The Ledge

The Ledge (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/index.php)
-   Stevie Nicks (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Just for fun: Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams (http://ledge.fleetwoodmac.net/showthread.php?t=47289)

louielouie2000 05-16-2011 11:18 AM

Just for fun: Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
 
Since Street Angel is the only other album besides Trouble In Shangri La to have 13 tracks, let's compare it to In Your Dreams as well! :p

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

SapphireSister 05-16-2011 11:28 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love (This was really hard)
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee (tie)
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free (neither)

SA: 5
IYD: 6
Tie: 1
Neither: 1

bluefox4000 05-16-2011 11:29 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight Tie......very hard
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

Street Angel-3
In Your Dreams-9
1 tie

Mick

louielouie2000 05-16-2011 11:33 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams (this one was really tough for me!!)
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans (another narrow win)
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel (another very tough one for me!)
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

Street Angel: 3 In Your Dreams: 10

Artemis 05-16-2011 11:38 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

Street Angel; 1
IYD; 12

I really love some of the songs on SA; Greta, Love Is Like A River, Just Like A Woman and Kick It, but, IYD is just so much better on every level, for me.

ontheEdgeof17 05-16-2011 11:41 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

My sweet, Street Angel: 5
In Your Motherf'ing Dreams: 8

Gypsybecca 05-16-2011 11:48 AM

I really did laugh out loud when I read Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free!

That's like Charlie Sheen vs. Lindsay Lohan...both undesirable train wrecks.

TrueFaith77 05-16-2011 11:52 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

2 - SA
11 - IYD

Travis 05-16-2011 11:57 AM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love (tie)
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams (verdict is out, I kind of have a soft spot for SA the song)
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea (believe it or not - I do find the chorus of Docklands catchy whereas WSS does nothing for me)
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free (tie) (of all the songs in which Dave wrote the music this is actually my favorite. I love the sentiment of this song)

I had yet to offer my feelings about IYD mainly due to the fact I just didn’t feel like getting into it but I find the CD a bit overrated to be honest. I love 2 songs, “Secret Love” and “For What It’s Worth.” To me these are classic Stevie. I'm not really feeling the Dave Stewart tracks in which he wrote the music (something I did not know when I first listened to the CD in full the first couple of times). Later when I went back and read the liner notes, I noticed that the songs I like the best are the ones where Dave did not write the music. This is not meant to be a diss at Dave. I know many of you love love love this new CD and I don’t want to take that away from anyone. I’m happy that Stevie is back and she seems to be very happy with the CD which is fine, but my thing is, since when did Stevie rely so heavily on someone else to write the music? Dave wrote the music for more than half the CD. It doesn’t feel like a Stevie CD for me personally. There are two stand out tracks that I love (SL and FWIW), a few others I like but not love (New Orleans, Annabel Lee, and Moonlight) and others where I just do not get the appeal (WSS, GAG and Everybody Loves You). Maybe in time my feelings will change but as of now ….

Don't hate me

SpyNote 05-16-2011 12:26 PM

01. Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
02, Greta vs. For What It's Worth
03. Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
04. Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
05. Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
06. Destiny vs. Moonlight
07. Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
08. Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
09. Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
10. Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
11. Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
12. Kick It vs. Italian Summer
13. Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free (If had Jane been more like the demo, I would have voted for it instead. I kind of get now why Stevie gets annoyed when people alter her music. :nod:)

SA = 4
IYD = 9

TheWILDheart 05-16-2011 12:53 PM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
May Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

chiliD 05-16-2011 01:01 PM

Before I even looked, I was thinking that the only song on Street Angel that would come close to getting a nod was "Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind", but then I saw it up against "Ghosts Are Gone" and thought...damn.

Ok, another IYD sweep.

sorcerer999 05-16-2011 01:15 PM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

Street Angel - 6 In Your Dreams - 7

Wow! I wasn't expecting these results. This is an eye opener for me. I need to start listening to "Street Angel" more often I guess.

Great thread, Louie!

Christopher 05-16-2011 01:38 PM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love (tie)
Greta vs. For What It's Worth *(tie)
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel (this was a hard call)
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone (tie)
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

9 = IYD
1 = SA
3 = IYD/SA (tie)

*It was interesting to have 2 of Mike Campell's collaborations up against each other, in which I consider FWIW and Greta to be the 2 all time best SN/MC song efforts ever.

Maxd9 05-16-2011 02:04 PM

Blue Denim vs. Secret Love
Greta vs. For What It's Worth
Street Angel vs. In Your Dreams
Docklands vs. Wide Sargasso Sea
Listen To The Rain vs. New Orleans
Destiny vs. Moonlight
Unconditional Love vs. Annabel Lee
Love Is Like A River vs. Soldier's Angel
Rose Garden vs. Everybody Loves You
Maybe Love Will Change Your Mind vs. Ghosts Are Gone
Just Like A Woman vs. You May Be The One
Kick It vs. Italian Summer
Jane vs. Cheaper Than Free

IYD - 9
SA - 4


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
© 1995-2003 Martin and Lisa Adelson, All Rights Reserved