SYW Song Survivor "by the numbers"

[DownOnRodeo]

Originally posted by seteca
This is the best collection of Stevie songs on a Fleetwood Mac album since Tusk: songs 1 to 17 are superb.
Song 18 has been permanently removed from my playlist.

Well said!
And I don't know about you but in many ways, Silver Girl gets a bad rap from me *because* the other Stevie songs are so damn good. If Silver Girl had been on Mirage or Tango, it might have fitted in better (for me).


Oh BTW, needless to say, Not Make Believe is no. 1 or 2 for me. No Limit is greatness too, but he didn't write it, so ...

[jwd]

Hey Brett I hope you have a calculator handy!

I too agree about SYW being Stevie's best collection of songs since Tusk. And Lindsey's best collection of songs since OOTC....or was that his last collection of songs?!


Great feedback everyone! Keep them COMEing.



Joe

[sodascouts]

Here's me!

1. Everybody Finds Out
2. Red Rover
3. Running Through the Garden
4. Steal Your Heart Away
5. Thrown Down (SO exceeds the demo!)
6. Peacekeeper
7. Destiny Rules
8. Come (although I LOVE it live!)
9. Bleed to Love Her
10. What's the World Coming To
11. Say You Will
12. Say Goodbye
13. Goodbye Baby
14. Miranda
15. Smile at You
16. Murrow
17. Silver Girl
18. Illume

[Nightbird_Brett]

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by jwd
Hey Brett I hope you have a calculator handy!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


LOL....Yep Joe! I definitely had a calculator for this!

Here are the current results guys. (Quite a difference from the first set of results, eh?)

1. Thrown Down (6.48)
2. Everybody Finds Out (6.6)
3. Illume (7.32)
4. Running Through The Garden (7.56)
4. Steal Your Heart Away (7.56)
6. Say You Will (8.12)
7. Destiny Rules (8.24)
8. Peacekeeper (9.24)
9. Say Goodbye (9.56)
10. Goodbye Baby (9.76)
11. Red Rover (10.16)
12. Murrow (10.36)
13. Miranda (10.4)
14. Smile At You (10.6)
15. Come (10.64)
16. What's The World Coming To (10.76)
17. Bleed To Love Her (11.64)
18. Silver Girl (16)

[jwd]

Excellent job Brett! And "Thrown Down" is currently on top. Interesting indeed.



Joe

[LV-Alpha]

Let's see...

1.) Murrow
2.) Red Rover
3.) Come
4.) Destiny Rules
5.) Miranda
6.) Say Goodbye
7.) Steal Your Heart Away
8.) Everybody Finds Out
9.) Thrown Down
10.) What's The World Coming To?
11.) Peacekeeper
12.) Say You Will
13.) Bleed To Love Her
14.) Goodbye Baby
15.) Illume
16.) Running Through The Garden
17.) Smile At You
18.) Silver Girl

Not Make Believe and the "Wall of Sound" version of Thrown Down would certainly be in my top 5 but they are on the extra disc so I won't count them.

[~nightbird~]

Add mine to the tally...

1.What's The World Coming To
2.Steal Your Heart Away
3.Red Rover
4.Miranda
5.Thrown Down
6.Peacekeeper
7.Smile At You
8.Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
9.Destiny Rules
10.Say Goodbye
11.Come
12.Bleed To Love Her
13.Everybody Finds Out
14.Illume
15.Goodbye Baby
16.Running Through The Garden
17.Sliver Girl
18.Say You Will

[Sugar]

WOW this is crazy tough! This is my "first initial feeling":

1. Red Rover
2. Illume
3. Thrown Down
4. Miranda
5. Murrow
6. Destiny Rules
7. WTWCT
8. Say You Will
9. Goodbye Baby
10. SYHA
11. EFO
12. Come
13. RTTG
14. Peacekeeper
15. Smile At You
16. Say Goodbye
17. BTLH
18. Silver Girl

[promogirl]

1) Bleed to Love Her
2) Peacekeeper
3) What's The World Coming To?
4) Miranda
5) Red Rover
6) Smile at You
7) Steal Your Heart Away
8) Say Goodbye
9) Thrown Down
10) Say You Will
11) Everybody Finds Out
12) Murrow
13) Silver Girl
14) Come
15) Goodbye Baby
16) Running Through the Garden
17) Illume
18) Destiny Rules

[Janet]

List time!

1. Running Through the Garden
2. Red Rover
3. Say Goodbye
4. Everybody Finds Out
5. Come
6. Illume
7. Peacekeeper
8. Thrown Down
9. Destiny Rules
10. Miranda
11. Bleed To Love Her
12. WTWCT ( end saves the song)
13. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
14. SYW
15. Steal Your Heart Away ( only b/c I was tired of it b4 album came out)
16. Smile At You ( demo spoiled me)
17. Goodbye Baby( demo spoiled me)
18. Silver Girl ( I cant stand this song)

[Sarah]

1. Everybody Finds Out
2. Murrow Turning Over in His Grave
3. Thrown Down
4. Smile at You (Love the demos, but love SYW version more.)
5. Red Rover
6. Peacekeeper
7. Running Through the Garden
8. Say You Will
9. Say Goodbye
10. Come
11. Goodbye Baby
12. Miranda
13. What's The World Coming To?
14. Steal Your Heart Away
15. Destiny Rules (Goaty Factor.)
16. Bleed To Love Her (Good song, but there's too much noodling at the end, Liddy. Just end the song already.)
17. Silver Girl (Boring.)
9,847,293,927,472. Illume (Blows.)

Oops, did I accidentally rate Illume the Worst Song of All Time?

[face of glass]

Final results? You decide. But first, a bit of humour.

Originally posted by ~nightbird~
17.Sliver Girl

And now the current results:

1. Thrown Down (6.78125)
2. Everybody Finds Out (6,8125)
3. Steal Your Heart Away (8,1875)
4. Illume (8,4375)
5. Red Rover (8,5625)
Running Through The Garden (8,5625)
7. Destiny Rules (8,625)
8. Say You Will (8,90625)
9. Peacekeeper (9,15625)
10. Say Goodbye (9,34375)
11. Murrow (9,40625)
12. Miranda (9,6875)
13. What’s The World Coming To (10,28125)
14. Come (10,46875)
15. Goodbye Baby (10,78125)
16. Smile At You (11,03125)
17. Bleed To Love Her (11,375)
18. Silver Girl (16,1875)

“We’ve come to take you over�!

[darklinensuit]

Originally posted by face of glass
Final results? You decide. But first, a bit of humour.

In that case I'll vote for Silver Grill. (I like the George Foreman demo much better.)

- Jake

[Travis]

Being that I love Stevie, most of her songs are going to be near the top, but I will try and be as object as I can to the CD as a whole. Here goes:



01-Destiny Rules
02-Goodbye Baby
03-Everybody Finds Out
04-Say You Will
05-Thrown Down
06-Illume (9/11)
07-Steal Your Heart Away
08-Silver Girl
09-Peacekeeper
10-Smile At You
11-Bleed To Love Her
12-Miranda
13-What's The World Coming To
14-Running Through The Garden
15-Say Goodbye
16-Come
17-Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
18-Red Rover

Depsite the fact that I mostly love Stevie's songs more, I think this is my honest list of faves in order.

Travis

[~nightbird~]

Final results? You decide. But first, a bit of humour.



quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by ~nightbird~
17.Sliver Girl
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DUH! ::slaping forehead:: So, that's what the "Preview Reply" is for...to catch spelling errors! LOL

::extends hand in friendship:: Nice to meet you Face of Glass!