American Idol

[darklinensuit]

Originally Posted by skcin

LMAO!

I actually thought this was John's best week in a few weeks (although I had a hard time stomaching the song Mandy - ugh!) Very disappointed in George, this was clearly his worst performance, I'm surprised the judges weren't harder on him. Jasmine - ehhh, she's blah. This was also the first week I didn't like Fantasia. Jennifer was best, IMO, Latoya second. I just realized Diana reminds me of a Cabbage Patch Doll, so that's all I can think of when she's on.

Anyone else notice how egotistical Barry was? With every performance, he had some comment "well, when I arranged this one..." "I wrote this song, and was a huge hit for so&so..." "Of course, with my catalog of songs, you need great range..." "I have so many songs, it's hard to pick one to sing..."

WTF? OK, we get it, you wrote a lot of songs. Congrats.

Pauila

I couldn't tell what was with Barry's eyes. Makeup or surgery? He looked like the love child of Rod Stewart and Joan Rivers.

- Jake

[GardenStateGirlie]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

Why would I need Viagara? I'm not YOUR husband.

- Jake

LOL!

And why would you need to worry about how I look? I'm not YOUR wife

[GardenStateGirlie]

Originally Posted by Violet

Every time I hear this song, it reminds me of the Will & Grace episode with Barry Manilow where Grace sang "Oh, Mommy" instead of Mandy and Karen introducing Jack: "This is Jack. He's a fagilow!" Cracks me up!!! I love that show!

Carol

Carol, I LOVE that episode with whats her name from Roseanne as the head of the Fanilows saying that if Will moves, she gets his spot.

[darklinensuit]

Originally Posted by GardenStateGirlie

LOL!

And why would you need to worry about how I look? I'm not YOUR wife

Yeah, but I can still speak up when my eyes bleed.

- Jake

[DeeGeMe]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

I couldn't tell what was with Barry's eyes. Makeup or surgery? He looked like the love child of Rod Stewart and Joan Rivers.

- Jake

The sad thing is that no amount of plastic surgery is going to make
Barry Manilow look good!

I really continue to like Fantasia--she's my girl. The growl in her voice & her riffs remind me a little of Miss Stevie. Jennifer was excellent this week. LaToya was good, but for some reason, I just don't feel a connection with her. I used to like George but he's wearing on my nerves now. John needs to say bye-bye. So does Diane or whatever the heck her name is. I thought she was terrible--I don't care what the judges say.

[Hawkeye]

I really continue to like Fantasia--she's my girl. The growl in her voice & her riffs remind me a little of Miss Stevie.

SOMEONE agrees with me.

[Hawkeye]

OMG they just sang Holiday Road

[WelshWitchPMD]

I know it. I just posted on the Rumours board.

[WelshWitchPMD]

Diana, Jasime and JOHN are all safe?? Are they kidding??

[Hawkeye]

OMG I'm NOT looking at this bottom 3. I'm NOT. I CAN'T BE. This PISSES me off and I just might boycott the danmed show if Fantasia leaves.

[GypsySorcerer]

What????!!!!??? The three best singers where in the bottom three?!! I am so pissed.....What the hell is wrong with America?

[GardenStateGirlie]

W H A T T H E H E L L.

Okay. John and George should have been the bottom three. I have to say that out of the three girls, Jennifer SHOULD NOT have been the one to go AT ALL. This says to me that America is evidently still lying around on the floor smoking dope WHICH CLEARLY IMPAIRS THEIR JUDGEMENT TO VOTE FOR THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL. IT also says to me that America is not a fan of a soulful voice and there are a few in this competition. I'm glad Ryan made a plea to America....vote on talent...too bad no one will listen.

Oh, and am I the only one that was incredibly excited they sang Holiday Road. I actually *SQUEEE!!*'d.

[Sorceress]

It's clear that for the sake of all good sense, we all have to vote for Fantasia next week. We have to overtake the teenyboppers who have no taste and nothing better to do than hit redial 85 million times for two hours straight.
It's true--there would be no point in watching the competition if Fantasia goes too! The results of tonight's show are just disgusting.

[GardenStateGirlie]

Originally Posted by darklinensuit

Yeah, but I can still speak up when my eyes bleed.

- Jake

Oh, because i'm SO downright hideous....

Wellll...you don't have to look now do you?

[Patti]

Fantasia's ok...but LaToya is where it's at.

Patti