Idol Alum Say Stevie Should Be New Judge!

[Jondalar]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

Sorry . folks, Stevie would never be selected for a spot on the AI judge panel...ever. They need a "big name" and Stevie is not a name who would bring in viewers

Mariah Carey will not bring viewers.

[olive]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Mariah Carey will not bring viewers.

WE CAN ONLY HOPE! and then the whole thing will go away Marking the end of reality television!

[mikephxaz]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Mariah Carey will not bring viewers.

As much as I love my Stevie (and dislike Carey) ...Carey will bring in millions of viewers...Simply, because of the potential "train wreck" factor...If you ask the average 17 yo who Stevie Nicks is, they will say...who is HE?

[Macfanforever]

Originally Posted by olive

WE CAN ONLY HOPE! and then the whole thing will go away Marking the end of reality television!

Thank goodness that will end reality television.

[Macfanforever]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

As much as I love my Stevie (and dislike Carey) ...Carey will bring in millions of viewers...Simply, because of the potential "train wreck" factor...If you ask the average 17 yo who Stevie Nicks is, they will say...who is HE?

I agree.Who's Stevie Nicks.I"m not into Mariah's music .I did like her holiday cd.Some of her tunes she screams and howls.I'm not into that.

[QueenStevie]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

If you ask the average 17 yo who Stevie Nicks is, they will say...who is HE?

Oh, you'd be surprised. The average 17 yo knows who Fleetwood Mac is. Ergo, it would make sense that they would know who Stevie Nicks is as well.

[Fannymac]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

As much as I love my Stevie (and dislike Carey) ...Carey will bring in millions of viewers...Simply, because of the potential "train wreck" factor...If you ask the average 17 yo who Stevie Nicks is, they will say...who is HE?

Sorry, but I think it was MOSTLY those "average 17 yo" that watched both AI and Glee that put a number of Stevie's AND Fleetwood Mac's albums in the Top Ten for a couple of weeks after they were on the show/showcased on the show.

Remember...25% of all The Beatles' "#1's" sold were to buyers UNDER the age of 21!

[Jondalar]

Originally Posted by mikephxaz

As much as I love my Stevie (and dislike Carey) ...Carey will bring in millions of viewers...Simply, because of the potential "train wreck" factor...If you ask the average 17 yo who Stevie Nicks is, they will say...who is HE?

Carey will not bring in millions of new viewers.

[mikephxaz]

Originally Posted by Jondalar

Carey will not bring in millions of new viewers.

and you think Stevie will? Again, Im not a Carey fan but Google how many cds that Carey has sold in the last twenty years compared to Stevie I would love to see Stevie as a judge but television producers base these decisions on who attracts viewers...Stevie won't...If Carey becomes a looney tune or a train wreck like Paula did...trust me, it will bring in million of viewers..(and the producers are betting on it)

[LittleSpacey]

I love both Stevie and Mariah, and I think Stevie would be a great Idol judge (if she had the time). However, I don't think it will happen. I do think Mariah will be great, though.

[Ghosty]

Originally Posted by Fannymac

In a recent interview, both Colton Dixon and winner Phillip Phillips said Stevie should be the new judge on Idol. Both guys said she was their favorite mentor, having done her homework the most, caring about the kids.....I doubt she would commit, but VERY cool!!

That is so awesome to hear! Young men with good taste!

She probably would hate having to hurt someone's feelings when they have to choose people. But that would be wonderful.