Like or Dislike: Rose Garden

[SapphireSister]

Originally Posted by amber

Yay! You rock!

I know.

The tune is gross and not pretty to me.

The world tragic comes to mind. Sounds like something I'd hear at a horrible country show and feel the need to leave the room immediately. God forbid any non-fans heard this song! I’d never hear the end of it.

[ontheEdgeof17]

Originally Posted by SapphireSister

God forbid any non-fans heard this song! I’d never hear the end of it.

Just blast your Desert Angel for them with pride then. They will become instant fans, I'm sure.

[SapphireSister]

Originally Posted by ontheEdgeof17

Just blast your Desert Angel for them with pride then. They will become instant fans, I'm sure.

Works every time!

[SapphireSister]

Thanks guys I now have Rose Garden stuck in my head lol. .

[Dreammms]

Originally Posted by SapphireSister

Works every time!

Not always. One of my friends loves Desert Angel. But I love it too. Sooo

[Dreammms]

Originally Posted by amber

oh, god. It just gets worse. You like DA and RG, but not Cry Wolf. Good lord!

LOL

I think I have great Stevie song sense.

At least she wrote DA and RG and not the pitiful CRY WOLF. Any three year old can tell you what Cry Wolf means. I just don't like it. Can't. Won't. Yuck.

But at least we both love Kick It

[Nixxxed]

One of my all-time favorites. Especially:

"YES, and I've got money
Men to love me
And acres of land..."

Also, a very fun song to 2-step to.

[Dreammms]

Originally Posted by amber

Yes, and "Rose Garden" is so complex.
okay, I can't talk anymore, when people don't like Cry Wolf it sticks in my craw.
kisses.

Sensitive

It's okay I respect that you like it Amber. You too my Sharona.

[Dreammms]

Originally Posted by amber

well, I didn't mean it like that. You can say how much CW sucks all you want. I'll just silently seethe....

I think it's awesome how everybody gets so passionate about "their" songs

[Macfanforever]

As coming from the biggest country music fan on here, probably the only one too. I loooovvvveeee It. I love that song. that will be part of my Stevie Nicks goes Country cd mix.

[Nightbird17]

[QUOTE=skcin]The harmonies on this verse are amazing:[./QUOTE]


Ditto.....perfection

[Mad4stevie]

I love Rose Garden. I can relate to the words . . . being 32 and unmarried

[golden braid]

I gave Rose Garden a dozen beautiful red roses. I love this song. I love the country vibe, I love the lyrics, I love the simplicity. I know the lyrics might seem trite but Stevie wrote them so long ago and they actually came true. The song makes me feel a little sad every time I hear it.

[strandinthewind]

Originally Posted by amber

I'm suprised all you country lovers lke this so much.
Because most country singers I know, or have ever heard, would leave this vocal in Stevie's Glitter-Studded, Fabulously Catered Dust!!!

If I want to hear someone do a country song....
It will rarely be Stevie post 19eighty.....hrmm....6.5?


And the lyrics aren't that good either.

The whole song reminds me of something really, really, FLAT.

And the lyrics and/or the tune aren't good enough for me to tell if SOMEONE ELSE could have made it better.

I assume someone could have made it sound better,
but then I imagine that that version would have SUCKED too!

I mean, give it to Emmylou, Bonnie (Tylers and Raitts) , Dolly, Linda, Billie, Lindsey, Your Mom, The Guy Down the Road, Bette Midler, Doris Day, Shirley Muldowney, Norma Rae, Gloria, Baby Jane, and Pavoratti, - Maybe even one of the Juddsbarf, or a Dixie Chickhurl -
and it could still be crappy.
Although it could sound waaaaay better.

I think that is why her Enchanted live versions kick a$$.

[dissention]

Originally Posted by amber

I'm suprised all you country lovers lke this so much.
Because most country singers I know, or have ever heard, would leave this vocal in Stevie's Glitter-Studded, Fabulously Catered Dust!!!

If I want to hear someone do a country song....
It will rarely be Stevie post 19eighty.....hrmm....6.5?


And the lyrics aren't that good either.

The whole song reminds me of something really, really, FLAT.

And the lyrics and/or the tune aren't good enough for me to tell if SOMEONE ELSE could have made it better.

I assume someone could have made it sound better,
but then I imagine that that version would have SUCKED too!

I mean, give it to Emmylou, Bonnie (Tylers and Raitts) , Dolly, Linda, Billie, Lindsey, Your Mom, The Guy Down the Road, Bette Midler, Doris Day, Shirley Muldowney, Norma Rae, Gloria, Baby Jane, and Pavoratti, - Maybe even one of the Juddsbarf, or a Dixie Chickhurl -
and it could still be crappy.
Although it could sound waaaaay better.
We may never know.

Amen.

She wrote it as baby girl still going through puberty and it sounds like it.