Lindsey vs. Stevie 2011 Grudge Match!

TrueFaith77 · #1 11-02-2010, 02:32 PM

If, as I dream, both Lindsey and Stevie's albums were to be released on the same day, which one would you listen to FIRST!?!?!?

bluefox4000 · #2 11-02-2010, 02:44 PM

Lindsey. It would take a while to get around to stevie.

Mick

Silver Springs · #3 11-02-2010, 03:00 PM

Wow. Suddenly Mama's getting her bum handed to her on a silver platter. And people say that he's a failure compared to her

Although Stevie was my "gateway drug" to Fleetwood Mac, I ultimately prefer Lindsey's work to Stevie's. Maybe because I've always preferred Folk/Real music over the big production and showyness Stevie's music tends to be. That being said, I'll never stop loving her music. I'll just always go for the acoustic/accapella version over the studio.

Retrospective: May have spoken too soon lol.

Nico · #4 11-02-2010, 03:01 PM

Lindsey. I guess if Stevie's album came out notably before his I would listen to that first, but I would prefer to listen to Lindsey's. Stevie solo stuff has never blown me away, to be honest. It's quite hit or miss for me. Much prefer her early Fleetwood Mac stuff.

Lindsey's albums are almost always incredible.

Silver Springs · #5 11-02-2010, 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nico

Lindsey. I guess if Stevie's album came out notably before his I would listen to that first, but I would prefer to listen to Lindsey's. Stevie solo stuff has never blown me away, to be honest. It's quite hit or miss for me. Much prefer her early Fleetwood Mac stuff.

Lindsey's albums are almost always incredible.

Sometimes you just wish The Ledge had a Facebook style "like" button for comments

louielouie2000 · #6 11-02-2010, 03:13 PM

I'd have to say Stevie's for the sole reason that we've gotten 2 albums from Lindsey since her last release, and I'm anxious to hear what Stevie has to say, and how she's evolved.

If this were a question of if I had to chose between seeing Stevie's tour, or seeing Lindsey's... hands down, Buckingham would win.

astro-addy · #7 11-02-2010, 03:36 PM

I'd say Lindseys the winner becoz when you buy a Lindsey album you know what your getting. Stevie depends so greatly on her collaborators.

However

While stevies solo stuff has ben less than impressive, I dont think anything Lindsey has ever done has come close to how amazing Belladonna was. Its like they were squeezing the last of the greatness from the 70s.

Lindsey is amazing as a solo artist... However, I think doing big albums isnt in him anymore, his production on SYW is so dated.

TrueFaith77 · #8 11-02-2010, 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by louielouie2000

I'd have to say Stevie's for the sole reason that we've gotten 2 albums from Lindsey since her last release, and I'm anxious to hear what Stevie has to say, and how she's evolved.

If this were a question of if I had to chose between seeing Stevie's tour, or seeing Lindsey's... hands down, Buckingham would win.

What a thoughtful answer. That's a good point. I guess I'm just afeared of Stevie's more than Lindsey's. Either way, I'll still be imagining: "What if..."

Nico · #9 11-02-2010, 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver Springs

Sometimes you just wish The Ledge had a Facebook style "like" button for comments

Thank you.

I agree.

**jbrownsjr** · #10 11-02-2010, 03:44 PM

I would listen to Stevie's first. I am interested to see if her sound has changed at all. I like some recent songs of hers that really interested me...

Sweet Girl. I love the melody.. I know this is old now.. but still new compared to 80's material...

Illume ... Great atmosphere and feel.. I hope she goes this sort of direction... Hoping the feel wasn't all LB.

Thrown Down.. Love the direction of this tune..

Everybody finds Out... With the exception of the clothespin on her nose voice... this is a great tune... nice harmonies w/ LB..

Direction I don't want... Silver Girl, Destiny Rules, Goodbye Baby, Say You Will...

Nico · #11 11-02-2010, 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by astro-addy

While stevies solo stuff has ben less than impressive, I dont think anything Lindsey has ever done has come close to how amazing Belladonna was. Its like they were squeezing the last of the greatness from the 70s.

I'm going to respectively disagree.

Bella Donna bores me. Her other album, Wild Heart is superior. And yet...nothing she's done solo is quite on par with Out of the Cradle.

But that's the beauty of opinions...

louielouie2000 · #12 11-02-2010, 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nico

I'm going to respectively disagree.

Bella Donna bores me. Her other album, Wild Heart is superior. And yet...nothing she's done solo is quite on par with Out of the Cradle.

But that's the beauty of opinions...

I have to disagree regarding Wild Heart. I think it's just a terribly sappy monument to Stevie's bloated ego.

But I definitely agree Stevie's also never come anywhere near Out Of The Cradle. Hell, Fleetwood Mac itself might not have.

vivfox · #13 11-02-2010, 05:40 PM

Hands down, Stevie Nicks. She hasn't put out an album since 1994! I liked Lindsey's first 2 solo albums, the rest are fair to midland. Two songs, Murrow & Down On Rodeo I really loved though.

Christopher · #14 11-02-2010, 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by louielouie2000

I have to disagree regarding Wild Heart. I think it's just a terribly sappy monument to Stevie's bloated ego.

But I definitely agree Stevie's also never come anywhere near Out Of The Cradle. Hell, Fleetwood Mac itself might not have.

While I think the Wild Heart is a solid effort, I agree it is no Bella Donna. And it is also the beginning of Stevie resting on her laurels and getting somewhat lazy in her songwriting. This is when Stevie began writing songs to music tracks provided by outside musicians. In Wild Hearts case Sandy Stewart's tracks were heavily relied upon, Which sucked cause Stevie had plenty of great tracks in the vault, Sorcerer, The Beautiful Worlds, Violet and Blue, and others would have put Wild Heart in Bella Donna's league easily.

And that is why I am excited about Stevie's new record and would most definitely play it first due to Stevie actually writing songs real time with a collaborator in the same room organically speaking. It's a refreshing change of direction for her, one in which we have all dreamed she would do with Lindsey, and Dave and her sound so thrilled with the results. I think we could be in store for her most musically ambitious outing ever and easily best since Bella Donna.

chiliD · #15 11-02-2010, 06:14 PM

Depends if California's Prop 19 passes. If so, I'll probably listen to Lindsey's first. Plus, the chances of me buying Lindsey's album before I buy Stevie's is pretty large. I'm still a couple of Stevie albums behind in my "completist" goal. (But, then, the ones I'm behind on are compilations not albums of all new material)

Um, Louie...I agree with you on principle, but, to me Stevie's TISL was as close to a "perfect" Stevie Nicks album as she's ever released...as was Lindsey's Out Of The Cradle. But, no way OotC outdoes Then Play On or Mystery To Me...or hell, even, *gag*, *choke* Ru.... *hack*...Rum... *wheeze*...Rumours.

No one will EVER...get that? EVER convince me that Wild Heart is superior to Bella Donna...or Rock A Little...damn...even Street Angel. The only album WH is superior to is The Other Side Of The Mirror, which is the ultimate abomination of Stevie's catalogue.

View Poll Results: Which would you listen to first?
Lindsey's new album	26	27.96%
Stevie's new album	55	59.14%
BOTH: I'd play randomly shuffle them simultaneously on my ipod	6	6.45%
NEITHER: The intensity of such an occurrence would quite literally kill me	6	6.45%
Voters: 93. You may not vote on this poll