Idol Alum Say Stevie Should Be New Judge! - Page 3

jwd · #31 07-28-2012, 12:02 PM

She won't do this. It's not in her blood to sit in a chair every week and critique AI contestants. She wants to sing, dance, and be a part of a great romance. Still forbidden, still outrageous.

michelej1 · #32 07-28-2012, 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by olive

It would be like CHER doing an INFOMERCIAL

That caused Cher quite a career setback. I'm not sure AI would have the same effect on Stevie's career. But that raises a question: has anyone considered Cher for a seat as a judge? She certainly likes to give her opinion on things, why not singers?

Michele

olive · #33 07-28-2012, 02:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michelej1

That caused Cher quite a career setback. I'm not sure AI would have the same effect on Stevie's career. But that raises a question: has anyone considered Cher for a seat as a judge? She certainly likes to give her opinion on things, why not singers?

Michele

i saw the show twice the first time when it first started and wasn't sure what i was watching with all the coke commercials the last time was this past season, for 10 minutes , i couldn't take any more of it and left and it was on at a bar and they spent more time on critiquing the persons look , STEVEN TYLER , would have never made it past auditions based on looks and j-lo would have failed miserably with out the aid of auto tune and computer assistants . I think CHER has better things to do like promote a new cd with songs by gaga and P!NK and tour than i-DULL.

MrStevie · #34 07-28-2012, 04:22 PM

I'd hate to see Stevie doing this kind of thing. So lame.

Dreamz19 · #35 07-28-2012, 07:51 PM

I have mixed feelings about this. I used to watch the show, but stopped caring years ago even before Simon left. I really would hate to have to watch it again, but I would for Stevie. I guess whatever is best for her I will support, but hopefully best for her is not this show.

michelej1 · #36 07-28-2012, 08:56 PM

It would be a perfect job for her after her touring days are over. Not right now. Though, it would increase her concert audiences. It would also take one year away from her creative work.

Michele

vivfox · #37 07-28-2012, 10:17 PM

Imagine if she were to do this. The press would have a field day ranking on her for wearing the same outfit every week.

Jondalar · #38 07-30-2012, 09:37 AM

She should be lucky to get this. It would generate her so much press. People who don't her music might buy her music out of curiosity. It would reinvigorate her career.

Fannymac · #39 07-30-2012, 03:08 PM

I still say my dream panel would be Chris Isaak, Cyndi Lauper and David Foster!
(With Stevie mentoring again, of course!)

WildHearted · #40 07-30-2012, 03:18 PM

I agree that this would be great for Stevie to do AFTER she can no longer physically/mentally tour...

But she's still creative and she still seems to want to tour and record... and I really wouldn't want her putting any of THAT on hold for a stint on Idol.

However, it'd be great for them to bring her back as a mentor as I honestly think she was one of the best they have ever had on there [and it seems the contestants felt similarly].

Jondalar · #41 07-30-2012, 03:40 PM

I'm not buying the arguement that Idol would stop from doing more albums. I think it would like a fire under her ass and help her move on from In Your Dreams. About touring, she has done way too much of that. She needs to stop it and create. Either ****tttttttt, or get off the pot!

WildHearted · #42 07-30-2012, 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jondalar

I'm not buying the arguement that Idol would stop from doing more albums. I think it would like a fire under her ass and help her move on from In Your Dreams. About touring, she has done way too much of that. She needs to stop it and create. Either ****tttttttt, or get off the pot!

If she's doing Idol, she won't have TIME to do another album while it's filming, will she? That's the problem. Not that it would like drain her creativity, but that it would drain her of time, and then once that time is up, she might be too tired/too whatever to want to record again.

Obviously it's all just speculation..

Jondalar · #43 07-31-2012, 04:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WildHearted

If she's doing Idol, she won't have TIME to do another album while it's filming, will she? That's the problem. Not that it would like drain her creativity, but that it would drain her of time, and then once that time is up, she might be too tired/too whatever to want to record again.

Obviously it's all just speculation..

What is the likleyhood of her doing another album anyway. She can record on the weekends or basically whenever she wants. She just has to give the demos to her producer and show up for the recording its not that hard. It's not that hard to do another album. She doesn't even have to be there for most it. The problem is motivation.

Fannymac · #44 07-31-2012, 03:07 PM

I don't think there's a lack of motivation on Stevie's part....I think she just needs to think more of herself and her career...she's concentrated on and worried about Fleetwood Mac too much over the last decade! (And this is coming from someone who REALLY wants a new FM album!!!!)

mikephxaz · #45 07-31-2012, 04:32 PM

Sorry . folks, Stevie would never be selected for a spot on the AI judge panel...ever. They need a "big name" and Stevie is not a name who would bring in viewers