Need Ledge Expert Advice

[nwestohiofan]

Fellow Ledgies,

I recieved an expensive gift for Christmas. A white Fender Elec. Guitar signed by all Fleetwood Mac members.

The person who gave it to me spent about $300.00 and bought it on ebay.

Obviously I was very excited about this gift but noticed immediately that the signatures looked odd. And Christine McVie hasn't been around for like 8 years. Even if this was signed during a Say You Will meet & greet, she would not have been there.

Also the Certificate of Authenticity also looks bogus and I havent been able to find any info on the company who authenticated it. "Atlanta's Geniune Signature's" ... can not be found online.

Heres the ebay link.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...9876&rd=1&rd=1

I need your advice.

HELP!

[BlackWidow]

Originally Posted by nwestohiofan

Fellow Ledgies,

I recieved an expensive gift for Christmas. A white Fender Elec. Guitar signed by all Fleetwood Mac members.

The person who gave it to me spent about $300.00 and bought it on ebay.

Obviously I was very excited about this gift but noticed immediately that the signatures looked odd. And Christine McVie hasn't been around for like 8 years. Even if this was signed during a Say You Will meet & greet, she would not have been there.

Also the Certificate of Authenticity also looks bogus and I havent been able to find any info on the company who authenticated it. "Atlanta's Geniune Signature's" ... can not be found online.

Heres the ebay link.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...9876&rd=1&rd=1

I need your advice.

HELP!

...just say "Thank You!"

[catinthedark]

sounds like this would be a great question for the "ask john" segment! (over on the rumours board, in case you haven't seen). seriously, why don't you submit a question about this kind of thing: do the members actually sign guitars to be sold later? or are these things usually bogus? i'd be interested to know myself.

good luck - i hope your friend didn't get duped.

[Gypsy-Rhiannon]

I'm sorry but it looks totally bogus to me. Stevie's sig looks fake most definitely. If this were genuinely the real deal I would have expected it to sell for a lot more anyway. I would never trust signed stuff from ebay

[carrie721]

all those signatures look like they were signed by the same person to me.

[DashingDan]

Originally Posted by BlackWidow

...just say "Thank You!"

Hear, hear!

Now get yourself an amplifier and sign it "Keith Richards" and you'll be ready to take a few lessons. Enjoy.

[WelshWitchPMD]

Originally Posted by Gypsy-Rhiannon

If this were genuinely the real deal I would have expected it to sell for a lot more anyway. I would never trust signed stuff from ebay

That is what I thought, too. If it was real I would think that it would go for at least $1,000.00. Lindsey's sig looks odd to me. Of course I don't have anything on this laptop with his signature on it to compare it to.
I just remembered that I made a UTS banner using a photo that he signed for me a few years ago.

[catinthedark]

Originally Posted by BlackWidow

...just say "Thank You!"

absolutely!! don't breathe a word of your misgivings to your very generous friend.

but at the same time, i understand your questioning of it. and again, i hope he/she didn't get duped. still, not a word to your friend.

[BlackWidow]

Originally Posted by catinthedark

absolutely!! don't breathe a word of your misgivings to your very generous friend.

but at the same time, i understand your questioning of it. and again, i hope he/she didn't get duped. still, not a word to your friend.

...exactly.

[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by nwestohiofan

Fellow Ledgies,

I recieved an expensive gift for Christmas. A white Fender Elec. Guitar signed by all Fleetwood Mac members.

The person who gave it to me spent about $300.00 and bought it on ebay.

Obviously I was very excited about this gift but noticed immediately that the signatures looked odd. And Christine McVie hasn't been around for like 8 years. Even if this was signed during a Say You Will meet & greet, she would not have been there.

Also the Certificate of Authenticity also looks bogus and I havent been able to find any info on the company who authenticated it. "Atlanta's Geniune Signature's" ... can not be found online.

Heres the ebay link.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...9876&rd=1&rd=1

I need your advice.

HELP!

I have an authetic Stevie signature and I can say that it doesn't look much like that. I also have an authentic Lindsey signature that looks nothing like that.
I think the best recourse you would have at this point would be through eBay. Also, you might want to pursue it with PayPal if that's how it was paid for. I'm terribly sorry this happened to you.

[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by catinthedark

absolutely!! don't breathe a word of your misgivings to your very generous friend.

I think his friend should know. What if he goes about buying this sort of thing for other friends? Shouldn't he know that like 95% of the stuff on eBay is fake? I don't know.
And yes, it would be good to ask John if they do this sort of thing. I'd be interested in his repsonse.

[77Rumours77]

Stevie's dosen't look real, BUT..... That guitar is a real beauty! That could be signed by god IMO, and I would still play it all day and night!

[SortaSavageLike]

Originally Posted by WelshWitchPMD

So his real name is Pm Phjars? Or is it M Piars? No wonder he had it changed to Lindsey Buckingham!

[shackin'up]

These autographs look like bad copies from the 25 years of FM -chain box.

300 bucks for a fender. is that so bad? is it a real one?

[DavidMn]

I hope you didnt get taken, but it looks as though you might have been.