American Idol: Season 5

[SuzeQuze]

Originally Posted by jannieC

And Kevin... Last night he reminded me of a little boy performing at his grandparent's nursing home...

ITA! He's sixteen but he's very immature and the song choices (and lisp) reflect that. He does have a nice sounding voice though and he can sing in tune, maybe he'll be ready in the future but he is not now.

I hate Gedeon's hair, I know, how shallow of me.

I usually don't even watch Taylor because the antics get too weird for me but I love the sound of his voice - I just listen.

Bucky was good last night I thought! The mustache needs to go.

Will, not bad, stupid song, not in the same league with the others.

Chris, boring song, good performance. I'm with you, Sorceress, bust out the Pearl Jam!

Elliot sounds good but I don't get the whole thing with him either. Maybe if he picked songs that really moved me I'd feel differently. Didn't he do Bryan Adams? WTF? Too vanilla.