DISCUSSION: Other Lindsey songs not already considered

[elle]

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC

"Stand Back" live is on The Chain box set. I personally think "SB" has been grandfathered in as an FM standard, but rules are rules!

Ah, I stand corrected again!

But, do we count live albums? I didn't see Dance in the competition... On edit - TVBOFM is not in the competition either!

[elle]

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC

"Stand Back" live is on The Chain box set. I personally think "SB" has been grandfathered in as an FM standard

I'd go with that!

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC

but rules are rules!

Aren't we making the rules of this game as we are going along?

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by elle

But, do we count live albums? I didn't see Dance in the competition... On edit - TVBOFM is not in the competition either!

Live albums, best of albums don't count the way the studio albums count, with the detailed analysis and discussion threads. However, new songs on live albums, best of's would count. Hence the purpose of the "extra" song poll for the primary vocalists - to pick up those songs not on studio albums.

[elle]

Originally Posted by MacShadowsBall

Live albums, best of albums don't count the way the studio albums count, with the detailed analysis and discussion threads. However, new songs on live albums, best of's would count. Hence the purpose of the "extra" song poll for the primary vocalists - to pick up those songs not on studio albums.

Hence, Go Insane and Stand Back should count. Unless you go with "new". And even then, for the sake of argument, The Very Best of FM came out before Bass Hall CD - and these are only CDs where acoustic Go Insane is available.

What about Love Minus Zero/No Limit? It is an extra... And although Dylan's, you did count Blue Letter and Seven Wonders as Lindsey and Stevie songs, correct?