Good golly- a Buckingham Nicks show surfaces! - Page 20

chiliD · #**286** 04-28-2006, 01:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skcin

It's finally official - every tune from Rumours has been done live.

Well, considering "I Don't Want To Know" was the FIRST one done, every tune from Rumours had been done live by the end of 1977 (including "Silver Springs")

goldustboi · #**287** 04-29-2006, 05:23 AM

Is there any reason why my download of IDWK is only 10 seconds and only includes the intro??

Keith · #**288** 04-29-2006, 12:26 PM

I continue to scratch my head about this band. I love them, I really do. But now after hearing both Crystal and I Don't Wanna Know played live, there is no reason why FM never played these gems in concert.. IDWK is terrific. I used to think that maybe the band rehearsed the songs but didn't think they transfered from the studio to the stage.. but these wonderful BN live tracks prove me wrong. Oh well. Good to hear them now. Thanks again for sharing these tracks.. Great stuff.

Keith · #**289** 04-29-2006, 12:30 PM

just heard Telephone. :-)

My girl Stevie still stays deep inside my heart... I so love her voice. Great track.

PenguinHead · #**290** 04-29-2006, 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David

Yeah, true. But it's shorter than calling it Never Going Back Again Genesis or something. Obviously, this is common in Lindsey's career & Beethoven's career: kernels of musical ideas, twisted & turned in numerous directions throughout the course of many years, put on tape (or in a notebook, in Beethoven's case) & then later returned to--sometimes years later--until it finally "makes sense" to the composer, who finalizes the kernel.

I'm loving this live I Don't Want To Know!!

Well, that's my point. Lindsey creates little instrumentals and guitar sketches that he may eventually refer back to and use to build songs. I don't think that justifies giving them the titles to the songs they eventually became. The instrumental he perfomed with Buckingham Nicks is not Never Going Back Again, so why call it that? At the very least, for lack of a name -- if it's going to be referred to as NGBA, add "early version" or something that doesn't misrepresent it (just because it makes for a shorter title!). For example, with the Tusk demos: Song #3 (Walk A Thin Line)

desrtangl · #**291** 04-29-2006, 06:32 PM

very interesting...just listened to sorcerer and she introduces it as "this is Lady from the Mountain"...isn't that crazy!!!...lol!

madformac · #**292** 04-30-2006, 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PenguinHead

Well, that's my point. Lindsey creates little instrumentals and guitar sketches that he may eventually refer back to and use to build songs. I don't think that justifies giving them the titles to the songs they eventually became. The instrumental he perfomed with Buckingham Nicks is not Never Going Back Again, so why call it that? At the very least, for lack of a name -- if it's going to be referred to as NGBA, add "early version" or something that doesn't misrepresent it (just because it makes for a shorter title!). For example, with the Tusk demos: Song #3 (Walk A Thin Line)

Yeah it's like referring to "Doing What I Can" as "Big Love" when they are not the same song....

Err... Hang on actually.