Should Go Your Own Way in discog be listed as different mix on Chain to Rumours mix

[wetcamelfood]

Per discussion in another thread, this is to decide whether we should list Go Your Own Way on the Chain box as including a different mix instead of it being linked to the Rumours version in the Penguin Discogrpahy (as it is now).

We're just looking for votes in this thread but if you feel it should be listed as a different mix please say in this thread how you think it should be listed (i.e. "Alternate Mix" etc.) but please keep it as brief as possible since there's not much room to list such details but we need to put something there so those visiting the page will know why it's separated from the Rumours version.

Naturally, the most votes here wins and I'm not wedded to either outcome but I'd only say that I don't think we should open a can of worms in that there's no point having a database set up there if it gets to the point where people feel every compilation has a "different (something) to each track for a milisecond" then we have none linked together. Please use judgement regarding these kinds of things. Yes, audiophiles probably will notice very small things about each pressing of a particular recording but let's be reasonable about it. Like I said in the other thread, let's determine how many extra/different seconds it has to be to merit it being called a "different mix" or whatever (because rarely, is it always going to match up time wise perfectly due to different pressings being manufactured as slightly different speeds etc.

Thanks in advance for your input.

John

[candlebright86]

I thought this was for Gold Dust Woman?

[wetcamelfood]

Originally Posted by candlebright86

I thought this was for Gold Dust Woman?

Oops, you're right, meant to put GDW so I guess everyone can ignore this.

Just noticed though, we do have GDW listed as an alternate mix on the box now so I guess we're all set.

John