The "TISL" Survivor Challenge - Final Round

[ahafan02]

Here is the list of what has won so far...

Round One - Too Far From Texas
Round One - That Made Me Stronger
Round Two - It's Only Love
Round Two - Everyday
Round Three - Love Changes
Round Three - I Miss You/Bombay Sapphires (tie)
Round Four - Candlebright/Sorcerer (tie)
Round Four - Fall From Grace


Onto the final round...vote for two more tracks to go...the song with the LEAST amount of votes wins

[tabruns]

Man the "Love Is" haters are going to have a cow if it actually ends up winning.

[darklinensuit]

IMO only two should have left last round. FFG should still be here (based on votes, not my personal preference, which would be "Sorcerer").

Guess I'm voting "Love Is" & "Planets of the Universe" out.

- Jake

[ahafan02]

Planets is in the top 10 of my all time favorite Stevie songs

[darklinensuit]

I think the vocal on POTU is overrated - no way did it deserve a Grammy nod compared to some of the other tracks.
I miss the lyrics that were cut from the demo for the album track.
Most of all I'm disappointed in the production. Anyone else think POTU & "Secret Love" sound very similar production-wise? (though I do prefer Stevie's voice on the latter)

- Jake

[Christopher]

IMO only two should have left last round. FFG should still be here (based on votes, not my personal preference, which would be "Sorcerer").

Guess I'm voting "Love Is" & "Planets of the Universe" out.

- Jake

Agreed. TISL, FFG or POTU are usually always the last 2 or 3 standing. But "Love Is" has been enjoying a renaissance with fans since Stevie added it to her set last year. I've always had a sweet spot for "Love Is" (demo AND album version) so I'm happy to see it get some deserved attention all these years later. 10 years on, it's still one of my most played songs from TISL.

[vivfox]

Man the "Love Is" haters are going to have a cow if it actually ends up winning.


Not really. I hate the song but I know it is loved by many so if it wins I will celebrate by eating a whole pint of Hagen Daz ice cream in one sitting.

[darklinensuit]

Agreed. TISL, FFG or POTU are usually always the last 2 or 3 standing. But "Love Is" has been enjoying a renaissance with fans since Stevie added it to her set last year. I've always had a sweet spot for "Love Is" (demo AND album version) so I'm happy to see it get some deserved attention all these years later. 10 years on, it's still one of my most played songs from TISL.

And it's the opposite effect for "Sorcerer". I think the live performances have hurt its popularity on here. The album track is far superior vocally & melodically to any of the other tracks that made it this far. I've already shared my thoughts on "Love Is" & POTU. IMO the song TISL is superior to those two, but it does not hold a candle to "Sorcerer" except lyrically. Her craggy voice sounds good on the chorus, but grating on the verses. At this point I hope it wins, but I know there's a lot of love for the other two on this board.

- Jake

[Christopher]

I think the vocal on POTU is overrated - no way did it deserve a Grammy nod compared to some of the other tracks.
I miss the lyrics that were cut from the demo for the album track.
Most of all I'm disappointed in the production. Anyone else think POTU & "Secret Love" sound very similar production-wise? (though I do prefer Stevie's voice on the latter)

- Jake

I don't recall anybody (fans) raving about Stevie's vocal on POTU :shrug: Her vocal is very dry, but the chorus has some lovely, subtle harmonies with the girls :nod:. And it's blasphemous that they cut out the best verse. For me, I hear more similarity in production to Moonlight (the chorus) than Secret Love.

[Christopher]

Not really. I hate the song but I know it is loved by many so if it wins I will celebrate by eating a whole pint of Hagen Daz ice cream in one sitting.

Yum! I haven't done that in a long time. Vanilla Swiss Almond is my weakness:distress: I just don't keep any in the house, otherwise I cannot control myself:cool:

[SapphireSister]

I think Love Is gained a ton of new fans since it became part of her live set. It really makes so much more of a statement when performed live as opposed to the album version. The demo is also far superior to the album version and is one of my top 10's of all time. Love Is hasn't been a winner in the past so it would be really nice to see it triumph here. The other 2 tracks are also amazing songs in their own right and definitely deserve to be in the top 3.

[Christopher]

Planets & Love Is>>>>>>>>>>>>Trouble in Shangri~La for the win!!

[darklinensuit]

I don't recall anybody (fans) raving about Stevie's vocal on POTU :shrug: Her vocal is very dry, but the chorus has some lovely, subtle harmonies with the girls :nod:. And it's blasphemous that they cut out the best verse. For me, I hear more similarity in production to Moonlight (the chorus) than Secret Love.

If you go back a few years posters were in love with the vocal on POTU (and pretty much the rest of the album, except "Candlebright" - though to me TISL has Stevie's weakest vocals of any studio album other than TOSOTM).
I know some of the cut lyrics are on at least one of the extended/dance versions.
I'm telling you, the intros to POTU & "Secret Love" sound very alike to my ears. I'd think it was the same producer if I did not know otherwise.

- Jake

[Allycattt]

OMGGGG!!! NOOOOOOO!!!!! I voted for the one I wanted to WIN!! Ugh:'(

[ontheEdgeof17]

Planets....since they cut the best part of the song

and

Love Is....



Title Track for the win.

[Dodfather]

How can Fall From Grace be gone???! I wanted it to win and am confused because it hardly had any votes the last time I checked. Oh well...

[MacFan92]

How do I pick between TISL and LI??? Oh well. I spose I want Love Is to win...

[Neal]

"TISL" for the win, ditch the other two.

[johnnystorms]

if for no other reason... "you can consume all the BEAUTY in the room baby"

[StevieNicksfann]

Hasn't the title track always won on the TISL survivor? I seldom bother with these polls quite honestly because they always turn out the same. If it garnered better discussion as to the merits of each song before the poll, I think it would be a more value-added experience. Just sayin...

[SapphireSister]

Hasn't the title track always won on the TISL survivor? I seldom bother with these polls quite honestly because they always turn out the same. If it garnered better discussion as to the merits of each song before the poll, I think it would be a more value-added experience. Just sayin...

Yes it has...but I liked this one because Love Is did much better than usual which I attribute (as I mentioned earlier) to her adding it to her set list.

[darklinensuit]

Hasn't the title track always won on the TISL survivor? I seldom bother with these polls quite honestly because they always turn out the same. If it garnered better discussion as to the merits of each song before the poll, I think it would be a more value-added experience. Just sayin...

Over the years the winners have tended to remain consistent (though I remember LWTG beating ROF at least once), but the other rankings don't. I recall "Bombay Sapphires" doing pretty well in years past. I think in other polls, "Kick It", "Rose Garden", and "Doing the Best that I Can" have done really well a few times.

- Jake