Givin it Back [Archive]

View Full Version : Givin it Back

Gailh

06-03-2006, 03:30 PM

I've been listening to this a lot recently and at the moment it's my favourite on ITM. It has my favourite line in it "I tripped and I fell, I got lost for a little while. But then you caught be in your lovin arms, rescued me with your smile"

I used to think that it might be about her family but now it sounds to me like it's about someone who gets together with a person who they've known for a long time but just as a friend.

It doesn't have to be about her at all. I know she co-wrote it with Billy Burnette and George Hawkins but I'm not sure how responsible she was for the words.

What does everyone else think?

Gail

macfan 57

06-03-2006, 03:47 PM

I've been listening to this a lot recently and at the moment it's my favourite on ITM. It has my favourite line in it "I tripped and I fell, I got lost for a little while. But then you caught be in your lovin arms, rescued me with your smile"

"Givin' It Back" is one of my favorites on the album. Those lyrics are also MY favorite lyrics on the album, maybe even among my favorite lyrics of any of her songs ever.

I used to think that it might be about her family but now it sounds to me like it's about someone who gets together with a person who they've known for a long time but just as a friend.

It doesn't have to be about her at all. I know she co-wrote it with Billy Burnette and George Hawkins but I'm not sure how responsible she was for the words.

Hmmm...here I might disagree with you, Gail.:) I still think it's about her family. I know she does sometimes step into other people's shoes when writing songs, but I think this album is much more personal. Also, this song ends the album. I think it's a nice, little tribute/thank you to her brother/family. By the way, this was one of the questions I asked her in that Q & A. So, I guess we'll never know. Regardless of who it's about, it's a beautiful song.

Gailh

06-04-2006, 09:39 AM

Hmmm...here I might disagree with you, Gail.:) I still think it's about her family. I know she does sometimes step into other people's shoes when writing songs, but I think this album is much more personal. Also, this song ends the album. I think it's a nice, little tribute/thank you to her brother/family. By the way, this was one of the questions I asked her in that Q & A. So, I guess we'll never know. Regardless of who it's about, it's a beautiful song.

You could be right. It's difficult to tell how personal it is to her without knowing who wrote the words.

It's a pity she didn't answer her questions then we would know for sure.

I wonder if the sheer volume put her off? I'm sure the questions could have been grouped together in general themes and then there wouldn't have been so many to answer.

I'll volunteer to do it as long as I get to go and ask the questions to her personally! (I think this is where I wake up!)

Gail

macfan 57

06-04-2006, 10:34 AM

I wonder if the sheer volume put her off? I'm sure the questions could have been grouped together in general themes and then there wouldn't have been so many to answer.

Probably...It sounds like the website administrator sent all of the questions at once(probably hundreds & hundreds of them) to her nephew & told him to take care of it. Supposedly, she was recording her answers on audio tape...that's the last we heard of it, well over a year ago. I think that the website administrator has gone AWOL. You would think that he'd at least remove the reference to the Q & A from the site.

I'll volunteer to do it as long as I get to go and ask the questions to her personally! (I think this is where I wake up!)
Gail

You could go to her house, knock on her door & get those audiotapes that she was recording her answers. I'm sure you could find someone to transfer those tapes to digital format. Then we'd have the answers to the Q & A.:D All Christine McVie fans would be very grateful to you.;) :laugh:

HomerMcvie

06-04-2006, 11:16 AM

jbrownsjr

06-04-2006, 11:33 AM

I honestly think she was disappointed with the sales of ITM, and just said, "to hell with it".

yes that's my gut too

Gailh

06-04-2006, 12:43 PM

You could go to her house, knock on her door & get those audiotapes that she was recording her answers. I'm sure you could find someone to transfer those tapes to digital format. Then we'd have the answers to the Q & A.:D All Christine McVie fans would be very grateful to you.;) :laugh:

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

Yes that's a good idea. I'm sure I'd be very welcome at her house!

Hello you don't know me but my name's Gail and I'm here to collect your cassettes with your answers to the questions we all sent in.

I'll walk the dogs while you go and find them.

Yes thanks I will have a cup of tea. And a chocolate Hobnob? Ooh lovely

Gail

Gailh

06-04-2006, 12:52 PM

I honestly think she was disappointed with the sales of ITM, and just said, "to hell with it".

Yes you might be right.

I must say I do find it vastly irritating that they put that on the web site with the promise of someone winning one of her gold albums and then .... nothing. No explanation at all.

I mean why offer to do it in the first place?

And as Mary Anne says the webmaster has gone AWOL and the competion details haven't been removed.

:confused:

Gail

HomerMcvie

06-04-2006, 01:46 PM

Mary Anne got her jacket. I want that gold record!:thumbsup:

Gailh

06-04-2006, 02:03 PM

Mary Anne got her jacket. I want that gold record!:thumbsup:

OK OK when I go round for the tapes I'll get the blasted gold record for you!

Gail

macfan 57

06-04-2006, 05:44 PM

And a chocolate Hobnob? Ooh lovely

There you go again with those Chocolate Hobnobs.:laugh: :laugh: I knew you'd work them in somehow.:D

Gailh

06-05-2006, 07:40 AM

There you go again with those Chocolate Hobnobs.:laugh: :laugh: I knew you'd work them in somehow.:D

:laugh: :laugh:

It is my mission in life to get chocolate hobnobs into as many posts as I can!

Gail

billwebster

07-05-2006, 05:54 AM

Givin' It Back is a great tune. I just wish there were more like this on In the Meantime, instead of all of that funk guitar stuff.

eclipse

07-05-2006, 06:44 AM

Do you think you'll see a duck in her kitchen??
That's what I want to know!!
(and what the hell is a chocolate hobnob? ( sorry if I am too American)

Gailh

07-05-2006, 07:25 AM

Do you think you'll see a duck in her kitchen??
That's what I want to know!!
(and what the hell is a chocolate hobnob? ( sorry if I am too American)

She's probably made Duck a L'orange with the poor unfortunate creature by now! :lol:

A chocolate hobnob is a biscuit. Oatmeal covered on one side with either milk or plain chocolate. Christine mentioned in an interview that now at the end of the day she prefers a cup of tea and a chocolate hobnob to a glass of champagne. Since then I have taken any and every opportunity to get them into as many posts as I can.

Gail

eclipse

07-05-2006, 07:39 AM

Gailh

07-05-2006, 07:42 AM

Thanks for the explanation-
Sounds yummy, in as much as I would love to have anything at the end of the day....
I cannot imagine tiring of Champagne....
I should, but I just can't!! ;)

Be sure and tell Christeen that I send my regards when you visit!:

Yes I will - I'm sure she'd be thrilled if I just turned up on her doorstep in Kent! But all she has to do is hand over the cassettes, oh and the gold album for Homer.

Gail

HomerMcvie

07-05-2006, 12:27 PM

Yes I will - I'm sure she'd be thrilled if I just turned up on her doorstep in Kent! But all she has to do is hand over the cassettes, oh and the gold album for Homer.

Gail
That's right! Don't forget about old Homie.
Chocolate Hobnobs for everyone!(boy, that sounds disgusting!):o :o :o