Bella Donna vs Trouble in Shangri La

[Rickypt]

Originally Posted by Miss Vicky

But then, I'm not known for my extreme opinions about her, or anything.

No, you're just known for being obnoxious.

[Miss Vicky]

Originally Posted by Rickypt

No, you're just known for being obnoxious.

Eh, I get mixed reviews.

Some love me, some hate me. It's all good to me.

[goldustsongbird]

Overall? Bella Donna, obviously.

[carrie721]

Originally Posted by goldustsongbird

Overall? Bella Donna, obviously.

liek, t0ttaly.

no, i agree, 4srs. where are you?

[goldustsongbird]

Originally Posted by carrie721

liek, t0ttaly.

no, i agree, 4srs. where are you?

Going to bed. I didn't go out.

[carrie721]

Originally Posted by goldustsongbird

Going to bed. I didn't go out.

aw. tell me about it tomorrow?

[goldustsongbird]

Originally Posted by carrie721

aw. tell me about it tomorrow?

Yeah. Sleep tight, dude. Let's quit being thread jackin' bitches, ok?

[nightbird89]

I'm going 4 bd. It has Edge which is my all time fav, hmsl which is the sexiest song on earth, highwayman (LUUUUV IT), and glitter. tisl is a great album, but tfft and that made me stronger sorta make my choicce easier, and i think that the production 4 candlebright shoulda been a lot better.

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by iamstevienicks

Just felt garbage was a little extreme

it was extreme. pay no mind.

Originally Posted by Rickypt

No, you're just known for being obnoxious.

exactly.

Originally Posted by Miss Vicky

Some love me, some hate me. It's all good to me.

whatever. you keep telling yourself that.

I voted Bella Donna. it is classic and every song is perfection.

[jannieC]

I voted Bella Donna- Kind of Woman, Glitter, Edge; it's a CD I can listen to from beginning to end without skipping any songs.

That being said, TISL really grew on me over time. There are a few songs I could do without though, so...BD it is. Plus, I just think the whole overall Stevie-ness of the BD era was so incredible.

[foxyluva]

Originally Posted by Miss Vicky

TISL is garbage. Bella Donna is classic.

Just shut up

TISL is the best...

[carrie721]

i voted for bella donna, but i think these album vs. album / love or hate / least favorite album threads are getting old - they're unnecessarily divisive and what is the point? they always become ridiculous. at this point, they're just a showcase for certain people to post their well-rehearsed, sometimes incendiary opinions. not much is happening in stevieland, but surely we came come up with something more analytical and interesting to talk about than rehashing which album we like better than another.

[foxyluva]

Originally Posted by carrie721

i voted for bella donna, but i think these album vs. album / love or hate / least favorite album threads are getting old - they're unnecessarily divisive and what is the point? they always become ridiculous. at this point, they're just a showcase for certain people to post their well-rehearsed, sometimes incendiary opinions. not much is happening in stevieland, but surely we came come up with something more analytical and interesting to talk about than rehashing which album we like better than another.

Totally. Im getting a little sick of hearing that my precious TISL is garbage. I have heard opinions before, and their is always room for healthy debate, but when people/albums start getting attacked, I do get rather defensive

[carrie721]

Originally Posted by foxyluva

Totally. Im getting a little sick of hearing that my precious TISL is garbage. I have heard opinions before, and their is always room for healthy debate, but when people/albums start getting attacked, I do get rather defensive

i agree about healthy debate. these threads don't invite healthy debate, they invite extremist opinions. what is the point?

[foxyluva]

Originally Posted by carrie721

i agree about healthy debate. these threads don't invite healthy debate, they invite extremist opinions. what is the point?

I agree. I really hate reading bad things about TISL - you know how much that album means to me....