Any Phil Collins fans out there? - Page 2

WildHearted · #16 12-16-2011, 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dodfather

Homer - That pun is GENIUS! Good work!

I'm not a Phil fan at all. I really can't bear him, other than In The Air Tonight and a couple of ones with Genesis (Jesus He Knows Me).

ughhhhh no! For me that's the worst one and I'm still enraged that that song beat the wonderful Aimee Mann to an Oscar (she was nominated for her work in Magnolia).

Well, I was a child when Tarzan came out, so maybe it's just the nostalgia from hearing the songs and buying the soundtrack and seeing them on Disney Channel and all that jazz...

PolishStevieFan · #17 12-16-2011, 12:15 PM

Just like I thought there are many people who diplomatically saying are not his biggest fans

But I think that he was truly a great songwriter, especially during the 80's. And "Sussudio" no matter how silly might sound its title, still it's one of the better singles of the decade. I also like "Dance Into The Light" which too soon went to dust bins

Phil has never been prolific artist in the eyes of critics but 100 million fans all over the world can't be wrong

Best wishes for all Phil's fans

HomerMcvie · #18 12-16-2011, 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dodfather

Homer - That pun is GENIUS! Good work!

I'm not a Phil fan at all. I really can't bear him, other than In The Air Tonight and a couple of ones with Genesis (Jesus He Knows Me).

Thanks. I try to earn my keep!!!

And I COMPLETELY disagree about Sussudio(or however the hell it's spelled)....I think it was a big part of what ended his popularity, because it's so craptacular!

bluefox4000 · #19 12-16-2011, 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

Thanks. I try to earn my keep!!!

And I COMPLETELY disagree about Sussudio(or however the hell it's spelled)....I think it was a big part of what ended his popularity, because it's so craptacular!

I agree. I'm not ashamed to admit. I LOVED him in genesis. Loved him. As i said his first 2 solo records, face Value and Hello I must Be Going were brilliant. Then no Jacket came. Talk about a steaming pile of puke. I loath that album. Nothing from No Jacket on worked.

I still love him though.

Mick

vivfox · #20 12-16-2011, 04:21 PM

I feel bad for Phil. I read an article about him in Rolling Stone Magazine where he said he wants nothing to do with his musical past. Apparently he read some bad reviews on his 1980's output and seriously took it to heart. He does not feel appreciated. He now goes by the name of Phillip and won't answer to Phil any longer. Even his wife has to call him Phillip.
Could you imagine if Stevie took to heart all the bad reviews she got from the 1980's and then decided to only answer to the name Stephanie and never again perform any of her past songs?
Forgot to mention that Phil has arthritis so bad that he is unable to play drums today. He can only sing.

PolishStevieFan · #21 12-16-2011, 05:00 PM

As I wrote before I love "Sussudio". The lyrics are stupid but who cares? Do you remember a band named "Black Eyed Peas" and their "thought provoking" song "My Humps"? Is it any better? No. But musically "Sussudio" beats that song out. The horn section in this song is simply the greatest. To me this song sounds like Stevie's "Stand Back", it just draws you in right from the very start. Probably it's no coincidence that both "Stand Back" and "Sussudio" were heavily inspired by Prince's music at that time. And no matter what people say there was a life for Phil after "Face Value" and Genesis

For example my all time favourite album of him is "Both Sides"-self produced, self arranged, self-written and self-played gem. This album is truly remarkable, especially songs like "We Fly So Close", "Can't Find My Way" and "Everyday".

Macfanforever · #22 12-16-2011, 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vivfox

I feel bad for Phil. I read an article about him in Rolling Stone Magazine where he said he wants nothing to do with his musical past. Apparently he read some bad reviews on his 1980's output and seriously took it to heart. He does not feel appreciated. He now goes by the name of Phillip and won't answer to Phil any longer. Even his wife has to call him Phillip.
Could you imagine if Stevie took to heart all the bad reviews she got from the 1980's and then decided to only answer to the name Stephanie and never again perform any of her past songs?
Forgot to mention that Phil has arthritis so bad that he is unable to play drums today. He can only sing.

Wow .I did no t know this.Thats to bad the reviews got to him.I do remember Stevie was livid when the reviewers commented about her weight.Not her artistic works of her music.If I was in this position. I probably tell them where to go.Hum .Stevie won't answer to Stevie.

HomerMcvie · #23 12-17-2011, 02:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PolishStevieFan

As I wrote before I love "Sussudio".

And you are totally allowed! I'm one of the 3 (TOTAL) FM fans, who absolutely loves Sugar Daddy.

And I couldn't care less, who else doesn't like it.... F*CK em!!!!

People worry too much, about what everyone else thinks. If it works for you, that's all.that.matters,period.

tilthefirefades · #24 12-17-2011, 04:11 AM

I really couldn't care less about Phil Collins, but....

Someone hates Morrissey?!?!?!?! I mean wow, come on, I'm just speechless

ButterCookie · #25 12-17-2011, 04:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

And you are totally allowed! I'm one of the 3 (TOTAL) FM fans, who absolutely loves Sugar Daddy.

And I couldn't care less, who else doesn't like it.... F*CK em!!!!

People worry too much, about what everyone else thinks. If it works for you, that's all.that.matters,period.

You counted me in that total of 3, right?

I like Phil Collins's work with Frida Lyngstad.

PolishStevieFan · #26 12-17-2011, 09:42 AM

Okay so there are four of us

I really like "Sugar Daddy".

Dodfather · #27 12-17-2011, 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ButterCookie

I like Phil Collins's work with Frida Lyngstad.

I know there's something going on...

vivfox · #28 12-17-2011, 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HomerMcvie

absolutely loves Sugar Daddy.

I love SD and Warm Ways.

PolishStevieFan · #29 12-17-2011, 11:56 AM

"Warm Ways" is even better than "Sugar Daddy". In the beginning, after first few listens of "Fleetwood Mac" I did not care for these two songs but I've grown to appreaciate them and now I love them. My girlfriend absolutely loves "Warm Ways", it's one of her favourite FM songs ever! Every artist is entitled to record so called trash classic

You know... the song that is so bad that you actually love it

And going back to Phil...he did this thing more than few times but with great results.

HomerMcvie · #30 12-17-2011, 01:15 PM

Okay, so there are 5 of us that love Sugar Daddy. Warm Ways is alright, but a little to sleepy for me.

Sugar Daddy ROCKS!!!! I love every single nuance of the music! The piano intro, the way the drums kick in, and that B3!!!!! Musically, for me, it's the PERFEKT pop-ROCK song.

It makes it onto every single greatest FM hits CD I make(as does Think About Me, As Long As You Follow, and Love Shines).

Those four songs, are stellar examples, of why Chris was the biggest hitmaker. Pure Pop Perfektion!