American Idol: Top 12

[DavidMn]

I'm thinking now that I dont want Paris to win because doesnt her grrandmother have great music business connections? And with Paris getting as far as she has, I have no doubt that she'll be able to get some sort of recording contract. There are others that I'm sure need to win more.

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by DavidMn

I'm thinking now that I dont want Paris to win because doesnt her grrandmother have great music business connections? And with Paris getting as far as she has, I have no doubt that she'll be able to get some sort of recording contract. There are others that I'm sure need to win more.

yes. the great Ann Nesby. she is fierce. I've loved her for a while.

not quite sure how I feel about your Paris idea tho. I'm kinda torn...gotta think on it.

[bikerchic]

I now have a soft spot for Elliot, since finding out about his diabetes. I know it's the wrong reason to like him but that hit close to home (my 16 year old has it). I know what his life is like living with that disease and how his mom must feel. Besides, I'm not voting

[DavidMn]

Originally Posted by bikerchic

I now have a soft spot for Elliot, since finding out about his diabetes. I know it's the wrong reason to like him but that hit close to home (my 16 year old has it). I know what his life is like living with that disease and how his mom must feel. Besides, I'm not voting

I'm sory about that Theresa. My great aunt had diabetes for 10 years before she died, and I made her needles up every day. I remember she took Humulin N.

[Mageboy25]

Kelly is my favorite. That was a total Lita Ford Kiss Me Deadly video moment when Kelly got down on her knees and up real fast. She arouses my queer ass.

I HATE closet case queers like Ace trying to act straight. Will someone please stick the cane out on stage with the hook on it.

[cliffdweller]

Originally Posted by Mageboy25

Will someone please stick the cane out on stage with the hook on it.

funny visual!

[skcin]

Eh. I would have rather seen ACE go after that sickening verion of "We Will Rock You," but it's not like Bucky had a real chance to win, IMO.

I'm thinking Kellie & Chris will definitely be in the top 3 or 4, not sure about the others. Katharine is great, but not consistent. Elliot has a gorgeous voice, but I've heard many people don't like it. Taylor & Paris are always possibilities too. Ace doesn't have a chance in hell.

If it does come down to kellie & Chris, I think Chris would win. They already have Carrie Underwood for their country blondie. I mean, I hate to think that it's fixed, but you have to wonder. Winners were (excuse my generalizations) white pop/rock girl, then black R&B guy, then black R&B chick, then white country gal. We still don't have white rocker dude. Idol is all about marketing, and the more markets they cover, the better.

[JazmenFlowers]

Originally Posted by skcin

Eh. I would have rather seen ACE go after that sickening verion of "We Will Rock You," but it's not like Bucky had a real chance to win, IMO.

I'm thinking Kellie & Chris will definitely be in the top 3 or 4, not sure about the others. Katharine is great, but not consistent. Elliot has a gorgeous voice, but I've heard many people don't like it. Taylor & Paris are always possibilities too. Ace doesn't have a chance in hell.

If it does come down to kellie & Chris, I think Chris would win. They already have Carrie Underwood for their country blondie. I mean, I hate to think that it's fixed, but you have to wonder. Winners were (excuse my generalizations) white pop/rock girl, then black R&B guy, then black R&B chick, then white country gal. We still don't have white rocker dude. Idol is all about marketing, and the more markets they cover, the better.

...totally...

damnit...I haven't said that in so long I thought I was totally over using "totally" - but I guess old habits die hard

[Brwn_eyes0511]

My thoughts..

Chris - I usually am not a big fan of his.. and probably will never be.. he just isn't my cup of tea! However.. tonight I have to say he did a fantastic job..

Paris - AMAZING! I wanted to light up a cig., pour some wine, put on a tux and head out for a night of fun at the Coconut Grove in 1958.. just great.

Taylor - Started out a tad boring but he really nailed it at the end.. this guy has soul!

Elliot - I have to say I wasn't that impressed with his performance.. he did OK.. the vocals were there but it just came off as a tad boring.

Kellie - I LOVE LOVE LOVE "Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered" but boy oh boy did she screw this one up.. But I do have to give her credit for trying AND for KNOWING that she messed it up.

Ace - He sang one of my favorite songs.. EVER! "That's All" was perfected by my fav. singer Judy Garland in 1963.. so IMO anyone else's version will not even come close.. and his really just didn't "go there" for me.. That said, he did do much better than he has in a long while.. He is still fake and plastic to me.

Katharine - Glad they saved my girl for the end.. PERFECTION! She did this song justice.. and just was leaps and bounds better than everyone else tonight! And might I add.. this girl has a flawless complexion.. and I have High Definition TV.. so I see it all!


..overall this was the best night so far.. and this type of music is one of my favs. so I could be a bit biased!

[seeker007nmss]

ummm.... I have never seen the show.

[Patti]

I really enjoyed the show tonight. I like the standards and I thought they did a great job overall. Well except for Pickler. She sucked. I do think Ace will probably go. Taylor's ending was the highlight of the show for me. That was awesome! I've been trying to get some votes in for Elliott, but haven't been able to get through.

[BTFLCHLD]

chris' pants were way too tight and ace sucks

[CelticGypsy]

Chris did a good job. Taylor is my favorite so far. He really did a great ending of that song. I was getting a little worried in the beginning but I love Taylor LOVED Paris. She can sing for such a little girl. LOVED Katherine and she was the perfect one to end the show. She is great.

Pickler can GO HOME tomorrow.............PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE Even Rod Stewart could see right through her DUMB country girl ACT and if any man on earth knows a dumb, blonde, flakey girl......it is definitely Rod Stewart Rod and Penny's baby is very cute by the way.

[Mageboy25]

Kelly wasnt that bad. I hope someone gives her a real talk not to doubt herself on TV. Thats why everyone thinks shes bad, bc she called it 1st. Do what you know, and fake the rest.

[GypsySorcerer]

This was one of the better weeks. Can Pickler please leave now? I guess we learned last night that she forgot lyrics and words are one in the same.

Bottom three: Ace, Pickler, Elliott