Different "I Know I'm Not Wrong"?

[Peestie]

I saw this on amazon.com:

Unfortunately, I still have to recommend Tusk on vinyl as the optimal way to experience it. This is due to the fact that a bizarre version of "I Know I'm Not Wrong" was included, instead of the original vinyl version (it's the same version as on the last Tusk CD, I prayed they would fix this). I'd just like one person, ANYONE, to explain this to me, so I can feel better.

So, was there another version of IKINW on the vinyl one? Surely there wouldn't be? Seems very confusing to me.

[joshywashy377]

I know there is an alternate version on the Tusk Expanded but i dont know if it would be the same as Tusk on vinyl

[shackin'up]

The vinylversion of IKINW is definately different from all CD-releases. And for me....still the ultimate version, although I haven't heard it for years, due to the lack of a turntable, that I plan to reinstall again in the near future.

[Peestie]

Originally Posted by shackin'up

The vinylversion of IKINW is definately different from all CD-releases. And for me....still the ultimate version, although I haven't heard it for years, due to the lack of a turntable, that I plan to reinstall again in the near future.

I wonder why it was changed for the CD release then Seems strange. Be great to hear.

[golddustwoman77]

I have the vinyl and a turntable. When my dad gets out of the hospital, I'll listen to it, and tell you guys something about it.

[Johnny Stew]

I was surprised the alternate mix was included on the recent remaster/reissue. I had assumed the original vinyl mix would be restored to the main CD and that the alternate mix would be included on the second disc.

Since the band had to listen to and approve these remastered discs, I wonder if Lindsey prefers that alternate mix to the original.

I'm also kind of surprised that no one's ever ripped the original version from a cassette source, so that we could have a clean, hiss & pop-free mp3 of it.

[HejiraNYC]

Originally Posted by Peestie

I saw this on amazon.com:



So, was there another version of IKINW on the vinyl one? Surely there wouldn't be? Seems very confusing to me.

To my ears the CD version sounds exactly like the vinyl version, except the vinyl version does not have the background vocal arrangements on the "Don't blame me... please be strong" part of the chorus. I think the b/g vocals adds makes it quirkier; I definitely prefer the CD version.

[Johnny Stew]

Originally Posted by HejiraNYC

To my ears the CD version sounds exactly like the vinyl version, except the vinyl version does not have the background vocal arrangements on the "Don't blame me... please be strong" part of the chorus. I think the b/g vocals adds makes it quirkier; I definitely prefer the CD version.

There's some different instrumentation in the mix, too. The original album version is a little more bare-bones.

[joshywashy377]

I think i actually prefer the alternate Tusk Expanded version myself, i dont know why. Although the best has to be the recent live versions, no doubt!