SYW Song Survivor "by the numbers"

[jwd]

So a lot of you were whining about the outcome of the Survivor poll. Usually that's just the way the game works, if you've ever watched it play out on tv. The strongest or the favorites don't always win.

To get a different perspective on what we think are the most liked songs from SYW, I thought it'd be kind of interesting to rank them from 1 to 18(1 being the most liked and 18 the least liked). Then average the numbers of each ledgie to a final list at the end. Of course this probably should be done throughout the course of the thread to get a good idea of the standing of the songs as we go. If anyone is bored and wants to do the math jump right in.


Here's my ranking and will be the ranking of the ledge until they get "corrupted" by someone else.


1. Illume
2. Say You Will
3. Red Rover
4. Thrown Down
5. Murrow
6. Goodbye Baby
7. Say Goodbye
8. Everybody Finds Out
9. Steal Your Heart Away
10. Destiny Rules
11. Come
12. Miranda
13. Peacekeeper
14. Smile At You
15. Running Through The Garden
16. What's The World Coming To
17. Bleed To Love Her
18. Silver Girl



Joe

[wondergirl9847]

Well, sort of a list...LOVE LISTS!! Here ya go:

1. Red Rover
2. Come
3. Murrow
4. EFO
5. Destiny Rules
6. Smile at You
7. Peacekeeper
8. Illume
9. Say Goodbye
10. Miranda
11. RTTG
12. Steal Your Heart Away
13. Bleed to Love Her
14. Thrown Down
15. WTWCT
16. Goodbye Baby
17. Say You Will
18. Silver Girl

1 - 3 and 16-18 were easy, it's the rest that's difficult to rank.

[Nightbird_Brett]

This is a great idea Joe! I love lists too! Here is mine:

1. Thrown Down
2. Say You Will
3. Everybody Finds Out
4. Come
5. Say Goodbye
6. Running Through The Garden
7. Red Rover
8. Peacekeeper
9. Destiny Rules
10. What's The World Coming To
11. Goodbye Baby
12. Illume
13. Bleed To Love Her
14. Steal Your Heart Away
15. Murrow
16. Smile At You
17. Miranda
18. Silver Girl

[Nightbird_Brett]

I also love to do math, so here are the current rankings with their averages in parentheses: (I hope this is how you wanted to do it Joe.)

1. Red Rover (3.7)
2. Everybody Finds Out (5)
3. Come (5.7)
4. Thrown Down (6.3)
5. Illume (7)
5. Say Goodbye (7)
5. Say You Will (7)
8. Murrow (7.7)
9. Destiny Rules (8)
10. Peacekeeper (9.3)
11. Running Through The Garden (10.7)
12. Goodbye Baby (11)
13. Steal Your Heart Away (11.7)
14. Smile At You (12)
15. Miranda (13)
16. What's The World Coming To (13.7)
17. Bleed To Love Her (14.3)
18. Silver Girl (18)

[Ali]

1. Say You Will
2. What's The World Coming To
3. Steal Your Heart Away
4. Miranda
5. Murrow
6. Peacekeeper
7. Say Goodbye
8. Everybody Finds Out
9. Bleed To Love Her
10. Smile At You
11. Running Through The Garden
12. Thrown Down
13. Red Rover
14. Come
15. Destiny Rules
16. Goodbye Baby
17. Illume
18. Silver Girl

[iamstevienicks]

*also loves lists*

1.Illume
2.Running through the garden
3.Destiny rules
4.Smile at you
5.Everybody finds out
6.Thrown down
7.Come
8.Goodbye baby
9.Bleed to love her
10.Say you will
11.Steal your heart away
12.Peacekeeper
13.Say goodbye
14.Miranda
15.Whats the world coming to
16.Murrow
17.Red rover
18.Silver girl

Oops looks like I dragged the average of Red rover down, Oh well

[darklinensuit]

Why not. I feel like ticking some folks off today anyway.

1) Running through the Garden
2) Goodbye Baby
3) Say You Will
4) Steal Your Heart Away
5) Illume
6) Thrown Down
7) Murrow
8) Miranda
9) Smile at You
10) Peacekeeper
11) Silver Girl
12) Destiny Rules
13) Bleed to Love Her
14) Everybody Finds Out
15) What's the World Coming To
16) Say Goodbye
17) Come
18) Red Rover

- Jake

[TwoTricky]

1. Illume
2. Everybody Finds Out
3. Goodbye Baby
4. Miranda
5. Steal Your Heart Away
6. Running Through The Garden
7. What's The World Coming To
8. Say Goodbye
9. Bleed To Love Her
10. Thrown Down
11. Come
12. Smile At You
13. Destiny Rules
14. Say You Will
15. Peacekeeper
16. Murrow
17. Red Rover
18. Silver Girl

[jwd]

I also love to do math, so here are the current rankings with their averages in parentheses: (I hope this is how you wanted to do it Joe.)

Yep. Keep up the good work Brett!




Joe

[DownOnRodeo]

1. Murrow Turning Over In His Grave
2. Running Through The Garden
3. Illume
4. Thrown Down
5. Come
6. Red Rover
7. Destiny Rules
8. Say You Will
9. Goodbye Baby
10. Everybody Finds Out
11. Say Goodbye
12. Steal Your Heart Away
13. Peacekeeper
14. What's The World Coming To
15. Smile At You
16. Miranda
17. Bleed To Love Her
18. Silver Girl

[face of glass]

Note that everything before has been done by completely biased persons. The following is the only objective list.

1. Murrow / Red Rover (10/10 points each)
3. Bleed To Love Her / Come / Everybody Finds Out / Not Make Believe / Running Through The Garden / Say Goodbye / Thrown Down (9,5/10 each)
10. Destiny Rules / Goodbye Baby / Miranda / Say You Will / Smile At You (9/10 each)
15. Love Minus Zero - No Limit / What's The World Coming To (8,5/10 each)
17. Illume (8/10)
18. Peacekeeper (7,5/10)
19. Silver Girl / Steal Your Heart Away (7/10 each)

So, how will Stevie and Lindsey do against each other?

LB average: 8,9
SN average: 8,9

Hah.

[dissention]

Originally posted by face of glass
The following is the only objective list.

Only I know objectivity.

My rankings:

1. Say Goodbye
2. Running Through the Garden
3. Murrow
4. Come
5. Everybody Finds Out
6. Smile At You
7. Miranda
8. Goodbye Baby
9. Illume
10. What's the World Coming To
11. Steal Your Heart Away
12. Peacekeeper
13. Red Rover
14. Destiny Rules
15. Say You Will
16. Bleed to Love Her
17. Silver Girl
18. Thrown Down

[Christopher]

Alrighty then...here goes.....

1. DESTINY RULES
2. Illume
3. Running through the garden
4. Steal your heart away
5. Everybody Finds Out
6. Red Rover
7. Smile At you
8. Thrown Down
9. Say you Will
10. Peacekeeper
11 Silver Girl
12. Miranda
13. Goodbye Baby
14. Say Goodbye
15. Bleed To Love her
16. Murrow
17. Whats the World coming to
18. Come

[stefan]

Not too easy- but here we go
1.Red rover
2.Come
3.Peacekeeper
4.Murrow
5.Illume
6.Say goodbye
7.Steal your heart away
8. What's the world coming to
9.Smile at you
10.Thrown down
11.Miranda
12. Destiny rules
13. Running through the garden
14. Everybody finds out
15. Say you will
16.Bleed to love her
17. Goodbye baby
18. Silver girl
Stefan

[joe68]

1 Destiny Rules
2 Thrown Down
3 Say You Will
4 Illume
5 Miranda
6 Running Through The Garden
7 Peacekeeper
8 Goodbye Baby
9 Bleed To Love her
10 Steal Your Heart Away
11 Smile At You
12 Silver Girl
13 Whats the World Coming to
14 Everybody Finds Out
15 Say Goodbye
16 Murrow
17 Red Rover
18 Come