a bit of a confession....Peacekeeper

[Cammie]

We agree with you Steve!!! Peacekeeper loses its powerful
nuances and the essence of a male voice to express its message! C.

[erwk05]

Just thought I would say Im a Lindsey Convert (used to be a Stevie Fan) but now Im a Die Hard Lindsey fan since 2003.

Had a listen to both versions, the only bit I feel is missing from lindseys version is that little drum roll about 3/4 of the way into the song (which is on the album version)

I think lindseys is more intence and errie sounding but I think the Album version has more depth - as provided by the rest of the band.

I think I prefer the SYW version - but only for micks little drum roll- thats intense

DW

[michelej1]

Don't like the song that much, so don't have a preference.

I have always said that I like the solo version of My Little Demon better than the group version But that may not be exactly true. I guess I think The Dance version is fine and fun, but I think the solo version had a different meaning and mood and I would have liked to see that released. At the very least, he should do that version in one of his solo sets.

Michele

[David]

Originally Posted by Peestie

Of all the GOS demos I like them more without the jammed in harmonies by Stevie.

You mean you don't think all those songs benefited from the sound of snot rattling around in Stevie Nicks's gullet?

[Peestie]

Originally Posted by David

You mean you don't think all those songs benefited from the sound of snot rattling around in Stevie Nicks's gullet?

I like the sound of the rattling snot but not the harmonies. The ultimate versions would remove the harmonies but retain the nasal sounds.

[MissLadyLoki]

Originally Posted by Lindsfan

Here you go Cassie:

http://www.mediafire.com/file/6cf56y...e%20Keeper.mp3

I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Lindsey's solo/demo version. I think it's a lot better than the SYW. Some songs I prefer with Stevie's harmonies added, but this isn't one of them! I love it when he harmonizes with himself, and this just sounds really cool with only male voices ( IMO ).
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Now i finally got around to downloading it. Anyways, I'm listening to it and I like it more than the album version.

[Cammie]

Good girl Cassie!!! Peacekeeper was a Lindsey
only... solo tune! The lyrics come alive!!! Tacked
on frivilous female vocalizing ruins the intent!!! C.

[MissLadyLoki]

Originally Posted by Cammie

Good girl Cassie!!! Peacekeeper was a Lindsey
only... solo tune! The lyrics come alive!!! Tacked
on frivilous female vocalizing ruins the intent!!! C.

Camme, can you check your PMs please?

Anyways, when I heard the original, I felt it was a more, for lack of a better word, manly song and to have female harmonies in it (as good as Stevie is, don't get me wrong, they sound great together) felt a bit odd.

[Little Nicki]

The solo versions also fits better in Lindsey vocal range due to its lower key. He sounds much more relaxed and less strained which I think benefits the song a lot. The harmonies are so much more lush and full too. Overall I think it just became a watered down pop song on Say You Will compared the intensity of the solo version.

[Nicks Fan]

I think both versions are really good but I do think that SYW as a whole was an album of missed opprotuities. Allot of Lindsey's songs should have been on solo albums because they didn't work as FM cuts. Murrow, Miranda, Come were songs that I felt were too experimental even for FM. I think the album would have done better if they had started from the ground up. Lindsey contributed some good songs but if you compare the other FM albums where he took some songs intended for solo releases and gave them over to Fleetwood Mac I think you will find much stronger material overall compared to what ended up on SYW.

[louielouie2000]

The funny thing is, I'm a dyed in the wool chiffonhead, but I actually think Stevie's presence on the Say You Will version of Peacekeeper ruins the atmosphere of the song. Her voice is just reedy and nasally sounding, and totally pierces the vibe. It's just annoying to listen to. The original Gift Of Screws version seems more harmonious.

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by Nicks Fan

I think both versions are really good but I do think that SYW as a whole was an album of missed opprotuities. Allot of Lindsey's songs should have been on solo albums because they didn't work as FM cuts. Murrow, Miranda, Come were songs that I felt were too experimental even for FM.

I know what you mean with Murrow and Come, but I always thought that Miranda was just right for FM and, actually, I think it fit Fleetwood Mac more than it fit Lindsey solo. Miranda reminded me of Stevie, in the same way that Say You Will reminded me of Christine. Christine reminded me of Lindsey on Ricky, but he co-wrote that song, so that doesn't really count.

Michele

[GypsySorcerer]

Originally Posted by louielouie2000

The funny thing is, I'm a dyed in the wool chiffonhead, but I actually think Stevie's presence on the Say You Will version of Peacekeeper ruins the atmosphere of the song. Her voice is just reedy and nasally sounding, and totally pierces the vibe. It's just annoying to listen to. The original Gift Of Screws version seems more harmonious.

Preach it. The GOS version is so much better. Lyrically, I think it's one of Lindsey's very best. I just wish Stevie wasn't on the SYW track.

[louielouie2000]

Originally Posted by GypsySorcerer

Preach it. The GOS version is so much better. Lyrically, I think it's one of Lindsey's very best. I just wish Stevie wasn't on the SYW track.

Agreed. I think the GOS Peacekeeper was a neat modern day protest song (even though Lindsey insists it's a relationship song), but Stevie's soaring folksy harmony parts make it into a cheesy mach '60s throwback-style protest song. I'm normally a big fan of the Buckingham/Nicks harmonies... but it's just a buzzkill here.