Say You Will - Least Favorite Song

[McTrouble]

Oh no, what's going on - Red Rover is catching up, I'm getting all panicky!

[RickRobert]

Originally Posted by KarmaContestant

Oh, it's on now.

Oh it's definitely on

[Peestie]

Red Rover is one of my favourite Lindsey/Mac songs. It's just fantastic IMO.

Silver Girl is probably my least favourite from SYW but I still don't think I'd skip it. It's a bit bland but it's hardly offensive.

[jbrownsjr]

Originally Posted by TrueFaith77

Red Rover is one of Lindsey's greatest songs of all time.

Silver Girl reminds me of my first or second favorite Mary Gaitskill short stories of all time.

As much as I hate SYW, I do like Red Rover, it's interesting. See we do agree sometimes... lol

[caroline79]

Originally Posted by KarmaContestant

Good grief, this is easy - Red Rover. It doesn't even sound like a song; more like noise made by a human-imitating machine.

Originally Posted by louielouie2000

I actually like both songs... and I don't think I could dislike one over another.

Me too. I can't vote on this one.

[jellyman10]

Originally Posted by KarmaContestant

Good grief, this is easy - Red Rover. It doesn't even sound like a song; more like noise made by a human-imitating machine.

Mhmm.

[MacShadowsBall]

Poll closes tomorrow morning.

[mikephxaz]

Originally Posted by Neal

What do you mean "Almost"? It most certainly does make "Family Man" sound catchy!

"family man" and "red rover" and " holiday road" and go insane" and etc are the exact reasons why LB shouldn't ever produce fleetwood mac again...he can't help himself...uuuhhhggghhh...how do you say "over produced"?

[Peestie]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

"family man" and "red rover" and " holiday road" and go insane" and etc are the exact reasons why LB shouldn't ever produce fleetwood mac again...he can't help himself...uuuhhhggghhh...how do you say "over produced"?

I wouldn't call Holiday Road over produced. It's just a waif of a song. I can see the argument of Go Insane (the album) being considered overproduced though I don't agree. I think it's the perfect production for the style. Red Rover is just one of the best things Lindsey's ever done IMO.

I could live without Family Man but even the guitar on that one makes it worthwhile.

[MacShadowsBall]

With 17 votes, "Silver Girl" wins least favorite song from Say You Will.

Part 2 of the contest starts Monday.