "comeback"..and "cheaper than free"..really like but it lacks staying power..and the order of track list??? opens w/"secret love" and closes w/"cheaper than free????" thats just weird..I LOVE THE THE 4 TRACKS ON THE ALBUM PREVIEW...why they didnt open the album w/"Moonlight" and THAT not the first single is BEYOOOOND me....sounds like "italian summer" would b a beautiful and typical stevie nicks record closer..I hope this is a good album...but i wont b surprised if its not

tabruns · #69 04-21-2011, 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrpjr

i read this persons review and i pray to god its not true...BUT "secret love" ...i bet will fall off the charts very soon...i think its a crappy first single for a "first album in 10 years" "comeback"..and "cheaper than free"..really like but it lacks staying power..and the order of track list??? opens w/"secret love" and closes w/"cheaper than free????" thats just weird..I LOVE THE THE 4 TRACKS ON THE ALBUM PREVIEW...why they didnt open the album w/"Moonlight" and THAT not the first single is BEYOOOOND me....sounds like "italian summer" would b a beautiful and typical stevie nicks record closer..I hope this is a good album...but i wont b surprised if its not

This is stupid. You say that you love the 4 tracks on the album preview, you "really like" "Cheaper Than Free", but you apparently dislike "Secret Love" (since its a "crappy first single"). So that's 5 songs out of 6 that you've heard which you LIKE, but you "won't be surprised if its not [a good album]"? That just doesn't make any sense.

jrpjr · #70 04-21-2011, 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tabruns

This is stupid. You say that you love the 4 tracks on the album preview, you "really like" "Cheaper Than Free", but you apparently dislike "Secret Love" (since its a "crappy first single"). So that's 5 songs out of 6 that you've heard which you LIKE, but you "won't be surprised if its not [a good album]"? That just doesn't make any sense.

no...i like "secret love"..just not a catchy song for a big comeback...im just writing as im thinking..if it dont make sense and its stupid..wat i wrote..its just an unrehearsed discussion...dont take word for word literally..but agrred..i am contridicting myself a lil...bottom line..i just HOPE its a great record..for her and for the fans...thats all

tabruns · #71 04-21-2011, 10:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrpjr

no...i like "secret love"..just not a catchy song for a big comeback...im just writing as im thinking..if it dont make sense and its stupid..wat i wrote..its just an unrehearsed discussion...dont take word for word literally..but agrred..i am contridicting myself a lil...bottom line..i just HOPE its a great record..for her and for the fans...thats all

Well have faith.....lots of people that have heard it have been calling it a career best. As for this reviewer, keep in mind that he seems to be critical of what Stevie Nicks *is normally like*....in other words, he panned the album (insofar as he actually panned it) cuz she didn't do something new and different.

So if you like Stevie Nicks, you'll likely love this album.