The "In Your Dreams" Survivor Thread - Round Six

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by Phoenix

I used to like it. that's the problem this poll has ruined the song for me and
SOME people DO like it for that reason alone though, shipper! Shipper! Shipper!

Why would shippers like the song for romantic reasons? In it she is saying, "You'll never be the one for me, you low life liar. Dry your crocodile tears, take your fake apologies and leave."

That's not something that makes me go, "Oooooh, Stevie and Lindsey forevah!"

If shipper hearts were voting, I'd say that Italian Summer would be in the lead, because it is dreamy and loving and, yes, I do think it's about Lindsey and his guitar. Everybody Loves You is about Lindsey, according to Stevie. I don't see that in the lead.

I can understand that the song you like is losing, but I don't understand casting aspersions on people's motivation for liking other songs.

Michele

[Phoenix]

Originally Posted by Christopher

I guess I understand a little. You happen to not believe YMBTO deserves to be in the final four...or final six...or etc etc. It's all subjective and in good fun.
FWIW I am not a shipper skipper just running to the defense of one of my favorite songs from Stevie in a long long time.

Thanku
And for what its worth, I totally do you believe it deserves to be in the top 4
... Just AS number 4

[Phoenix]

[QUOTE=michelej1;1016683]Why would shippers like the song for romantic reasons? In it she is saying, "You'll never be the one for me, you low life liar. Dry your crocodile tears, take your fake apologies and leave."

That's not something that makes me go, "Oooooh, Stevie and Lindsey forevah!"

If shipper hearts were voting, I'd say that Italian Summer would be in the lead, because it is dreamy and loving and, yes, I do think it's about Lindsey and his guitar. Everybody Loves You is about Lindsey, according to Stevie. I don't see that in the lead.

I can understand that the song you like is losing, but I don't understand casting aspersions on people's motivation for liking other songs.
Michele[/QUOTE


Once again it's perfectly okay for other people to like another song I'm just sick of hearing about that 1 personally that is all

[Christopher]

Originally Posted by michelej1

Why would shippers like the song for romantic reasons? In it she is saying, "You'll never be the one for me, you low life liar. Dry your crocodile tears, take your fake apologies and leave."

That's not something that makes me go, "Oooooh, Stevie and Lindsey forevah!"

If shipper hearts were voting, I'd say that Italian Summer would be in the lead, because it is dreamy and loving and, yes, I do think it's about Lindsey and his guitar. Everybody Loves You is about Lindsey, according to Stevie. I don't see that in the lead.

I can understand that the song you like is losing, but I don't understand casting aspersions on people's motivation for liking other songs.

Michele

Yes! YMBTO is straight up in the pantheon of F**k you, Kiss my a$$ songs from Stevie's volcano such as "Long Way To Go", "Freedom", "Planets Of The Universe" (before she softened it a wee bit) & "Smile At You" pretty much.

[Phoenix]

Originally Posted by Christopher

Yes! YMBTO is straight up in the pantheon of F**k you, Kiss my a$$ songs from Stevie's volcano such as "Long Way To Go", "Freedom", "Planets Of The Universe" (before she softened it a wee bit) & "Smile At You" pretty much.

Wait wait, so this is a kiss off song? I thought this was a lovers lament song? ( Nobody freak out or throw stones, I'm asking)

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by Phoenix

I can understand that the song you like is losing, but I don't understand casting aspersions on people's motivation for liking other songs.
Michele[/QUOTE


Once again it's perfectly okay for other people to like another song I'm just sick of hearing about that 1 personally that is all

Yes, I know you're sick of it. I just didn't understand your SHIPPER. SHIPPER, SHIPPER conclusion.

This song has little positive to say about the relationship in question and many other songs that do are not winning out over FWIW, so your rationale for people keeping this song in the running out of blind love for SnL, just didn't seem logical. Maybe if you'd said that about Blue Denim I could understand it.

Michele

[WildHearted]

Originally Posted by Phoenix

Wait wait, so this is a kiss off song? I thought this was a lovers lament song? ( Nobody freak out or throw stones, I'm asking)

I think it's kind of both.

I think she's lamenting the fact that 'the one' for her can never actively BE the one for her.. but also kind of saying, screw you, you two faced bitch, I can't believe what you're saying, how could you do this to me, I used to love you so much.

[michelej1]

Yeah, and "Oh you're such a righteous hypocrite."

Michele

[WildHearted]

Originally Posted by michelej1

Yeah, and "Oh you're such a righteous hypocrite."

Michele

Yes, that too.

[jellyman10]

I think YMBTO is saying, 'We could have been so happy, if only we were different people, and by "we" I specifically mean you, Lindsey.'

[ontheEdgeof17]

How anti-climatic this turned out to be.

[jellyman10]

^^^ OK, sorry if I'm being thick, but is this poll finished? I thought the last two would go head-to-head to find the overall winner? Also, AL and YMBTO ended up tied on 40, so do we not vote again to separate them?

[TrueFaith77]

so... it's a tie?

[Christopher]

this. is. serious. ly not cool. could've had a death match between AL & YMBTO to break the tie, then continue until there was a true victor I somberly pledge not to squander more time with these frivilous polls eva again (mad hatter laugh)

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77

so... it's a tie?

No. Moonlight won.

Michele