Album Points Ranking: Enchanted Box Set Extras

Musicman408 · #1 11-30-2009, 05:19 PM

At the encouragement of you all, I decided that we would be lacking if we didn't do this!! Last rounds totals:
Blue Denim - 330
Love Is Like A River - 301
Greta - 277
Kick it - 277
Listen To The Rain - 254
Rose Garden - 251
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind - 230
Street Angel - 225
Docklands - 220
Unconditional Love - 194
Destiny - 186
Just Like A Woman - 123
Jane - 105

So, BD, LILAR and Greta are automatically in the finals, with Kick It making it to the Wild Card Round.

Now for the Enchanted Round. This was REALLY difficult for me, because I don't listen to this as much, which is sad, because it is some of Stevie's best stuff- but here it goes. For this round, all songs will be separated by 3 points, so 50,47, 44, etc!

1. Thousand Days- 50
2. Battle of the Dragon- 47
3. Violet and Blue- 44
4. Whenever I Call You Friend- 41
5. Reconsider Me- 38
6. Gold and Braid- 35
7. Sweet Girl- 32
8. Blue Lamp- 29
9. Sleeping Angel- 26
10. Long Distance Winner- 23
11. Big Time Rock and Roll Star- 20
12. Gold- 17
13. Somebody Stand By Me- 14
14. Twisted- 11
15. Free Fallin'- 8
16. It's Late- 5
17. Rhiannon- 2

Everyone have a ball, and it'll be interesting to see where this one ends up!!! Top 3 make it to the finals, and 4th and 5th get a spot in the Wild Card!

FMlex · #2 11-30-2009, 07:11 PM

Ethan, if we're sticking to disc 3 of Enchanted, why have you included "One More Time Big Rock and Roll Star" into your rankings??

Musicman408 · #3 11-30-2009, 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FMlex

Ethan, if we're sticking to disc 3 of Enchanted, why have you included "One More Time Big Rock and Roll Star" into your rankings??

Well, I included all of the works that hadn't really appeared on any other album- I know it is randomly on Disc 1, but I'm including everything that is "new" ish. Hence Why it is called Enchanted Extras!

PS: You still owe me a video!

FMlex · #4 11-30-2009, 08:02 PM

In that case, here's mine:

1. Gold and Braid - 50
2. Blue Lamp - 47
3. Long Distance Winner - 44
4. Violet and Blue - 41
5. Rhiannon (Piano) - 38
6. Sleeping Angel - 35
7. Sweet Girl - 32
8. Whenever I Call You Friend - 29
9. One More Big Time Rock and Roll Star - 26
10. Reconsider Me - 23
11. Gold - 20
12. Free Fallin' - 17
13. I's Late - 14
14. Somebody Stand By Me - 11
15. Thousand Days - 8
16. Battle of the Dragon - 5
17. Twisted - 2

New totals:
1. Gold and Braid- 85
2. Violet and Blue- 85
3. Blue Lamp- 76
4. Whenever I Call You Friend- 70
5. Long Distance Winner- 67
6. Sweet Girl- 64
7. Reconsider Me- 61
8. Sleeping Angel- 61
9. Thousand Days- 58
10. Battle of the Dragon- 52
11. Big Time Rock and Roll Star- 46
12. Rhiannon- 40
13. Gold- 37
14. Twisted- 13
15. Free Fallin'- 25
16. Somebody Stand By Me- 25
17. It's Late- 19

Musicman408 · #5 11-30-2009, 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FMlex

In that case, here's mine:

1. Gold and Braid - 50
2. Blue Lamp - 47
3. Long Distance Winner - 44
4. Violet and Blue - 41
5. Rhiannon (Piano) - 38
6. Sleeping Angel - 35
7. Sweet Girl - 32
8. Whenever I Call You Friend - 29
9. One More Big Time Rock and Roll Star - 26
10. Reconsider Me - 23
11. Gold - 20
12. Free Fallin' - 17
13. I's Late - 14
14. Somebody Stand By Me - 11
15. Thousand Days - 8
16. Battle of the Dragon - 5
17. Twisted - 2

New totals:
1. Gold and Braid- 85
2. Violet and Blue- 85
3. Blue Lamp- 76
4. Whenever I Call You Friend- 70
5. Long Distance Winner- 67
6. Sweet Girl- 64
7. Reconsider Me- 61
8. Sleeping Angel- 61
9. Thousand Days- 58
10. Battle of the Dragon- 52
11. Big Time Rock and Roll Star- 46
12. Rhiannon- 40
13. Gold- 37
14. Twisted- 13
15. Free Fallin'- 25
16. Somebody Stand By Me- 25
17. It's Late- 19

Dang girl, you pretty much took my results and flipped them upside down!!!

fleetwoodtrick · #6 11-30-2009, 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FMlex

17. Twisted - 2

Okay, I totally quit these threads because it's like, as Stevie says, picking your children. Which luckily, I don't have yet! That'd be bad. But let's not get into that.

Your apparent lack of interest in Twisted hurts me.

That'd be in my top 3 on Enchanted. And Battle of the Dragon too! Sheesh. :P But I love your first 5 choices enough to forgive you.

Musicman408 · #7 11-30-2009, 10:14 PM

It's one of those things though, that they are so equal that it's hard to choose!!

FMlex · #8 11-30-2009, 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fleetwoodtrick

Okay, I totally quit these threads because it's like, as Stevie says, picking your children. Which luckily, I don't have yet! That'd be bad. But let's not get into that.

Your apparent lack of interest in Twisted hurts me.

That'd be in my top 3 on Enchanted. And Battle of the Dragon too! Sheesh. :P But I love your first 5 choices enough to forgive you.

Thank you for forgiving me!

I'm sorry, I just find "Twisted" really dull. I like the lyrics and I like the msuic, but not together. I dunno, I can't really explain it.

And I do like her voice on "Battle of the Dragon," but other than that it doesn't do much for me.

holidayroad · #9 12-01-2009, 11:05 AM

My List:
Gold and Braid-50
Sleeping Angel-47
Long Distance Winner-44
Violet and Blue-41
Blue Lamp-38
Reconsider Me-35
Gold-32
Battle of the Dragon-29
Sweet Girl-26
Whenever I Call You Friend-23
One More Big Time..-20
Rhiannon-17
Thousand Days-14
Free Fallin-11
Twisted-8
Somebody Stand By Me-5
It's Late-2

New Totals:
Gold and Braid-135
Violet and Blue-126
Blue Lamp-114
Long Distance Winner-111
Sleeping Angel-108
Reconsider Me-96
Whenever I Call You Friend-93
Sweet Girl-90
Battle of the Dragon-81
Thousand Days-72
Gold-69
One More Big Time..-66
Rhiannon-57
Free Fallin-36
Somebody Stand By Me-30
Twisted-21
It's Late-21

daniellaaarisen · #10 12-01-2009, 07:29 PM

My List:
Sleeping Angel - 50
Blue Lamp -47
Rhiannon - 44
Gold and Braid - 41
Sweet Girl -38
Violet and Blue - 35
Long Distance Winner -32
Free Fallin - 29
Thousand Days -26
Twisted - 23
Reconsider Me -20
Battle of the Dragon - 17
Somebody Stand By Me -14
Whenever I Call You Friend - 11
Gold -8
One More Big Time Rock N' Roll Star - 5
It's Late - 2

New Totals:
Gold and Braid-176
Violet and Blue-161
Blue Lamp-161
Sleeping Angel-158
Long Distance Winner-143
Sweet Girl-128
Reconsider Me-116
Whenever I Call You Friend-104
Rhiannon-101
Battle of the Dragon-98
Thousand Days-98
Gold-77
One More Big Time..-69
Free Fallin-65
Somebody Stand By Me-44
Twisted-44
It's Late-23

Gypsycat999 · #11 12-02-2009, 02:28 PM

My picks:
Gold and Braid - 50
Long Distance Winner -47
Violet and Blue - 44
Battle of the Dragon - 41
Twisted -38
Thousand Days - 35
Sleeping Angel -32
Blue Lamp - 29
Sweet Girl -26
Rhiannon - 23
One More Big Time -20
Whenever I call you Friend- 17
Gold -14
Somebody Stand By Me - 11
Reconsider Me -8
Free Falling - 5
It's Late - 2

New Totals:
Gold and Braid-226
Violet and Blue-205
Blue Lamp-190
Long Distance Winner-190
Sleeping Angel-190
Sweet Girl-154
Battle of the Dragon-139
Thousand Days-133
Reconsider Me-124
Rhiannon-124
Whenever I Call You Friend-121
Gold-91
One More Big Time..-89
Twisted-82
Free Fallin-70
Somebody Stand By Me-55
It's Late-25

vivfox · #12 12-03-2009, 12:22 AM

My Picks:
1. One More Big Time Rock And Roll Star-50
2. Battle Of The Dragon-47
3. Blue Lamp-44
4. Twisted-41
5. Violet And Blue-38
6. Whenever I call You Friend-35
7. Gold-32
8. Long Distance Winner-29
9. A Bit Of Gold And Braid-26
10. Rhiannon-23
11. Sleeping Angel-20
12. Thousand Days-17
13. Sweet Girl-14
14. Free Fallin'-11
15. It's Late-8
16. Reconsider Me-5
17. Somebody Stand By Me-2

New Totals:
1. A Bit Of Gold And Braid-252
2. Violet And Blue-243
3. Blue Lamp-234
4. Long Distance Winner-219
5. Sleeping Angel-210
6. Battle Of The Dragon-186
7. Sweet Girl-168
8. Whenever I Call You Friend-156
9. Thousand Days-150
10. Rhiannon-147
11. One More Big Time Rock And Roll Star-139
12. Reconsider Me-129
13. Twisted-123
14. Gold-123
15. Free Fallin'-81
16. Somebody Stand By Me-57
17. It's Late-33

TheWILDheart · #13 12-03-2009, 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Musicman408

Well, I included all of the works that hadn't really appeared on any other album- I know it is randomly on Disc 1, but I'm including everything that is "new" ish. Hence Why it is called Enchanted Extras!

PS: You still owe me a video!

"Garbo" is missing in that case

Musicman408 · #14 12-07-2009, 04:42 PM

Voting on this round will run through the end of this week!

Hawkeye · #15 12-07-2009, 10:15 PM

1. Long Distance Winner 50
2. Blue Lamp 47
3. Gold and Braid 44
4. Battle of the Dragon 41
5. Twisted 38
6. Thousand Days 35
7. Violet and Blue 32
8. Sleeping Angel 29
9. Sweet Girl 26
10. Somebody Stand By Me 23
11. Gold 20
12. Reconsider Me 17
13. Rhiannon 14
14. Its Late 11
15. One More Big Time Rock and Roll Star 8
16. Free Fallin 5
17. Whenever I Call You Friend

New Results

1. Gold and Briad 296
2. Blue Lamp 281
3. Violet and Blue 275
4. Long Distance winner 269
5. Sleeping Angel 239
6. Battle of the Dragon 227
7. Sweet Girl 194
8. Thousnad Days 185
9. Twisted 171
10. Rhiannon 161
11. Whenever I Call You Friend 158
12. One More Big Time Rock and Roll Star 147
13. Reconsider Me 146
14. Gold 143
15. Free Fallin 86
16. Somebody Stand By Me 80
17. Its Late 47