random questions

[GateandGarden]

I've been thinking about all the questions I have for everyone for months now. At the moment, I can't remember all of them (as I never can and that always stops me from starting this very thread), but here are some and I might add to this thread later on. I didn't know where else to put it besides in this forum.

1) Has anyone read any articles that have given some insight into what Peter Green thinks about the incarnations of FM that came after him?

2) How does one obtain these much-talked-about Tusk documentaries?

3) About Bob Welch's "Forever." I love this song, though I know I'm one of the few. Does anyone know if he has ever said anything about it at all? Why he wrote it or anything?

4) Why is "Not that Funny" so much like "I Know I'm Not Wrong" but not nearly as good? The similarities are just too much to me. Why didn't he call "Not that Funny" "I Know I'm Not Wrong Part 2" or something? I suppose these are rhetorical questions.

5) Where is Erica? I haven't seen her post in awhile. Just wondering.

6) Is "Oh Diane" supposed to be about someone? I'm not mocking it by asking that; I really like the song a lot. Was there some inspiration for it?

Okay, that's all I've got right now.

[catinthedark]

I can't answer most of them... but they're definitely food for thought...

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

[COLOR=DarkRed]I've been thinking about all the questions I have for everyone for months now. At the moment, I can't remember all of them (as I never can and that always stops me from starting this very thread), but here are some and I might add to this thread later on. I didn't know where else to put it besides in this forum.

2) How does one obtain these much-talked-about Tusk documentaries?

I plugged in an eBay search thing, and everytime one came up on auction, I did my best... Finally, a very generous fellow poster from another board made me copies of her doc and her outtakes. It DOES come up on eBay pretty often - beware of copies of copies. The original exists, and you can get it every so often.

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

4) Why is "Not that Funny" so much like "I Know I'm Not Wrong" but not nearly as good? The similarities are just too much to me. Why didn't he call "Not that Funny" "I Know I'm Not Wrong Part 2" or something? I suppose these are rhetorical questions.

Have often wondered the same.

And I've often wondered about who Diane is, too. Good questions... I'm sure someone far more knowledgable will jump in...

[WildInTheWind]

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

2) How does one obtain these much-talked-about Tusk documentaries?

I bought an original BETA off Ebay. I thought it was VHS, and I got it and was like what the hell is this little tape?! I finally found someone to transfer it for me. You can get originals on Ebay, and sometimes even Amazon, but are probably better off getting it from a trader who has it on DVD. It's good stuff...I highly recomend it!

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

1) Has anyone read any articles that have given some insight into what Peter Green thinks about the incarnations of FM that came after him?

2) How does one obtain these much-talked-about Tusk documentaries?

3) About Bob Welch's "Forever." I love this song, though I know I'm one of the few. Does anyone know if he has ever said anything about it at all? Why he wrote it or anything?

4) Why is "Not that Funny" so much like "I Know I'm Not Wrong" but not nearly as good? The similarities are just too much to me. Why didn't he call "Not that Funny" "I Know I'm Not Wrong Part 2" or something? I suppose these are rhetorical questions.

5) Where is Erica? I haven't seen her post in awhile. Just wondering.

6) Is "Oh Diane" supposed to be about someone? I'm not mocking it by asking that; I really like the song a lot. Was there some inspiration for it?

Okay, that's all I've got right now.

1) Read his Q&A on this website. Overall, he seems to have nice things to say about the band. He and Jeremy both said they liked Stevie and Bekka.

2) EBay or trades. I got a CED copy of, so I had to buy a CED player. But, then, I also got Bob Welch & Friend "Live From The Roxy," the "Mirage" concert, and "Let It Be" on CED, so it was worth it. Unfortunately, I'm getting a lot of skipping, so these are just to satisfy my own curiousity.

3) The only thing I know about "Forever" is that they used a drum machine. If I'm not mistaken, he addressed this on his first epic Q&A on this very website.

4) There is an interesting theory that all of Lindsey's songs on "Tusk" are sort of a progression. On NTF, it's as if he feels everybody is blaming him for something, and his "don't blame me" is akin to "get off my back already." But, on IKINW, Lindsey sounds like he's more confident, "don't blame me...I know I'm not wrong," as in "hey, it's not MY fault." I want to say it was one of the Davids who came up with this theory. Makes sense to me.

5) I don't know.

6) I think Diana was a girlfriend of Lindsey's in the late 70s/early 80s.

[Hawkeye]

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

4) Why is "Not that Funny" so much like "I Know I'm Not Wrong" but not nearly as good? The similarities are just too much to me. Why didn't he call "Not that Funny" "I Know I'm Not Wrong Part 2" or something? I suppose these are rhetorical questions.

I absolutely agree they are very very similar and NTF probably developed out of IKINW, but I disagree that it's that it's not nearlya s good as IKINW. I think IKINW is Lindsey's best song ever so its hard for any song to be AS good, NTF is pretty danm close. I really love that song.

[macfan 57]

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

1) Has anyone read any articles that have given some insight into what Peter Green thinks about the incarnations of FM that came after him?

Recently I read a quote from Peter about the Rumours line-up. I'm not sure if it was this website or another one. Peter said that he thought Rumours was fabulous & that Christine wrote some wonderful songs after she joined the band. I have no idea when he said this.

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

2) How does one obtain these much-talked-about Tusk documentaries?

The commercially released Tusk documentary pops up on eBay from time to time. The winning bid price is usually VERY expensive. There are numerous traders who can copy this video for you however. There are other outtake & photo session bootleg videos that are very interesting as well.

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

5) Where is Erica? I haven't seen her post in awhile. Just wondering.

Erica just posted last evening in the Christine forum. She's had computer problems. She hopes to have her computer up and running this weekend.

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

6) Is "Oh Diane" supposed to be about someone? I'm not mocking it by asking that; I really like the song a lot. Was there some inspiration for it?

I've never heard that Lindsey had a girlfriend by the name of Diane. But, the song was a hit in the U.K. possibly because the name of the song was so similar to Princess Diana's name.

Also, you're not the only person who likes "Forever". I think it's terrific too.

[GateandGarden]

Thanks for all the answers, y'all! Looks like I need to visit ebay and definitely look more at the Q&A section on this site. Thanks!

Originally Posted by Hawkeye

I absolutely agree they are very very similar and NTF probably developed out of IKINW, but I disagree that it's that it's not nearlya s good as IKINW. I think IKINW is Lindsey's best song ever so its hard for any song to be AS good, NTF is pretty danm close. I really love that song.

I know what you mean. I'm really starting to love NTF, but I think IKINW is one of FM's all-time best, so that's where I'm coming from with that.

[GateandGarden]

Originally Posted by macfan 57

Erica just posted last evening in the Christine forum. She's had computer problems. She hopes to have her computer up and running this weekend.

Ah! I just noticed her post. Thanks!

Also, you're not the only person who likes "Forever". I think it's terrific too.

Yay!

[David]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

1) Read his Q&A on this website. Overall, he seems to have nice things to say about the band. He and Jeremy both said they liked Stevie and Bekka.

I doubt Peter & Jeremy could name, or even recognize, five songs by Stevie Nicks -- which is just about the number she could name of theirs!

3) The only thing I know about "Forever" is that they used a drum machine. If I'm not mistaken, he addressed this on his first epic Q&A on this very website.

"Forever" is a lovely tune. People talk a lot about Christine's being a "rhythm" player, but they don't seem to know what they themselves mean. But the piano arrangement in "Forever" is a perfect example of that -- it's a bass-like part that helps lay rhythmic foundations.

4) There is an interesting theory that all of Lindsey's songs on "Tusk" are sort of a progression. On NTF, it's as if he feels everybody is blaming him for something, and his "don't blame me" is akin to "get off my back already." But, on IKINW, Lindsey sounds like he's more confident, "don't blame me...I know I'm not wrong," as in "hey, it's not MY fault." I want to say it was one of the Davids who came up with this theory. Makes sense to me.

Not me -- I almost never play these intentional fallacy games with lyrics. But certainly those songs are similar in lyrical content; the elliptical, almost paratactic approach in the orchestration; the cards-on-the-table attitude; & the low-period rupture of the performance.

[shackin'up]

Originally Posted by David

"Forever" is a lovely tune. People talk a lot about Christine's being a "rhythm" player, but they don't seem to know what they themselves mean. But the piano arrangement in "Forever" is a perfect example of that -- it's a bass-like part that helps lay rhythmic foundations.

I agree here. Always loved "forever". But this time epecially because of Johns' parts.

[HomerMcvie]

Originally Posted by shackin'up

I agree here. Always loved "forever". But this time epecially because of Johns' parts.

I'm a guitar player, not a bass player, but ANYtime I pick up a bass, that's the bass lick I play. And I always hear, "what song is that?"

[GateandGarden]

Originally Posted by David

I doubt Peter & Jeremy could name, or even recognize, five songs by Stevie Nicks -- which is just about the number she could name of theirs!

If so, that's really unfortunate if each of them doesn't know more than that about the other.

[chiliD]

Originally Posted by David

I doubt Peter & Jeremy could name, or even recognize, five songs by Stevie Nicks -- which is just about the number she could name of theirs!

Hmmmm, actually, I give Stevie the benefit of the doubt here. Especially considering that when they were offered the Fleetwood Mac gig back in '75, she went out & bought all FMac's back catalogue of albums and, as she said, "listened to them back to front".

Also, I think Jeremy could, since side 2 of his Flee album is, for all intents, a Rumours-era Fleetwood Mac parody.

Now, Peter, I'll give you that he barely knows about BOB WELCH, much less Buckingham & Nicks.

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by GateandGarden

If so, that's really unfortunate if each of them doesn't know more than that about the other.

It is, but it's completely understandable. Stevie and Lindsey were more focused on getting their material out there early on, and Peter and Jeremy were both in bad places during the "Rumours" Mac's heyday. Such is life. Although, it has to be said that Jeremy's kids have a band that covers "Rhiannon," so who knows.

[GateandGarden]

Originally Posted by SteveMacD

It is, but it's completely understandable. Stevie and Lindsey were more focused on getting their material out there early on, and Peter and Jeremy were both in bad places during the "Rumours" Mac's heyday. Such is life. Although, it has to be said that Jeremy's kids have a band that covers "Rhiannon," so who knows.

Well, I can understand that, but if I were any of them, I would've taken the time to buy those records and listen to them at some point. I think it's of importance to anyone who was once in the band. At the time of Rumours heyday, Peter and Jeremy may not have been in the position to be kicking back to "Gold Dust Woman," but they could've caught up later on. It's been quite a few years.

I had thought about Stevie listening to all the older Mac albums when she and Lindsey were offered jobs with the band, but it occurred to me that she might have listened just for that purpose and then never picked them up again. I've done things like that when I had to educate myself on something quickly but I didn't genuinely care about it for any other purposes. But I could be totally wrong; it's just an idea about what may have happened.