The Bonus Tracks!!!!!!!!!? - Page 9

Christopher · #**121** 04-06-2011, 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Only Stevie Nicks and Dave Stewart are getting credit for Ghosts Are Gone. Dave just tweeted me.

@DaveStewart is the Ghosts are Gone a Mike Campbell track? we are debating this now

@DaveStewart
DaveStewart
@jondalar41 no me and. Stevie

Here Here...now we can move on.....

Though Jondalar, you were pretty damn adamant the "The Ghost Are Gone" was a Mike C. track! Where upon, now we have more and more evidence that most likely the 2 Mike Campbell collaborations/songs Stevie keeps referring to, that are on this record (official track list or "Bonus" addition track list) are: For What It's Worth AND My Heart.

It's just a petty detail that keeps tripping us up and getting in the way. I hope we can move beyond this & just enjoy and talk about the damned *bonus* track already

I'm thrilled to hear a new version of My Heart on the UK import, I'm sure it's had a face lift. And I hope we get a different *bonus* in the U. S. Yeah, it does sorta suck apples to buy potentially different In Your Dreams versions. But, on the other hand, it's not everyday that we get a new Stevie Nicks CD or song for that matter. So I'll lap mine up happily and eagerly with immense pleasure

Jondalar · #**122** 04-06-2011, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Christopher

Here Here...now we can move on.....

Though Jondalar, you were pretty damn adamant the "The Ghost Are Gone" was a Mike C. track! Where upon, now we have more and more evidence that most likely the 2 Mike Campbell collaborations/songs Stevie keeps referring to, that are on this record (official track list or "Bonus" addition track list) are: For What It's Worth AND My Heart.

It's just a petty detail that keeps tripping us up and getting in the way. I hope we can move beyond this & just enjoy and talk about the damned *bonus* track already

I'm thrilled to hear a new version of My Heart on the UK import, I'm sure it's had a face lift. And I hope we get a different *bonus* in the U. S. Yeah, it does sorta suck apples to buy potentially different In Your Dreams versions. But, on the other hand, it's not everyday that we get a new Stevie Nicks CD or song for that matter. So I'll lap mine up happily and eagerly with immense pleasure

Well if the My Heart is really being the collboration then that is sorta false. The song was written a long time ago. She still says the Mike Campbell track is on the record. I'm thinking You May Be The One. Bonus track doesn't count in my eyes.

P.S. Dave is not say that Ghost lady was getting any credit.

Christopher · #**123** 04-06-2011, 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Well if the My Heart is really being the collboration then that is sorta false. The song was written a long time ago. She still says the Mike Campbell track is on the record. I'm thinking You May Be The One. Bonus track doesn't count in my eyes.

*Deep Breaths* ok, this tiny detail is becoming tedious

But...here goes, being that "My Heart" was written over 10 years ago, How does that make Stevie's statement or their collaboration "false" in any sense of the word!? That does not compute. Perhaps, you're having trouble ar.tic.u.lat.ing.

Again, Mike C. reported last year in an interview, that he was brought into Stevie's new recording sessions because Stevie wanted to re-do/revisit an old song they had previously worked on. Thus he went in and claimed "they" made the song even better. That sure sounds like" My Heart" - esp. now that the song is showing up on a tracklisting.

In addition, Mike also had recently written a new "track" that Stevie loved, which she wrote lyrics/melody on top of. Mike commented that he was very proud of the final version. This is likely the song that became "For What It's Worth".

So I suss up that these two songs are what Stevie is referring to as the "2 Mike Campbell tracks" on this record (bonus track or not) , most certainly.

Josh2003 · #**124** 04-06-2011, 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Well if the My Heart is really being the collboration then that is sorta false. The song was written a long time ago. She still says the Mike Campbell track is on the record. I'm thinking You May Be The One. Bonus track doesn't count in my eyes.

When Stevie mentioned doing two songs with Mike Campbell, there was no way ANY of them could have known what was going to be on the final version of the album, and what would be a "bonus track."

Secondly, and I know I have mentioned this ad nauseam, Stevie said herself that You May Be The One was the first song that she and Dave wrote together, based on him going through her books of poetry. Why do you keep going back to the possibility of it being a Mike Campbell song?

Jondalar · #**125** 04-06-2011, 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Josh2003

When Stevie mentioned doing two songs with Mike Campbell, there was no way ANY of them could have known what was going to be on the final version of the album, and what would be a "bonus track."

Secondly, and I know I have mentioned this ad nauseam, Stevie said herself that You May Be The One was the first song that she and Dave wrote together, based on him going through her books of poetry. Why do you keep going back to the possibility of it being a Mike Campbell song?

because Mike Campbell just wrote the track, they could of wrote it over it

Josh2003 · #**126** 04-06-2011, 06:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

because Mike Campbell just wrote the track, they could of wrote it over it

I haven't seen anything that said Mike wrote the music to You May Be the One. Did I miss something?

Jondalar · #**127** 04-06-2011, 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Josh2003

I haven't seen anything that said Mike wrote the music to You May Be the One. Did I miss something?

know you didn't miss anything, Mike wrote two tracks that Stevie put words too that made the album, one of them is For What It's Worth... guessing about the other.

In February, Stevie said that Dave wrote 7 seven songs, and she wrote 5 two with Mike Campbell, I take it they tacked on Cheaper Than Free and then it became 13 track album

sorcerer999 · #**128** 04-06-2011, 06:53 PM

There needs to be an icon for facepalm or banging head against table. This thread is starting to get frustrating.

I think you all need to just let it go. We'll find out who wrote and co-wrote what when the album comes out.

Jondalar · #**129** 04-06-2011, 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcerer999

There needs to be an icon for facepalm or banging head against table. This thread is starting to get frustrating.

I think you all need to just let it go. We'll find out who wrote and co-wrote what when the album comes out.

this is true, well I'm getting the bonus track with My Heart on it. I thought the song was really good but hated her vocal. I hope Dave had rerecord the vocal.

ontheEdgeof17 · #**130** 04-06-2011, 07:32 PM

I love My Heart....totally excited for this one.

AliceLover · #**131** 04-06-2011, 08:49 PM

My Heart is a totally cool song. I'm glad it is finally making its way to an album.

BUT

I would rather a completely new song we haven't heard before. We already have a crystal clear copy of MH. Just food for thought.

tabruns · #**132** 04-06-2011, 11:16 PM

I think people that are citing "For What It's Worth" and "My Heart" are probably correct. I don't think "You May Be The One" is it, because Stevie mentioned it as the first song that she wrote with Dave, and we know from an earlier interview that when they started the songwriting process that Dave pointed out a poem of hers from her book and said "Let's start with this one."

FM77 · #**133** 04-06-2011, 11:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

this is true, well I'm getting the bonus track with My Heart on it. I thought the song was really good but hated her vocal. I hope Dave had rerecord the vocal.

I haven't heard any other version of this other than what is on the record and I think her vocal is fantastic. I'm sure it was re-recorded. It sounded very new--including the track.

APerfectLie · #**134** 04-06-2011, 11:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FM77

I haven't heard any other version of this other than what is on the record and I think her vocal is fantastic. I'm sure it was re-recorded. It sounded very new--including the track.

Dodfather · #**135** 04-07-2011, 02:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sorcerer999

There needs to be an icon for facepalm or banging head against table. This thread is starting to get frustrating.

I think you all need to just let it go. We'll find out who wrote and co-wrote what when the album comes out.

Yes!! Come on guys, lighten up! I said it was irritating about diofferent bonus tracks but didn't expect it to become a huge thing about writers etc...

Oh, and I hate to sound like the vopice of doom but hmv's website is notorious for incorrect information anyway so I wouldn't rely too much on it. I remembered that after my earlier post - d'oh!