Say You Will Alternates

[Peestie]

Originally Posted by gldstwmn

Actually, now that I think about it, the DVD A version of Say You Will did have some different... tweaks to the songs. I think it's most evident on Running Through The Garden. So I'm off to find that. Here's the Thrown Down I think you were originally talking about:

http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.ph...1955B4653C3F0F

Ever since I heard this version I've liked it more than the one that turned up on the album (though I still think it kicks serious ass), but the only thing that stops me listening to it more is that it's not as good quality . I just wish there was a lossless version out there. Anyone know if there is?

Actually, on more detailed listening, I don't think it's exactly the same as the one I have (5 seconds shorter and maybe slight differences here and there). The one I heard was the "single mix" and I don't remember where I got it, but I think it was buckinghamnicks.net.

[Johnny Stew]

Originally Posted by Peestie

The one I heard was the "single mix"

There was no actual "single mix" for "Thrown Down"... that was just the phrase some fans used to distinguish it from the album version.
It's also been called the "Wall of Sound" version.

As gldstwmn pointed out earlier in the thread, it's actually an outtake from the 'Trouble In Shangri-La' sessions.

[Peestie]

Originally Posted by Johnny Stew

There was no actual "single mix" for "Thrown Down"... that was just the phrase some fans used to distinguish it from the album version.
It's also been called the "Wall of Sound" version.

As gldstwmn pointed out earlier in the thread, it's actually an outtake from the 'Trouble In Shangri-La' sessions.

Ah right, cool. I didn't think it had been release as a single, but I wasn't sure. So were Lindsey's vocals just added then? What about drums and bass? If it's an out-take from one of her solo albums would John and Mick have been on it?

[Johnny Stew]

Originally Posted by Peestie

Ah right, cool. I didn't think it had been release as a single, but I wasn't sure. So were Lindsey's vocals just added then? What about drums and bass? If it's an out-take from one of her solo albums would John and Mick have been on it?

John and Mick aren't on that version, but Lindsey definitely is.

In 2000, Sheryl Crow talked to Billboard magazine and discussed working on 'TISL' with Stevie, and she mentioned that Lindsey had just been in the studio with them to record parts for two songs -- one of which would "really satisfy the diehard fans." (I paraphrased.)

(For the record, "Thrown Down" was released as a single in late November of 2003 -- simultaneously with "Steal Your Heart Away." But as they were released just as most AC stations were switching over to their Christmas music formats, neither received very much airplay.)

[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by Johnny Stew

John and Mick aren't on that version, but Lindsey definitely is.

There are some drum parts that definitely sound like Mick to me on that song. I'd like to know who did play the drums on it.

[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by Peestie

Ever since I heard this version I've liked it more than the one that turned up on the album (though I still think it kicks serious ass), but the only thing that stops me listening to it more is that it's not as good quality . I just wish there was a lossless version out there. Anyone know if there is?

Actually, on more detailed listening, I don't think it's exactly the same as the one I have (5 seconds shorter and maybe slight differences here and there). The one I heard was the "single mix" and I don't remember where I got it, but I think it was buckinghamnicks.net.

I've never come across a lossless version of that version of Thrown Down. I think it originally showed up on a German CD that was shipped to radio stations? Does anyone else remember that?
I like all versions of Thrown Down. I think the one in question would have sounded out of place on Say You Will though. The vocal and big rock sound are more compatible with Trouble In Shangri La, although it didn't quite with that record either.