Is this a fake?

[Johnny Stew]

KarmaContestant -- my opinion is that it's a fake, for all the reasons you cited (lack of catalog number, different than the other known official promo release, etc).

Additionally, this seller has a listing for the "Secret Love" video on DVD -- with the insistence that he doesn't sell bootlegs or copies. To the absolute best of my knowledge (and I'm pretty OCD about tracking these things down), there is NO promo DVD for the "Secret Love" video.