The great Crystal slug-out!

[MissLadyLoki]

I got kinda bored today, and I decided to create yet another poll

Calm down, this has nothing to do with appearances, this has to do with a song written by La Nicks that has appeared in 3 different forms over the years, and we're not talking cover. This song is, of course, the lovely ballad Crystal, and over the years, we've seen 3 different versions and, with that, I ask you guys to pick your favorite version of the song

EDIT: I am aware that the BN and FM versions are nearly identical, but to my ears, there are some differences to their sounds

[jannieC]

We played thing song at our wedding- Lindsey's vocals (with Stevie harmonizing) are perfect. I'm not sure I knew there was a difference between the BN version and the FM version, though.

[skuncles]

Great song, but I am not a fan of Stevie's solo version at all. The BN and FM versions are almost identical but I would probably side with the FM version as the best version.

[bluefox4000]

It was close.....Cause Crystal's a fav of mine. I went with The Mac Version. Though I love the Buckingham-Nicks version too.

Mick

[MissLadyLoki]

For me, I had to go with the origina; BN version. For some reason, I like it more than the FM version, but then again, I'm weird like that

[tilthefirefades]

One of the most beautiful songs ever, but I can't stand Stevie's version at all. Love the FM version the best.

[KarmaContestant]

I picked the BN version. I don't love Stevie's version, but it's ok. Had she chosen to record it as a solo song about 15-20 years before she actually did, it would have been superb I'm sure.

[louielouie2000]

Practical Magic version. Always. Crystal is such a thoroughly Stevie song, nobody but Stevie ever should have sang it. Hearing Lindsey sing Crystal has always just annoyed me. It's such a beautiful feminine song, and when I hear Lindsey sigh out those first few words, something about it just enrages me . Not to mention Stevie was only given 2 slots on the '75 Mac album. I just wish she'd always been the one singing her own song. And that's what the Practical Magic version represents to me: the song coming full circle. Not to mention, I just adore the gorgeous production. The Practical Magic Crystal will always be one of my very favorite Stevie songs.

[tilthefirefades]

Originally Posted by KarmaContestant

I picked the BN version. I don't love Stevie's version, but it's ok. Had she chosen to record it as a solo song about 15-20 years before she actually did, it would have been superb I'm sure.

Now I'm picturing a Leather and Lace-esque version. It would have sounded amazing with that era vocal, I'm sure. The only album I can imagine it on though is Bella Donna, and I wouldn't want any tracks taken off. Are there any other versions or demos of it besides what's on this poll?

[bluefox4000]

I just listened To Stevie's version for the first time in ages.....and i remembered why I stopped. Not that it's terrible.it's not. But it's not my my Favorite. It's slightly grating. Had she sung it way back when....I'm sure it would have been a million times better.

Mick

[Musicman408]

[QUOTE=MissLadyLoki;928993]I got kinda bored today, and I decided to create yet another poll

Calm down, this has nothing to do with appearances, this has to do with a song written by La Nicks that has appeared in 3 different forms over the years, and we're not talking cover. This song is, of course, the lovely ballad Crystal, and over the years, we've seen 3 different versions and, with that, I ask you guys to pick your favorite version of the song

EDIT: I am aware that the BN and FM versions are nearly identical, but to my ears, there are some differences to their sounds[/QUOTE]

I haven't listened to either version in a long time, but if I'm remembering right, they are in two completely different keys.

[MissLadyLoki]

Originally Posted by Musicman408

I haven't listened to either version in a long time, but if I'm remembering right, they are in two completely different keys.

That was it! I knew there was something different!

[Meowi]

The BN version wins for me.
I feel it is way more powerful and moving than the other versions. Plus, I love that celtic-ish melody that was replaced by Christine's electric piano.

[RockAlot]

Currently a 3-way tie! Speaking of 3-ways...I kid, I kid!!!

[Phoenix]

Originally Posted by louielouie2000

Practical Magic version. Always. Crystal is such a thoroughly Stevie song, nobody but Stevie ever should have sang it. Hearing Lindsey sing Crystal has always just annoyed me. It's such a beautiful feminine song, and when I hear Lindsey sigh out those first few words, something about it just enrages me . Not to mention Stevie was only given 2 slots on the '75 Mac album. I just wish she'd always been the one singing her own song. And that's what the Practical Magic version represents to me: the song coming full circle. Not to mention, I just adore the gorgeous production. The Practical Magic Crystal will always be one of my very favorite Stevie songs.

ONCE AGAIN WE AGREE! twice in one week! i cant believe it! I ADORE the Practical Magic version of Crystal. It is one of my favorites of hers ever. I like the strings in the backround as well, and how she trails off in a whisper at the end. It IS a Stevie song. it is so her, hauntingly loving with a bit of the mystic. Pure stevie perfection.. PLUS it was nice to have a song of hers ACTUALLY prominently featured in a movie for a change, and not just in the backround. One of the best parts is when she sings the third "to the SEA" twards the end. I remember thinking, even back then, wow, i havent heard stevie do THAT with her voice in a long time. MAGIC.