"In Your Dreams" survivor round

[mitzo]

Originally Posted by KarmaContestant

Thing is, despite differences of opinion here (and excluding New Orleans which I personally do not like at all) this remaing batch of songs is some of the best material to be on one single Stevie album since Bella Donna. I think many of us would be hard pressed to decide which songs to eliminate going forward. For me, Everybody Loves You is would be in the top 5 for IYD if I made a list of the songs in order. I also love For What It's Worth.

Funny, I wholeheartedly agree about ELY, but FWIW ranks at the very bottom of anything she has ever ever done. Ever.

[mitzo]

For What It's Worth - 16 (-1)
In Your Dreams - 15
Wide Sargasso Sea - 18
New Orleans - 14
Moonlight - 15
Annabel Lee - 17
Everybody Loves You - 19 (+1)
You May Be The One - 13
Italian Summer - 10

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by TheWILDheart

NEW RULE seeing as we're getting a little stuck....

If a song drops into SINGLE FIGURES, it's OUTTA HERE...that sound ok?

Originally Posted by redbird

That's same as docking 11 points from each song, right? Maybe we should just adjust the numbers?

I'm fine with either way. You could just drop all the songs by like 6 or 7 points.

[Christopher]

For What It's Worth - 16
In Your Dreams - 15
Wide Sargasso Sea - 18
New Orleans - 14
Moonlight - 16 +
Annabel Lee - 17
Everybody Loves You - 19
You May Be The One - 13
Italian Summer - 9 -

[StevieNicksfann]

For What It's Worth - 16
In Your Dreams - 15
Wide Sargasso Sea - 18
New Orleans - 14
Moonlight - 16
Annabel Lee - 17
Everybody Loves You - 19
You May Be The One - 12
Italian Summer - 10

[johnnystorms]

For What It's Worth - 16
In Your Dreams - 15
Wide Sargasso Sea - 17 (-1)
New Orleans - 14
Moonlight - 16
Annabel Lee - 17
Everybody Loves You - 19
You May Be The One - 13 (+1)
Italian Summer - 10

[MikeInNV]

This will never end. A couple days ago "Italian Summer" was down to two, but it couldn't be killed off and now it's back in double digits.

[redbird]

Okay, MacshadowsBall and TheWildHeart and I are fine with speeding this up via some points flooring. We'd better get some kind of majority with that ASAP because if everyone's agreed then "Italian Summer" has been eliminated a few times already.

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by MikeInNV

This will never end. A couple days ago "Italian Summer" was down to two, but it couldn't be killed off and now it's back in double digits.

That's why it's lasting for so long. The votes are just being rearranged!

Originally Posted by redbird

Okay, MacshadowsBall and TheWildHeart and I are fine with speeding this up via some points flooring. We'd better get some kind of majority with that ASAP because if everyone's agreed then "Italian Summer" has been eliminated a few times already.

Here's my idea...the second number reflects what the new score would be (basically subtracting ten from each score, ten was the base used at the beginning of the game.)

For What It's Worth - 16 - - - - - 6
In Your Dreams - 15 - - - - - -- - 5
Wide Sargasso Sea - 17 - - - - - - 7
New Orleans - 14 - - - - - - - - - - 4
Moonlight - 16 - - - - - - - - - - - - 6
Annabel Lee - 17 - - - - - - - - - - - 7
Everybody Loves You - 19 - - - 9
You May Be The One - 13 - - - - 3
Italian Summer - 10 - - - - - - - 1

[redbird]

That looks great to me, MacShadowsBall.

[MacShadowsBall]

Originally Posted by redbird

That looks great to me, MacShadowsBall.

Thanks.

Also we could vote plus or minus 2 instead of just 1 - even quicker...

[TheWILDheart]

EXCELLENT!! Lets go...

For What It's Worth - 6
In Your Dreams - 5
Wide Sargasso Sea - 7
New Orleans - 4
Moonlight - 6
Annabel Lee - 7
Everybody Loves You - 8 -
You May Be The One - 4 +
Italian Summer - 1

[gypsy-sara]

For What It's Worth - 6
In Your Dreams - 5
Wide Sargasso Sea - 7
New Orleans - 4
Moonlight - 6
Annabel Lee - 7
Everybody Loves You - 8
You May Be The One - 3 -
Italian Summer - 2 +

[mitzo]

For What It's Worth - 5
In Your Dreams - 5
Wide Sargasso Sea - 7
New Orleans - 4
Moonlight - 6
Annabel Lee - 7
Everybody Loves You - 9
You May Be The One - 3
Italian Summer - 2

[TheWILDheart]

For What It's Worth - 5
In Your Dreams - 6 +
Wide Sargasso Sea - 7
New Orleans - 4
Moonlight - 6
Annabel Lee - 7
Everybody Loves You - 8 -
You May Be The One - 3
Italian Summer - 2