View Full Version : Rock Star-INXS
Livia
07-11-2005, 08:52 PM
Who's watching? Discuss!
golden braid
07-11-2005, 08:55 PM
I will be watching but it's not on for another two hourse for me. :nod:
xdreamsunwindx
07-11-2005, 09:01 PM
All's I can say is that Michael Hutchence is probably turning over in his grave right now. -_-
gldstwmn
07-11-2005, 09:26 PM
That girl just murdered Dylan's song.
Livia
07-11-2005, 09:38 PM
That girl just murdered Dylan's song.
I know - I wanted someone to shoot her and put her out of her misery....that dude who did "American Woman" was a tool...and so was that guy who butchered "Heroes." I liked the first girl and the girl who did the Hole song...I didn't care for the Nirvana guy. What else did you expect Ty to do, but "Cult of Personality?" I liked him too...I can't believe Dave Navarro is involved in this. He just lost some cool points in my book.
gldstwmn
07-11-2005, 10:13 PM
I know - I wanted someone to shoot her and put her out of her misery....that dude who did "American Woman" was a tool...and so was that guy who butchered "Heroes." I liked the first girl and the girl who did the Hole song...I didn't care for the Nirvana guy. What else did you expect Ty to do, but "Cult of Personality?" I liked him too...I can't believe Dave Navarro is involved in this. He just lost some cool points in my book.
Was the guy who did American Woman the one who grabbed his crotch and was doing the twitchy thing with his legs and then grabbed that girl in the audience by her hair? :lol: :eek:
Dave's married now so he's probably making all the money he can. Plus I don't think Jane's is touring this summer, are they?
Dark Angel
07-11-2005, 11:10 PM
All's I can say is that Michael Hutchence is probably turning over in his grave right now. -_-
Agreed. I've hated this idea since they first announced it.
Dreammms
07-11-2005, 11:12 PM
Agreed. I've hated this idea since they first announced it.
So did I. Nobody should even try to be Michael Hutchence.
gldstwmn
07-11-2005, 11:31 PM
So did I. Nobody should even try to be Michael Hutchence.
I don't think anyone's trying to be Michael Hutchence. It's not like the rest of the band told him to go hang himself. He left them holding the bag. They were getting ready to go out on tour again and waiting for him to come to rehearsal and he never showed up. So any of the dates that had already been booked had to be cancelled. I don't know what kind of money, if any, that cost them.
So now, they've waited a repsectable amount of time and have decided to continue under the name they're known for best-INXS. If they changed the name of the band they would have a much harder time getting booked. So this show is a good way to create some buzz about them and help them to continue to earn a living. I don't see anything wrong with that.
I saw INXS about three months before Michael killed himself. It was a great show with complete with Hutchence climbing up on the stacks like a monkey man. He gave a great performance. May he rest in peace.
golden braid
07-11-2005, 11:50 PM
The girl who did Dylan was awful and the last girl who forgot the lyrics sucked too. I really liked the first girl's voice and I thought the girl who did the Pretenders song was interesting too. The Living Colour guy was good too.
irishgrl
07-12-2005, 12:01 AM
They did replace him with a known Australian singer Jon Stevens. That was much more respectable. INXS could possibly be good without Michael but they wouldn't really be INXS, they'd be another band. I guess that's what they were with Jon Stevens because he didn't try to be Michael Hutchence, he already had a name here. Some say it actually worked well musically speaking but plugging that name INXS without Michael doesn't work. They should drop INXS and perform as a new band then they might gain more respect based purely on the music. So that experiment didn't work and now they've gone for a completely tacky experiment.
without having seen the show, and purely on principle, I agree with you. Michael WAS INXS, just like Freddy Mercury was Queen. Nuff Said.
Dreammms
07-12-2005, 12:02 AM
I got away from INXS after Michael died. He was to INXS what Jim Morrison was to the Doors and Freddie Mercury to Queen. They all had that star persona with the band in the background.
Dreammms
07-12-2005, 12:04 AM
without having seen the show, and purely on principle, I agree with you. Michael WAS INXS, just like Freddy Mercury was Queen. Nuff Said.
lol we posted the same thing at the same time!
very well said! :nod:
irishgrl
07-12-2005, 12:05 AM
lol we posted the same thing at the same time!
very well said! :nod:
back atcha! great minds and all that.... :)
Janet
07-12-2005, 01:38 AM
I got away from INXS after Michael died. He was to INXS what Jim Morrison was to the Doors and Freddie Mercury to Queen. They all had that star persona with the band in the background.
I agree.
Make new music, get new bands but don't try to make these classic bands come together again...what's done is done.
( The Who is the exception because at least Roger and Pete are still around and they can tour for all eternity)
But even the Beatles without John...no. Now without George, double NO.
It's like when FM did it without Stevie AND Lindsey...bad....thank God the Dance happened and they aren't looking for new singers, you KNOW this is right up Mick's alley. He did it already but with the surgence of reality tv...he'd be doing this right now.
I don't know, but this caused me to bring out my INXS Greatest Hits CD.
I watched it; I'm kind of hooked. Actually, I was surprised that they have so many women competing in it. :shrug: They're all pretty good, but I really think the women are better (maybe I'm biased since I am a woman). That 22 year old woman was pretty good. I can't see a young girl though in a band with those old man :lol: & they are looking old now.
Lee :)
Patti
07-12-2005, 09:40 AM
They did replace him with a known Australian singer Jon Stevens. That was much more respectable. INXS could possibly be good without Michael but they wouldn't really be INXS, they'd be another band. I guess that's what they were with Jon Stevens because he didn't try to be Michael Hutchence, he already had a name here. Some say it actually worked well musically speaking but plugging that name INXS without Michael doesn't work. They should drop INXS and perform as a new band then they might gain more respect based purely on the music. So that experiment didn't work and now they've gone for a completely tacky experiment.
I saw INXS a few years ago with Jon Stevens as the lead singer. I had a really good time--and he was easy on the eyes, too! Any idea why they dropped him?
gldstwmn
07-12-2005, 10:12 AM
The girl who did Dylan was awful and the last girl who forgot the lyrics sucked too.
I liked the girl who missed her cue on Remedy. Something about her reminds me of Stevie. :shocked:
gldstwmn
07-12-2005, 10:16 AM
I got away from INXS after Michael died. He was to INXS what Jim Morrison was to the Doors and Freddie Mercury to Queen. They all had that star persona with the band in the background.
I actually thought Ian Astbury did a great job fronting The Doors recently.
I mean, hey, Van Halen was still successful after DLR left.
Dark Angel
07-12-2005, 02:34 PM
I got away from INXS after Michael died. He was to INXS what Jim Morrison was to the Doors and Freddie Mercury to Queen. They all had that star persona with the band in the background.
I love how my IM quotes end up paraphrased here. :laugh: :thumbsup: INXS is not INXS without Michael, and never will be. His sexy voice, devil-may-care attitude, and stage prescence, (not to mention , his looks), made INXS what it was. I was fan from '82 till Michaels's death in '97, and am still a fan of everything they did with Michael. Without him, they're just another 80's pop band trying to make a comeback with a new lead singer. While that may work for some bands (Van Halen is the only one I can think of at the moment), I don't see anything great coming out of this. The very least they could do is change the band's name.
Dreammms
07-12-2005, 03:00 PM
I love how my IM quotes end up paraphrased here. :laugh: :thumbsup: INXS is not INXS without Michael, and never will be. His sexy voice, devil-may-care attitude, and stage prescence, (not to mention , his looks), made INXS what it was. I was fan from '82 till Michaels's death in '97, and am still a fan of everything they did with Michael. Without him, they're just another 80's pop band trying to make a comeback with a new lead singer. While that may work for some bands (Van Halen is the only one I can think of at the moment), I don't see anything great coming out of this. The very least they could do is change the band's name.
:xoxo:
With all this INXS talk I decided to put on Michael's solo album. It made me depressed. The lyrics and his voice are amazing. It's a very dark album. He is the one that had the true talent. I miss him.
irishgrl
07-12-2005, 05:49 PM
I actually thought Ian Astbury did a great job fronting The Doors recently.
I mean, hey, Van Halen was still successful after DLR left.
Sammy Hagar was a POOR SUBSTITUTE for Diamond Dave :sorry:
Dave was soooooo athletic and much better looking then...there's NO comparison IMHO.
Serrart
07-12-2005, 06:18 PM
All's I can say is that Michael Hutchence is probably turning over in his grave right now. -_-
I loved Inxs and had the chance to meet Hutchence in 1991 or 1992. He was a very gentle man. We spoke for five minutes about Dylan. He was a huge fan.
Romy
Dreammms
07-12-2005, 09:10 PM
Somebody just did a Franz cover. Did you see it Diss?
not crazy about the Call Me cover
hayley
07-12-2005, 10:02 PM
I watched last night's episode tonight and now this episode is almost over. I can say, sad but true, I think I'm going to get addicted to this show like wo.
The bastardization of INXS doesn't bother as much as I thought it would. Watching this, it just seems like they're just using them as an excuse to do a rock-oriented version of American Idol. I do think if I started a drinking game of how many times they SAY "INXS" I'd be plastered in the first thirty seconds. It's starting to bug.
I looooove Heather, the one who did "Somebody To Love"- she is sexy as hell, and her voice is awesome. Hate the girl who did Cheap Trick- I think she's too precious and boring. I liked the girl who did "Take It Easy" on the first episode, but gawd, how awful to get saddled with that Eagles song tonight, next to everyone else's song. Don't like the daddy's girl, because I'm mean. Don't like Suzie- the one who messed up the lyrics last night- her voice is boring to me. Typical blues-tinged bar band voice. I reeeeally like the girl who did "Piece of My Heart" last night and "Should I Stay Or Should I Go" tonight. Jordis is awesome, too.
Like, Ty is amazing- but I don't like him. I loooooooove Brandon. HOT. His energy is great. I kinda like Naked!Guy too, despite myself. Don't like J.D. Marty is okay, but his mannerisms put me off, and his cover of "Take Me Out" did nothing but remind me of what a kickass song it is, DESPITE him singing it.
I like that Dave Navarro's on here, although I'm glad to finally know for 100% that my crush on him is gone. He's just gotten too girly. I think it started to go downhill with the Jane's reunion after he left the Chili Peppers.
I will say- if I had known Brooke Burke was hosting this, I wouldn't have started watching it. Words cannot describe how much I hate her. HAAAAAAAAAAAATE. HATE. Hate.
eta: I really am completely ashamed for enjoying this show. Just had to say that to make myself feel better!
gldstwmn
07-12-2005, 10:08 PM
Sammy Hagar was a POOR SUBSTITUTE for Diamond Dave :sorry:
If you reread what I said, I wasn't comparing Sammy and Dave. I merely stated that they were just as successful with Sammy as they were with DLR.
gldstwmn
07-12-2005, 10:10 PM
I loved Inxs and had the chance to meet Hutchence in 1991 or 1992. He was a very gentle man. We spoke for five minutes about Dylan. He was a huge fan.
Romy
Lucky you. :)
Dreammms
07-12-2005, 10:16 PM
I like that Dave Navarro's on here, although I'm glad to finally know for 100% that my crush on him is gone. He's just gotten too girly. I think it started to go downhill with the Jane's reunion after he left the Chili Peppers.
i still think he is hot and sexy in a freaky sort of way :nod:
gldstwmn
07-12-2005, 11:12 PM
I loooooooove Brandon. HOT. His energy is great.
He's got what it takes. I thing he's going to do alright.
I really thought Will was kind of sexy, & I thought he could sing; I hated to see him go. I guess sexy just didn't cut it.
I really like Jordis. I'm not sure :shrug: about the men now since Will is gone. I'll have to check them out again. :nod:
Lee :)
Livia
07-14-2005, 09:52 AM
I really thought Will was kind of sexy, & I thought he could sing; I hated to see him go. I guess sexy just didn't cut it.
I really like Jordis. I'm not sure :shrug: about the men now since Will is gone. I'll have to check them out again. :nod:
Lee :)
Will was my first choice to get the boot!
Jordis is my favorite!
hayley
07-14-2005, 10:02 AM
Will was my first choice to get the boot!
Mine too! I really didn't like him. He butchered "Need You Tonight."
I still like Jordis and Brandon. HAAAATE J.D. I'm sorry, that version of California Dreaming was STILL horrific last night.
gldstwmn
07-14-2005, 10:34 AM
I really thought Will was kind of sexy, & I thought he could sing; I hated to see him go. I guess sexy just didn't cut it.
I really like Jordis. I'm not sure :shrug: about the men now since Will is gone. I'll have to check them out again. :nod:
Lee :)
I think he's got potential but he really doesn't suit the band. He needs to work on his stage presence a little more.
The guy that did California Dreamin' really surprised me. That was a complete turn around from the first night's performance.
BTFLCHLD
07-14-2005, 01:08 PM
i disagree on an inxs name-change...they have had it since 79...michael died...they didnt
Sorceress
07-14-2005, 10:20 PM
Jordis is my favorite too. JD's CA Dreamin' was not bad. I can't remember the names of any of the other guys to pick a favorite. I'm watching because I always wanted to see the American Idol contestants do more rock songs and this is an okay substitute. Maybe I'll get more into it as I get to know the contestants better.
Brooke Burke IS horribly annoying. And the crowd is a little too artificially pumped for my liking. I'll keep watching though, because it's the middle of summer and there's nothing better on!
bikerchic
07-19-2005, 01:24 PM
Why wasn't it on last nite. I kind of enjoyed it :shrug:
gldstwmn
07-19-2005, 02:10 PM
Why wasn't it on last nite. I kind of enjoyed it :shrug:
It was on last night. They picked their new songs and rehearsed them. They also got to pick out rock star clothes from a stylist.
I hope this isn't pre-empted by the SC nominee announcement tonight.
bikerchic
07-19-2005, 03:39 PM
It was on last night. They picked their new songs and rehearsed them. They also got to pick out rock star clothes from a stylist.
I hope this isn't pre-empted by the SC nominee announcement tonight.
So it was on last night or tonight? What time?
Lisa1769
07-19-2005, 03:45 PM
So it was on last night or tonight? What time?
I think it's on, on Mon., Tues. & Wed. nights.
It was on at 8 central last night.
http://rockstar.msn.com/
bikerchic
07-19-2005, 04:01 PM
I think it's on, on Mon., Tues. & Wed. nights.
It was on at 8 central last night.
http://rockstar.msn.com/
Ooooohhhhh, it's a 3 niter in a row.....dah. Thanks. Although, I channel surfed at 8:00 and couldn't find it.
gldstwmn
07-19-2005, 04:38 PM
So it was on last night or tonight? What time?
It was on at 8:30 mountain time.
golden braid
07-20-2005, 12:52 AM
Jordis is my favorite!
Me too! I totally want her to win. I really like her voice and her performance. A lot of the other contestants are over the top with their performances and don't really have great voices. Jordis doesn't seem to be trying to be something she's not.
mylittledemon
07-20-2005, 06:19 AM
I caught this show last night actually. Kinda American-Idolish...I think this is one of those bands, that to continue with Michael Hutchence they should change the name. The whole thing seems very sell-out-ish.
darklinensuit
07-20-2005, 03:01 PM
I saw most of the premiere & hadn't seen it since until last night, when I saw parts. I liked Jordis. She has good wide eyes for the stage, she's not in a bikini miolesting the guitarist, & she's not over-singing like some of the others are.
- Jake
She blew them all away last night. Actually she should just forget INXS & go out on her own. I think she'd be great. :nod:
Lee :)
gldstwmn
07-21-2005, 10:22 AM
She probably will end up going out on her own. I'm sure there are people who have got their eyes on her already.
darklinensuit
07-21-2005, 12:29 PM
She blew them all away last night. Actually she should just forget INXS & go out on her own. I think she'd be great. :nod:
Lee :)
Ditto. To be honest, I was never a huge INXS fan even in their heyday.
But if some of the lesser American Idols can get contracts, I don't foresee a problem for her.
- Jake
SapphireSister
07-21-2005, 01:50 PM
I LOVE this show. It's my new guilty addiction. I've seen every episode and if I'm not home I record it. As far as I'm concerned Jordis has it in the bag. I say she's going to win the whole thing and that was my though the first time she performed. She has it all - the look, the attitude, the stage presence, the voice, and she's a chick! And the best part about her is she pulls it all off without her tits hanging out! I also like Marty. I thought everyone they found were all quite talented in their own right and have been very impressed with everyone. I just think that not all of them are right for INXS just like the band says.
Livia
07-23-2005, 01:19 AM
Did I miss someone getting booted or have they not done that yet? I set the DVR to record the 1-hour show and the results show, but I got King of Queens instead.
Jordis rocks! I want that dork who played the guitar and sang (?) Summer of 69 to go next...
tuigirl
07-23-2005, 03:58 AM
We now have this show in the UK (or at least I saw pt 1&2 last week, but seem to have missed it this week.....oh well). I find it interesting as it was put to me by a fellow Ledgie, that had they changed the band name immediately and continued without MH, then they were in it for the love of the music, however by holding onto the name and finding a MH replacement, then it's all about the MONEY, cashing in on those songs and MH's memory..I must admit I do agree, why have they waited so long to do this? Because these blokes are wanting the cash and thats why theyr'e in it. Having said that though, I did find it quite interesting to watch.
darklinensuit
07-23-2005, 05:06 AM
I know it was on against the new dance show by the AI folks. I caught some of that and it was extremely boring.
- Jake
gldstwmn
07-23-2005, 10:34 AM
Did I miss someone getting booted or have they not done that yet? I set the DVR to record the 1-hour show and the results show, but I got King of Queens instead.
Jordis rocks! I want that dork who played the guitar and sang (?) Summer of 69 to go next...
Wish granted. :)
BombaySapphire3
07-24-2005, 02:03 AM
I didn't bother to watch it. I was a semi fan of the group in the 1980s .Surely they don't need the money this much to resort to such tackiness .They were huge internationally for quite awhile .
BTFLCHLD
07-27-2005, 11:51 PM
so far i think the eliminations have been right on
id sample a new cd with the following fronts
marty
jordis
ty
mig
Livia
08-03-2005, 12:01 PM
Last night was pretty good - Jordis BLEW ME AWAY w/ her rendition of "Man Who Sold the World." I've always loved that song - I voted for her!!!
If you missed it, you can go to msn.com and watch vids.
bikerchic
08-03-2005, 02:15 PM
Last night was pretty good - Jordis BLEW ME AWAY w/ her rendition of "Man Who Sold the World." I've always loved that song - I voted for her!!!
If you missed it, you can go to msn.com and watch vids.
Jordis was awesome and very easy on the eyes. If you went by last night's performance only, I'd say she won......but I don't think an all male band is going to pick a female lead singer.....it's an ego thing ;) JMO
hayley
08-03-2005, 02:23 PM
To me, it's not a question that Mig will win... he's got a great voice, he's by far the most likable and personable, he's their countryman, and he's the only one that has the kind of stamina INXS is looking for or going to need, from his stint singing Queen (!) songs 7 times a week for however long on the stage in London.
I really like Brandon, but I thought "If You Could Only See" fell apart. I thought it was great at the beginning, and then completely off rhythm and off pitch for the rest. I don't like any of the girls except Jordis, and sometimes Deanna. I like Marty more every week. I think if J.D.'s not off soon, though, I'm going to quit watching. That's how much he annoys me.
wondergirl9847
08-03-2005, 03:17 PM
The final four will be MiG, JD, Jordis and Marty I think. In that order.
I liked JD's Letter, even though he needs to get a clue about his ego.
Livia
08-03-2005, 05:14 PM
Jordis was awesome and very easy on the eyes. If you went by last night's performance only, I'd say she won......but I don't think an all male band is going to pick a female lead singer.....it's an ego thing ;) JMO
ITA - they'll want a dude...but hopefully, this show will launch her career! :thumbsup:
JD is a tool.
Last night was pretty good - Jordis BLEW ME AWAY w/ her rendition of "Man Who Sold the World." I've always loved that song - I voted for her!!!
If you missed it, you can go to msn.com and watch vids.
I can never vote b/c I tape it & then watch it Wednesday before the results show, so I just watched it. Jordis was awesome. You could tell that she really felt that song. Jordis needs to go out on her own, seriously. She doesn't need INXS.
I agree; JD is annoying! :nod:
Lee :)
gldstwmn
08-03-2005, 08:41 PM
I think if J.D.'s not off soon, though, I'm going to quit watching. That's how much he annoys me.
He is a cockly little bastard, isn't he?
gldstwmn
08-03-2005, 08:42 PM
I can never vote b/c I tape it & then watch it Wednesday before the results show, so I just watched it. Jordis was awesome. You could tell that she really felt that song. Jordis needs to go out on her own, seriously. She doesn't need INXS.
She's awesome but all wrong for INXS. I hope she gets to do her own thing.
DavidMn
08-03-2005, 08:43 PM
I'm just wondering how low these networks will go to get an audience? :confused:
bikerchic
08-04-2005, 04:52 PM
I missed the first five minutes last night and missed Jordis's encore of The Man Who Sold the World, how was she this time? just as good, better or not as good?
BTFLCHLD
08-04-2005, 04:56 PM
marty...mig...ty...jordis :nod:
gldstwmn
08-04-2005, 05:13 PM
I missed the first five minutes last night and missed Jordis's encore of The Man Who Sold the World, how was she this time? just as good, better or not as good?
She was great but the first performance was better, IMO.
gldstwmn
08-04-2005, 05:14 PM
marty...mig...ty...jordis :nod:
Your sig is hot!
BTFLCHLD
08-10-2005, 12:40 AM
OMG MARTY
**swoon**
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 12:47 AM
Hi
I think Jordis and JD will make the top two..(even though, I cant stand JD)..
He is the most ambitous...(arrangements and stuff) :angel:
BTFLCHLD
08-10-2005, 12:54 AM
Hi I think Jordis and JD will make the top two..(even though, I cant stand JD)..He is the most ambitous...(arrangements and stuff) :angel: what they determine to be important to them in their choice will be telling...im curious :wavey:
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 12:59 AM
what they determine to be important to them in their choice will be telling...im curious :wavey:
Me too...Everyone is so gr8...alot better than Amercian Idol..lol :angel:
gldstwmn
08-10-2005, 01:21 AM
Hi
I think Jordis and JD will make the top two..(even though, I cant stand JD)..
He is the most ambitous...(arrangements and stuff) :angel:
I think they like Ty and Suzie a lot too. I think Jessica is gone after this evening and possibly Brandon or Deanna.
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 01:24 AM
I think they like Ty and Suzie a lot too. I rhink Jessica is gone after this evening and possibly Brandon or Deanna.
I think Brandon is...He cant sing unless its coming from his nose...He needs alot of singing lessons..The Southern Rock stuff works for him..but, anything with a melody doesnt...
BTFLCHLD
08-10-2005, 01:29 AM
I think Brandon is...He cant sing unless its coming from his nose...He needs alot of singing lessons..The Southern Rock stuff works for him..but, anything with a melody doesnt... agreed :nod:
did jordis sound off tonight or was i not paying good enuf attn?
ontheEdgeof17
08-10-2005, 01:33 AM
I'm still waiting for someone to sing Fleetwood Mac/Stevie....They are running out of rock songs and FM's classics should be popping up.
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 01:34 AM
agreed :nod:
did jordis sound off tonight or was i not paying good enuf attn?
Really, It wasnt her best...but what can you do with eric clapton...vocally anyways...But I still love Jordis... :angel:
gldstwmn
08-10-2005, 01:37 AM
I think Brandon is...He cant sing unless its coming from his nose...He needs alot of singing lessons..The Southern Rock stuff works for him..but, anything with a melody doesnt...
And yet, the vocal coach said he had the most potential. I don't think Brandon was receptive to it.
gldstwmn
08-10-2005, 01:38 AM
agreed :nod:
did jordis sound off tonight or was i not paying good enuf attn?
I felt so bad for her. She almost dropped her mic and she was having an off night.
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 01:42 AM
I felt so bad for her. She almost dropped her mic and she was having an off night.
Me too...But he said, "it will be a long time before she will be singing a INXS song"..so they really like her... :angel:
BTFLCHLD
08-10-2005, 01:44 AM
these are still my choices
marty...mig...ty...jordis :wavey:
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 01:46 AM
these are still my choices
marty...mig...ty...jordis :wavey:
Jordis, JD(a**hole), Marty, & Mig
BTFLCHLD
08-10-2005, 01:58 AM
Jordis, JD(a**hole), Marty, & Mig hasnt he gotten humble yet? i should have paid more attention sorry. i would think if they really want him they wouldnt spoon sugarcubes...what was the bands response to him tonight?
nickslover2071
08-10-2005, 02:15 AM
hasnt he gotten humble yet? i should have paid more attention sorry. i would think if they really want him they wouldnt spoon sugarcubes...what was the bands response to him tonight?
They were impressed as usual..and one of them said he needed to watch his "pitch"..i myself didnt hear any "pitch" problems..but anywho...
golden braid
08-10-2005, 10:28 AM
They were impressed as usual..and one of them said he needed to watch his "pitch"..i myself didnt hear any "pitch" problems..but anywho...
I just don't think JD is that good of a vocalist although he can be entertaining to watch. I still love Jordis although she wasn't on last night and I really like Suzie and Ty too. Jessica is a goner for sure.
Lisa1769
08-10-2005, 12:56 PM
Jordis is very good, I've always enjoyed her performances. But, Marty is my favorite of the two.
Beachwood Mac
08-10-2005, 01:45 PM
Marty's performance last night was pure raw energy and the type of surprise moment you look for at a concert. It took a lot of guts to change plans 10 minutes before air time. Jordis is a presence but last night seemed to just stand up there with a mic and sing. She didn't seem to put any of herself into the song. Ty blew me away last night but I don't think he will win. It's almost as if his voice is too good to be a rock star.
SapphireSister
08-10-2005, 11:09 PM
Is anyone watching this crap right now? That Jessica needs to go like yesterday. This whole format is getting quite redundant. I'm going to a taping next Sunday. Should be fun. Jordis has it in the bag and has since the first show. They should just end it now.
gldstwmn
08-10-2005, 11:31 PM
Is anyone watching this crap right now? That Jessica needs to go like yesterday. This whole format is getting quite redundant. I'm going to a taping next Sunday. Should be fun. Jordis has it in the bag and has since the first show. They should just end it now.
I can't believe Jessica saved herself yet again. I love Jordis but i swear they really want a guy to front the band. :shrug: I can't believe Suzie was in the bottom three. She was very good last night I thought.
SapphireSister
08-10-2005, 11:37 PM
I can't believe Jessica saved herself yet again. I love Jordis but i swear they really want a guy to front the band. :shrug: I can't believe Suzie was in the bottom three. She was very good last night I thought.
If a guy had to win Marty is by far my first choice. He freakin rocks. I was half watching it, half chatting on here. What happend with DeAnna? I thought she was at the bottom?
golden braid
08-11-2005, 12:09 AM
If a guy had to win Marty is by far my first choice. He freakin rocks. I was half watching it, half chatting on here. What happend with DeAnna? I thought she was at the bottom?
From what I understand at one point during the voting she was in the bottom three but she didn't end up there. I thought for sure Deanna would end up in the bottom three and not Suzie. Suzie has been cool and I really like her.
Livia
08-11-2005, 09:41 AM
When I went to Vegas and was riding the escalator down to baggage claim, there was a HUGE advertisement for "We Will Rock You," with Ty on there, big as day. It took me a second to figure out why he looked familiar....
Yeah, Jordis had an off-nite, but she's still my fave...and I'll be shocked if they pick a girl to win....Deanna's growing on me...Suzie does nothing for me...she's a white girl with no soul....
Buh-bye, Brandon! :thumbsup:
SapphireSister
08-11-2005, 07:12 PM
I LOVE Deanna. She has such a soulful, throaty powerhouse of a voice and she's such a little bit of a thing. It's not like she's going to win but I really really enjoy watching her perform.
I still like Jordis though she was a bit off. The guy playing the guitar, is his name Marty? I thought he sounded way out of tune. :nod:
Lee :)
bikerchic
08-16-2005, 09:59 PM
WOW.....did anyone see tonites show? It was really good. Once again Jordis was awesome, Ty was fantastic and Mig was spectacular. Dave N. made me cry when he said that Mig's performance of "Baby I Love Your Way" made him think about how much he love's his wife. I really love this show!
BTFLCHLD
08-16-2005, 10:01 PM
WOW.....did anyone see tonites show? It was really good. Once again Jordis was awesome, Ty was fantastic and Mig was spectacular. Dave N. made me cry when he said that Mig's performance of "Baby I Love Your Way" made him think about how much he love's his wife. I really love this show! im on cali time...but def looking forward to the top performers tonight...esp marty, jordis, mig and ty :wavey:
ontheEdgeof17
08-16-2005, 10:04 PM
WOW.....did anyone see tonites show? It was really good. Once again Jordis was awesome, Ty was fantastic and Mig was spectacular. Dave N. made me cry when he said that Mig's performance of "Baby I Love Your Way" made him think about how much he love's his wife. I really love this show!
It was okay. It was rather boring. The songs that are chosen are so overrated and predictible. :cool:
Livia
08-16-2005, 10:04 PM
Aw, ****, I totally forgot to DVR it - I'm heading to msn.com....
Edit: It says to check back for tonight's performances. :thumbsup: Dave Navarro is HAWT and Carmen is one lucky beeyotch! :p Then again, she's hot and he's lucky too! I think they make a great couple! Not just cuz they're both hot, but I watched their wedding/reality show and they are just so cute together-they really love and respect each other and seem to have a healthy relationship!
laurarox
08-16-2005, 10:06 PM
My faves are Mig, Marty, Suzie and Jordis! Did you see how cut up Mig is? OOOOOHHHH Baby!
bikerchic
08-16-2005, 10:20 PM
It was okay. It was rather boring. The songs that are chosen are so overrated and predictible. :cool:
That's what I like about it. Songs that I really love, song differently. I'd rather have that then songs I didn't know. Way better then that pop crap they sing on American Idol. Tonite's show was acoustic and string section but other nite's it's good ol rock and roll. I think everyone left has a great voice and I apologize from Canada for J.D. :rolleyes:
wondergirl9847
08-16-2005, 10:49 PM
He is so adorable and he looks like a pixie! LOL I heart him. I want an mp3 of Baby, I Love Your Way. Marty did okay with HMBOMT too. :thumbsup:
BWAH!! Bikerchic, I'm sorry for the Bush family, Jen and April on Big Brother. :rolleyes: Sheebus.
bikerchic
08-16-2005, 10:58 PM
He is so adorable and he looks like a pixie! LOL I heart him. I want an mp3 of Baby, I Love Your Way. Marty did okay with HMBOMT too. :thumbsup:
BWAH!! Bikerchic, I'm sorry for the Bush family, Jen and April on Big Brother. :rolleyes: Sheebus.
Your cousin looks ALOT like my cousin Peppi (yes that's her real name), OMG, I wish I had a picture of her to show you. By the way I am very sorry for your loss, that is very sad. :distress:
gldstwmn
08-16-2005, 11:40 PM
WOW.....did anyone see tonites show? It was really good. Once again Jordis was awesome, Ty was fantastic and Mig was spectacular. Dave N. made me cry when he said that Mig's performance of "Baby I Love Your Way" made him think about how much he love's his wife. I really love this show!
I'm sooo hooked on this show. I've got to give Marty kudos for his performance tonight. Jordis, Mig, Suzie and even Jessica were good tonight. The next elimination is going to be difficult.
gldstwmn
08-16-2005, 11:43 PM
Aw, ****, I totally forgot to DVR it - I'm heading to msn.com....
Edit: It says to check back for tonight's performances. :thumbsup: Dave Navarro is HAWT and Carmen is one lucky beeyotch! :p Then again, she's hot and he's lucky too! I think they make a great couple! Not just cuz they're both hot, but I watched their wedding/reality show and they are just so cute together-they really love and respect each other and seem to have a healthy relationship!
Did you read Dave's book? I'm so glad he's clean now and has Carmen. They are a cute couple.
gldstwmn
08-16-2005, 11:44 PM
That's what I like about it. Songs that I really love, song differently. I'd rather have that then songs I didn't know. Way better then that pop crap they sing on American Idol. Tonite's show was acoustic and string section but other nite's it's good ol rock and roll. I think everyone left has a great voice and I apologize from Canada for J.D. :rolleyes:
It's okay, you've given us many fine other musicians to compensate for the likes of JD. :laugh:
wondergirl9847
08-17-2005, 12:10 AM
Your cousin looks ALOT like my cousin Peppi (yes that's her real name), OMG, I wish I had a picture of her to show you. By the way I am very sorry for your loss, that is very sad. :distress:
I like that name, it's different. I wish you had a pic too, I would love to see Peppi. :)
Beachwood Mac
08-17-2005, 12:36 AM
Dave N. made me cry when he said that Mig's performance of "Baby I Love Your Way" made him think about how much he love's his wife.
It made me cry thinking about how much I love Dave's wife, too! :D :D
Terry
bikerchic
08-17-2005, 09:50 AM
It made me cry thinking about how much I love Dave's wife, too! :D :D
Terry
I was thinking the same thing :nod:
gldstwmn
08-17-2005, 10:11 PM
Well, Jessica's gone, no surprise there I guess.
Beachwood Mac
08-17-2005, 10:19 PM
I'm not really sure how this show is doing in the ratings but it totally blows away American Idol. It's really going to be hard to pick a winner.
Terry
gldstwmn
08-17-2005, 10:56 PM
I'm not really sure how this show is doing in the ratings but it totally blows away American Idol. It's really going to be hard to pick a winner.
Terry
I know. I'm not feeling Deanna and JD gets on my nerves. I love the rest of them though. I hope they do something similar to this in the future.
golden braid
08-17-2005, 11:01 PM
I'm not really sure how this show is doing in the ratings but it totally blows away American Idol. It's really going to be hard to pick a winner.
Terry
I read that it's not doing well in the ratings. CBS is not showing the show on Mondays anymore, only the Tue and Wed editions. The Monday show is now shown on VH1 on Sundays because not too many people were watching.
bikerchic
08-18-2005, 10:12 AM
I read that it's not doing well in the ratings. CBS is not showing the show on Mondays anymore, only the Tue and Wed editions. The Monday show is now shown on VH1 on Sundays because not too many people were watching.
It's really hard for a show to have great rating's in the summer though. I love this show! It's about the ONLY show I have watched this summer.
golden braid
08-18-2005, 10:25 AM
It's really hard for a show to have great rating's in the summer though. I love this show! It's about the ONLY show I have watched this summer.
It's about the only show I've watched this summer too.
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 10:28 AM
i swtiched channels and missed who was voted off last night...please advise. thanks!
Livia
08-18-2005, 11:12 AM
Well, Jessica's gone, no surprise there I guess.
Jessica got booted - I liked her, but they were right, she wasn't a good fit for their band...
I watched the performances online - I haven't been a big fan of Marty's, but I loved what he did w/ the Spears song...Jordis = greatness...and Mig was just amazing! Cool that he invited Jordis and Marty up w/ him last night. Jordis is a great harmonizer!
BTW - all the performances, from the beginning of the show, are available online. I highly recommend Jordis' "Man Who Sold the World" if you haven't seen it yet!
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 12:50 PM
BTW - all the performances, from the beginning of the show, are available online. do you have a link? i didnt see anything on the cbs page.
Livia
08-18-2005, 12:52 PM
It's on msn.com - you'll see the Rock Star link on the left. Then click videos, then you'll see week 1, week 2, etc. And you have to be using Explorer - not Firefox. :nod:
mikeschmike
08-18-2005, 12:56 PM
For anyone who's interested:
www.jordisunga.org
is available for all of your Jordis audio needs. They have all of her performances (so far) from Rock Star:INXS and a few various mp3's. If you liked "The Man Who Sold the World", you'll love her version of "At Last". Not as good as Stevie's of course, but it's pretty good. Anyway, check it out!
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 01:06 PM
For anyone who's interested:
www.jordisunga.org
is available for all of your Jordis audio needs. They have all of her performances (so far) from Rock Star:INXS and a few various mp3's. If you liked "The Man Who Sold the World", you'll love her version of "At Last". Not as good as Stevie's of course, but it's pretty good. Anyway, check it out!
thanks! :cool:
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 03:19 PM
Did you see how cut up Mig is? OOOOOHHHH Baby! :nod:
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050724_Episode_103B_0181_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com"> <img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050807_Episode_105B_0402_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
ontheEdgeof17
08-18-2005, 03:21 PM
:nod:
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050724_Episode_103B_0181_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
Not bad for a pixie. :swoon:
mikeschmike
08-18-2005, 03:24 PM
:nod:
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050724_Episode_103B_0181_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com"> <img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050807_Episode_105B_0402_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
God I love Australia
bikerchic
08-18-2005, 05:13 PM
For anyone who's interested:
www.jordisunga.org
is available for all of your Jordis audio needs. They have all of her performances (so far) from Rock Star:INXS and a few various mp3's. If you liked "The Man Who Sold the World", you'll love her version of "At Last". Not as good as Stevie's of course, but it's pretty good. Anyway, check it out!
Thanks for posting that. I missed her encore performance of TMWSTW. Not quite as good as the first night but still great!
Livia
08-18-2005, 05:24 PM
:nod:
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050724_Episode_103B_0181_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com"> <img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050807_Episode_105B_0402_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
Oh, my...now that's a hunka-hunka burnin' Aussie love, right there!
He should SO win this thing - I mean, he's perfect for INXS. :nod:
bikerchic
08-18-2005, 05:32 PM
Oh, my...now that's a hunka-hunka burnin' Aussie love, right there!
He should SO win this thing - I mean, he's perfect for INXS. :nod:
I totally agree. :nod: Is he gay?
ontheEdgeof17
08-18-2005, 05:34 PM
I totally agree. :nod: Is he gay?
Married...
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 05:35 PM
I totally agree. :nod: Is he gay? in the words of many here at the ledge "who cares!" ;)
does anyone think marty is HOT?
bikerchic
08-18-2005, 05:39 PM
Married...
Damn! The only reason I asked was because I have terrible gaydar and I am just trying to learn :laugh:
bikerchic
08-18-2005, 05:42 PM
in the words of many here at the ledge "who cares!" ;)
does anyone think marty is HOT?
Marty is so cute and seems so sweet. What he did with Baby, Hit Me.... I thought was great.
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 05:53 PM
Marty is so cute and seems so sweet. What he did with Baby, Hit Me.... I thought was great. he is very sexy! and when the camera is thisclose to those penetrating eyes...
sends me over the edge! ***swoon***
oh and he sounds great too ;)
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050807_Episode_105B_0340_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
ontheEdgeof17
08-18-2005, 05:58 PM
I liked Will. Too bad he booted the first week. Any pics of him?
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 06:02 PM
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/will.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 06:09 PM
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050717_Episode_102B_0996.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
too hot...i better stop ;)
ontheEdgeof17
08-18-2005, 06:10 PM
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/will.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
GAWWWWW! I want one!
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 06:16 PM
GAWWWWW! I want one! he does look very good there...but i didnt care for his personality...and thats important, right? :rolleyes:
ontheEdgeof17
08-18-2005, 06:19 PM
he does look very good there...but i didnt care for his personality...and thats important, right? :rolleyes:
Not when you just want eye candy. :laugh:
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 06:25 PM
Not when you just want eye candy. :laugh: eye candy???? f-that i want to eat it!!! well...it not being will, but yeah will is eye candy definitely... ;)
he doesnt have too many pics as he was out week one...sorry!
BTFLCHLD
08-18-2005, 06:27 PM
eye candy. :laugh:
hey here is a link to week one videos so you can watch will to your hearts content :] http://rockstar.msn.com/video/performance/wk01
gldstwmn
08-18-2005, 07:35 PM
:nod:
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050724_Episode_103B_0181_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com"> <img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050807_Episode_105B_0402_300.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
If he doesn't win, I will be shocked.
Beachwood Mac
08-20-2005, 03:15 AM
Check out this performance of Mystify on an LA radio station. Hard to believe it is JD.
http://www.rockstargohome.com/rockstar/Mystify%20-%20JD.mp3
wondergirl9847
08-20-2005, 11:23 AM
For giving us Keith Urban and MiG Ayesa!! :xoxo:
ontheEdgeof17
08-23-2005, 09:53 PM
Jordis.....OUCH OUCH OUCH....my ears. :distress:
Mig....not so good.
Actually, not a good night for anyone. :shrug:
Livia
08-23-2005, 10:17 PM
I thought JD did a great version of "Cold as Ice," and I'm not even a fan of his...I liked Deanna's original song and performance also....
Jordis - ouch is right! She SO could have rocked it - why didn't they just drop it down a notch so "that one f*cking note" wouldn't have been such a mental block for her?
Marty-I was surprised how much praise he received - it sounded like karaoke to me, nothing very original or noteworthy - just...blah.
Mig - Meh. :shrug:
bikerchic
08-23-2005, 10:55 PM
I know he's an ass, but J.D. has a really nice voice. Oh Jordis....what happened? Yay, they all kinda sucked tonite.
gldstwmn
08-23-2005, 11:35 PM
Ty did a good version of Proud Mary. He should have had the girls do the shimmy dance like Tina used to. :lol:
Suzies song was good and her eyes remind me of Stevie. :shrug:
Other than that, tonight was off. Marty could've controlled his vocal much better without the screaming. Deanna was okay, as was Mig. And JD is just forgettable to me.
golden braid
08-24-2005, 01:00 AM
I usually love Jordis but tonight she just sucked. I was cringing and it looked like Dave was too. I thought JD was good but I still don't like him. Mig's song was just alright to me but I thought Deanna's song was kinda cool. Ty performance was very entertaining. Marty is ok but not a great singer and I agree that he's not right for the band.
BTFLCHLD
08-24-2005, 03:11 PM
'i swear mig my momma never showed me how to do laces...'
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/20050821_Episode_107B_1307.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
jadegypsy
08-24-2005, 03:20 PM
I actually noticed something about Jordis, she just doesn't do well with regular "rock" songs, like Dream On, or Layla. She is much better with the oddities like People are Strange, Man Who Sold the World or Knockin' on Heavens Door. Not sure what it is but when the song requires a real "rock out" approach it's just not there. Not that that's bad, there are plenty of great artists who don't have that, but it could hurt her here.
I liked Deannas song enough to wish i had the lyrics as it kinda peaked my interest.
The rest well...
Suzie was good, but she's just too cutesey, I don't think she has the personality to front an all male band, very few do (Grace, Janis and Debbie Harry come to mind but none of them were "cute")
JD is too I, Me, Mine.
Ty was okay, but actually I thought the best part was the backing vocals, and it's hard to screw that song up.
Marty looks possesed, a little creepy.
Mig, eh...his song just kinda passed over me and was forgotten.
ontheEdgeof17
08-24-2005, 03:47 PM
Honestly, it doesn't matter who wins. The show is a flop and the album will be, too. 20 somethings with 40 year old has-beens doesn't work. :cool:
Beachwood Mac
08-24-2005, 08:03 PM
I missed last nights show and when I went to the website to watch the performances the song by Jordis is listed as not available :shrug: Was it so bad it didn't record?
Livia
08-24-2005, 08:21 PM
I missed last nights show and when I went to the website to watch the performances the song by Jordis is listed as not available :shrug: Was it so bad it didn't record?
I'm sure it was recorded, and Jordis was mortified! Maybe she begged the producers not to put it online. :rolleyes:
bikerchic
08-24-2005, 09:48 PM
Deanna's gone, another Canadian bites the dust. I'm gonna miss her deep, husky voice, but I think it was the right decision.
BTFLCHLD
08-24-2005, 09:59 PM
Deanna's gone, another Canadian bites the dust. I'm gonna miss her deep, husky voice, but I think it was the right decision. spoiler :eek:
gldstwmn
08-24-2005, 10:07 PM
Deanna's gone, another Canadian bites the dust. I'm gonna miss her deep, husky voice, but I think it was the right decision.
So do I. It wasn't working for her.
bikerchic
08-24-2005, 10:21 PM
spoiler :eek:
You shouldn't be reading this thread on a Wednesday night before you see the show anyway ;)
BTFLCHLD
08-24-2005, 10:25 PM
You shouldn't be reading this thread on a Wednesday night before you see the show anyway ;) :wavey: i know who were the other two?
bikerchic
08-24-2005, 10:26 PM
:wavey: i know who were the other two?
Ty :shocked: and Marty. :wavey:
gldstwmn
08-24-2005, 10:27 PM
Ty :shocked: and Marty. :wavey:
Marty rocked. :nod:
BTFLCHLD
08-24-2005, 10:30 PM
marty say it isnt so :shocked: did america base it off his performance last night or what???? if so his wasnt the worst!
golden braid
08-24-2005, 10:59 PM
I thought Jordis would finally be in the bottom three. I really thought her perfomance was quite awful last night. I think it will end up being Jordis, Mig, and JD in the final three.
Livia
08-30-2005, 10:06 PM
WOW - tonight was great - except for JD. I can't pick a bottom three. Except for JD. :lol:
Marty blew me away, I had tears in my eyes at the end of his performance.
Jordis played it safe, but she was good.
I felt the same way about Ty.
I wasn't as impressed w/ Susie, as INXS and Dave seemed to be, but she pulled it off.
Mig hit a few clunkers, but no one mentioned it. :shrug: That's cuz he's the mole and he's gonna win!
All in all though, a great show! I actually sat and watched it and sang along, I just loved the song choices tonight!! I wonder if anyone will ever do a Mac song? That would be cool! :p
bikerchic
08-30-2005, 10:18 PM
^ :nod: agreed.
Beachwood Mac
08-30-2005, 10:23 PM
WOW - tonight was great - except for JD. I can't pick a bottom three. Except for JD. :lol:
It doesn't come on for more than an hour yet but that's enough incentive to watch. Buh-bye JD! :lol:
Terry
gldstwmn
08-31-2005, 10:39 AM
WOW - tonight was great - except for JD. I can't pick a bottom three. Except for JD. :lol:
Marty blew me away, I had tears in my eyes at the end of his performance.
Jordis played it safe, but she was good.
I felt the same way about Ty.
I wasn't as impressed w/ Susie, as INXS and Dave seemed to be, but she pulled it off.
Mig hit a few clunkers, but no one mentioned it. :shrug: That's cuz he's the mole and he's gonna win!
All in all though, a great show! I actually sat and watched it and sang along, I just loved the song choices tonight!! I wonder if anyone will ever do a Mac song? That would be cool! :p
It was great with the choir and the orchestra. And you're right about Mig. He was off several times but no one said a thing. They were all so good it's going to be hard to eliminate one of them this week. Unfortunately, I think it's going to be Ty.
hayley
08-31-2005, 11:44 AM
Suzie gets points with me for pulling that off as well as she did- she's gotten really good. Something's changed in the last couple of weeks- before, she struck me as nothing more than a nice, above-average bar band singer. I still don't think she has a chance in the world to win this, but she's moved from being off my radar to one of my favorites.
I know everyone else loves them and thinks they can do no wrong, but I am haaating Ty and Jordis. I had to fast forward through most of Ty's performance last night, because it is one of my absolute favorite songs of all time and seeing him overarticulate his way through it was making me sick. Jordis has an awfully nice voice, but so little power or magnetism. She's bland. The only word I can come up with for both of them is cloying. The way they preen at the camera is so irritating to me. They remind me of cheesy beauty pageant contestants.
Something about Mig's performances always bug me- maybe it's the theatricality, I don't know. But I find that once it's over, I never remember how annoying I found it. I just genuinely like him as a person.
I thought Marty was fantastic. Seriously, just good. In my office, we're all rooting for Marty to lose, though, because he's from Chicago and if he wins we're going to have to go crazy promoting the contestant performance album they have coming out next month, and the eventual INXS album. That, and whoever wins is going to have no career. I'm rooting for Marty and Suzie to make it out of this thing alive.
I hate J.D. I cringed through his entire performance. He's awful. I don't get why people are voting for him. He's arrogant, unlikeable, and... uh, not goooood.
wondergirl9847
08-31-2005, 01:07 PM
Suzie - WhyTH did they give her such a tongue bath? Constantine blew that song out of the water on AI....she was so boring. She didn't go for the high note or anything....WTH? I hope she's gone tonight. Blergh!!!!!!
Ty - Eh. He will probably be going tonight.
JD - Eh...he was okay, not great, not bad. Thought he looked kinda hot.
Jordis - Hate the song (whatevah), she broke her voice well though. Boring for me.
MiG - He was so energetic even though I don't care for this song either.
Marty - Holy sweet Moses. Spellbinding. Love the song and he sold it. Choo choo...I am on his train now. Would love to hear more of THAT voice.
bikerchic
08-31-2005, 01:47 PM
It was great with the choir and the orchestra.
I loved the orchestra too but the choir didn't seem all that great?
I love Jordis's voice but she does love the camera, smiling through the entire song.
Ty's good but his hair is just to distracting for me.
Don't like Mary.
JD's an asshole and his explanations for things is a load of horse ****.
Suzie's ok but I don't think she's strong enough voice wise to win and besides, a girl ain't gonna win this :rolleyes:
Mig's just hot so he has my vote. He doesn't need to sing, he can just stand there. I love a man who cries. :xoxo:
mikeschmike
08-31-2005, 03:30 PM
This has been brought up before, but it bears repeating. Why no FM songs?
Out of the remaining six, here's an FM song for each of them to do. I won't get too deep into their catalog, as they make these people sing every song you'd hear at a karaoke bar.
Marty-The Chain. I think he has the right style to out the anger and emotion in this song. Think of LB on the Mirage tour. Yeah, that kind of angry.
Ty-Tusk. Just because.
Mig- Mig needs a good rockin tune. Let's give him...I'm so afraid!
JD- JD is (most likely) getting voted off tonight anyway, and since I hate him, he doesn't get to sing an FM song. So there.
Suzie- I guess Suzie can have Rhiannon. Or maybe Dreams.
Jordis- GDW for sure. :cool:
Rickypt
08-31-2005, 05:29 PM
I hate myself for being so hooked on this show. I think it's a very cheesy and tacky way for INXS to replace Hutchence and move forward.
But it got me to drag out the old Cd's that I haven't listened to in 10 years or so. My god, what a fantastic band they were.
And I love the weekly concerts because, unlike American Idol, I love nearly every song they sing.
I will likely not follow the band when this show is over. For a long time, I thought JD was the only one who could front the band because he could pull off singing the old stuff. But I just can't stand him. Hutchence had natural sexiness; JD is a poser.
The remaining folks are all very talented, but I can't see any of them as the lead of INXS.
gldstwmn
08-31-2005, 05:59 PM
But it got me to drag out the old Cd's that I haven't listened to in 10 years or so. My god, what a fantastic band they were.
I know. I did the same thing. :)
on tape. I always watch it before the results show. I have to say that I liked Jordis again. And surprisely, I liked Marty. Usually he screams his songs, & I thought he really put some softness & feeling in this Pink Floyd song.
I just don't like J.D., Mig or Ty. Yeah, Ty's hair is too distracting; he needs to join a punk rock band or something. I think J.D. & Mig think too highly of themselves & they shouldn't.
I just don't like Susie. I think she's improved, but I just think she could cut it as the lead singer of INXS.
Lee :)
gldstwmn
08-31-2005, 11:01 PM
SPOILER
Ty is gone, as I suspected.
Beachwood Mac
09-01-2005, 02:22 AM
Not surprised that Ty is gone. I also think Jordis showed her lack of range in regards to INXS songs. I think she has a great voice but I'm not sure she can handle fronting a band with songs that require so much energy. She may be the next to go.
I'm not a fan but JD may be the eventual winner because he does fit the mold they may be looking for. I would like to see Suzie win. She has a great voice and I think people will be less inclined to compare her to Michael Hutchence as they will if one of the guys ends up winning.
Terry
golden braid
09-01-2005, 10:53 AM
I think Jordis will be leaving too. I can't see her fronting INXS. Her performance last night was bland. I think Suzie has a good chance of winning as well as Mig. I didn't think Suzie's performance of Bohemian Rhapsody was all that though. It was ok but I liked Constantine's version on AI better.
gldstwmn
09-01-2005, 10:55 AM
Not surprised that Ty is gone. I also think Jordis showed her lack of range in regards to INXS songs. I think she has a great voice but I'm not sure she can handle fronting a band with songs that require so much energy. She may be the next to go.
I'm not a fan but JD may be the eventual winner because he does fit the mold they may be looking for. I would like to see Suzie win. She has a great voice and I think people will be less inclined to compare her to Michael Hutchence as they will if one of the guys ends up winning.
Terry
I agree. I think Jordis may be next. I think Hayley was right in her earlier post. If Marty or Suzie win, they'll never have a career. And I really like them so if they don't win it could be a blessing in disguise. I see JD play weddings and bar mitzvahs. :lol:
gldstwmn
09-06-2005, 11:54 PM
Well, I think Jordis may be in jeopardy. Did anyone get a chance to watch tonight?
BTFLCHLD
09-06-2005, 11:57 PM
Well, I think Jordis may be in jeopardy. Did anyone get a chance to watch tonight? im in cali so i am set to watch in a few minutes :) what happened to sunday?
BTFLCHLD
09-07-2005, 12:04 AM
smeared chocolate on marty and mig...
i could have watched that for an hour :]
Beachwood Mac
09-07-2005, 12:21 AM
Jordis will have to do what she hasn't been able to do well to stay on the show - and that is to do a good cover of an INXS song. As much as I hate to say it - JD has what it takes to front this band. I thought he did very well on both songs tonight. I loved Trees by Marty and it could be a hit for him on his own if he doesn't make the band. Of course, they may also want the song enough to take Marty. In the end I think it will come down to Marty and JD.
Terry
ontheEdgeof17
09-07-2005, 12:21 AM
Well, I think Jordis may be in jeopardy. Did anyone get a chance to watch tonight?
Agreed. She is lackluster and uninspired. Dave was right when he asked her if she has lost her spunk.
Mig was okay.
Marty gets on my nerves.
Suzy is awesome, but not right for the band.
JD had the best original song, IMO.
In conclusion, no matter the winner, the band is doomed. :laugh:
wondergirl9847
09-07-2005, 12:36 AM
I loved Marty's song! He was my fave tonight and I'm totally on his train now. Choo choo, indeed. MiG was okay, but not as good as I'd hoped. I cannot stand Suzie and Jordis was awful. JD was really great too...and I think it will come down between Marty, MiG and JD. I'm hoping for that scenario, anyways.
golden braid
09-07-2005, 12:56 AM
Well, I think Jordis may be in jeopardy. Did anyone get a chance to watch tonight?
I used to really like Jordis but she hasn't been good at all the last few weeks. I think this will be her last week. I liked JD's and Marty's originals the best. Suzie's and Mig's were too sappy for me.
mikeschmike
09-07-2005, 02:17 AM
I think Jordis did a better job with We Are the Champions then JD, but her original canceled that right out. Very disappointing. But even if she gets the boot tomorrow, I'm sure she'll get a record deal. If it's the right song she can sing the hell out of it. Kind of like Stevie in a way. Anyway, I think JD was pulling an Elvis tonight ( I swear I saw a sneer) and Mig just got on my nerves.
Suzie killed it with I Can't Make You Love Me, and how cute is Trees by Marty? That song made him my new favorite.
I think it's going to get really good from here on out.
Livia
09-07-2005, 09:09 AM
When does JD NOT "pull an Elvis?" :lol: You know he was an Elvis impersonator, right? He can't help it - there's always a sneer or a pelvic thrust. Ironically, he butchered "Suspicious Minds" a couple weeks ago.
Marty was my fave last nite. But Mig's gonna win. :rolleyes:
BTFLCHLD
09-07-2005, 11:08 AM
yes marty forever you n me in the trees a recipe for disaster :sigh:
i dont like jd but he sounded inxsish with pretty vegas
i was surprised suzie recd a good rate from the dave as im sure i heard her squeek
jordis is too weak for a band if this tryout is getting to her as it obv is
mig was hot...id like to see him not resort to a striptease...although i love to see him ripped as he is :pant: the assessment by dave was right on...
BTFLCHLD
09-07-2005, 12:40 PM
ive tickets for the 14th...
be allupon marty :]
SapphireSister
09-07-2005, 01:15 PM
It's really too bad about Jordis. She was my pick all along from the very beginning but after the last few weeks there's no way she's going to win. I really think her age and lack of experience are huge disadvantages. I hope she still gets a record deal though...she's still my favorite even if she isn't right for the lead singer of INXS.
Susie has a great voice no doubt but she is SO not right for the band and downright annoying at times. JD is way too cocky. I hope the bands sees it and wants no parts of him. Mig or Marty are the obvious choices.
BTFLCHLD
09-07-2005, 03:48 PM
I Marty...totally on his train now what took you so long? ;) he kills me ... wish we had him nightly :]
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/ummph.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
SapphireSister
09-07-2005, 04:10 PM
what took you so long? ;) he kills me ... wish we had him nightly :]
<img src="http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a152/BTFLCHLD/ummph.jpg" alt="Image hosted by Photobucket.com">
I am a HUGE Marty fan. I think he is really great. The only thing that concerns me (and I think INXS feels the same) is that his style of singing is very over the top. He yells a lot and his style of singing is amazing but it's not very INXS. I could see him being the lead singer of a goth band and being fabulous or something more along the lines of The Killers. He's almost too edgy for INXS IMO.
BTFLCHLD
09-07-2005, 04:26 PM
I am a HUGE Marty fan. I think he is really great. The only thing that concerns me (and I think INXS feels the same) is that his style of singing is very over the top. He yells a lot and his style of singing is amazing but it's not very INXS. I could see him being the lead singer of a goth band and being fabulous or something more along the lines of The Killers. He's almost too edgy for INXS IMO. oh yeah leave inxs for someone else...
marty really is beyond inxs imo :wavey:
gldstwmn
09-07-2005, 08:33 PM
But Mig's gonna win. :rolleyes:
That's what I think too.
wondergirl9847
09-07-2005, 08:34 PM
I got on the train as fast as I could!! LOL
I've said this on another board...Marty looks like he wants to climb through my TV and slit my throat....and that is hot. :laugh:
BTW, Jordis sounds like Southern fried a$$ singing Need You Tonight right now. :shocked:
Beachwood Mac
09-07-2005, 08:48 PM
These are the times I hate living on the west coast. Not on until 9pm. What's a boy to do? Why, cheat of course and check the Rockstar INXS message boards... :D
Terry
gldstwmn
09-07-2005, 09:19 PM
did anyone else notice Trishelle from the Real World in the audience last night? I could've sworn that was her.
see Jordis go. I always looked forward to hearing her sing, but I do believe we'll see her around. She doesn't need them old geezers anyway! :lol:
I'm really not too impressed with the rest of that bunch. I do think INXS will choose a guy though. :nod:
Lee :)
BTFLCHLD
09-12-2005, 10:56 PM
i dislike very much that this show isnt on as much as it was [sniff]
i miss marty! :laugh:
ok jordis fans...i couldnt stand to watch one more week of her decline...what do you think got to her?
gldstwmn
09-13-2005, 12:50 AM
i dislike very much that this show isnt on as much as it was [sniff]
i miss marty! :laugh:
ok jordis fans...i couldnt stand to watch one more week of her decline...what do you think got to her?
It was on tonight on VH1. Marty gets to sing Trees again tomorrow night. :) They had to meet one on one with INXS for their clinic. The show made it look as though JD and Marty came out on top of that. I also got the impression from tonight's show that two people were leaving tomorrow night. :shocked:
hayley
09-13-2005, 08:33 AM
It was on tonight on VH1. Marty gets to sing Trees again tomorrow night. :) They had to meet one on one with INXS for their clinic. The show made it look as though JD and Marty came out on top of that. I also got the impression from tonight's show that two people were leaving tomorrow night. :shocked:
I think they probably are, because the finale's supposed to be next week!
BTFLCHLD
09-13-2005, 11:02 AM
i will be at the show tomorrow :]
gldstwmn
09-13-2005, 11:03 AM
i will be at the show tomorrow :]
Have fun! I want to read all about it when you get back. :)
wondergirl9847
09-13-2005, 11:09 AM
What will you be wearing so we can look for you! Unless you don't want us to know. LOL
BTFLCHLD
09-13-2005, 11:10 AM
Have fun! I want to read all about it when you get back. :) yeah i will be the girl with the glassy eyes n pouty lips in front of marty :] also look forward to the tall cool glass of water mig too...you know his bod is hot :nod:
Livia
09-13-2005, 10:37 PM
Everyone was good tonight. Yes, even JD. Did ya notice Suzie screwed up a couple times, Marty and Mig both hit some clunker notes, and NO ONE said a thing?? I hope I never have to hear Trees again. Sorry, Marty.
Livia
09-13-2005, 10:40 PM
i will be at the show tomorrow :]
(Napolean Dynamite voice) LUUUCKY!!!
gldstwmn
09-13-2005, 11:40 PM
Everyone was good tonight. Yes, even JD. Did ya notice Suzie screwed up a couple times, Marty and Mig both hit some clunker notes, and NO ONE said a thing?? I hope I never have to hear Trees again. Sorry, Marty.
I think JD has this in the bag. Another thing I noticed is that they don't seem to be wearing ear monitors. Considering that they have the best of everything else, I thought that was odd.
ontheEdgeof17
09-13-2005, 11:58 PM
I hope I never have to hear Trees again. Sorry, Marty.
Trees is terrible. :cool:
JD should win. He has had the best vocals throughout the competition.
BTFLCHLD
09-14-2005, 08:56 AM
christy...look at my profile pic...add to that a bit of drool...a funky colored green jean jacket (which will prolly induce a bead of sweat but i get cold real easy) and glassy eyes...yeah you will be able to pick me out of the crowd! lol ok guys im prolly gonna be late they start at 9am! i hope they let us talk to the "rockstars" before or after the show...i will be back tonight with a rundown... ///*-*)
hayley
09-14-2005, 09:45 AM
I thought Mig looked so terrible tonight up next to the other three. I'm not the biggest fan in the world of Trees, but it's a lot better than J.D.'s song, which is NOT good. Every episode and every performance that goes by of his makes me hate him even more. He's an arrogant prick, and I honestly cannot imagine INXS wanting to share a dressing room with that jerk every night.
I thought Marty was FANTASTIC. Trees was fine, but Creep? Ohhhh. Creep is one of my favorite songs of all time, and he gave me chills. It was awesome.
My company has signed INXS, and is putting out the Night at the Mayan CD- whomever wins this contest is someone I will have to work with and for, and if it's J.D., we'll all be miserable.
BTFLCHLD
09-14-2005, 05:53 PM
Sorry to disappoint…but it was a bust
Ive a story for you though
I got off late
latest one could arrive was 9
When I arrived at 930 there was a crowd of 20 of us outside the CBS gate
We all had tickets but because we were late they filled with those who just showed
Anyways…they said we could hang and they were awaiting one more radio call to see if more room…so we hung….
all of he sudden this truck pulls out of the cbs gate honking a couple of times and pointing to his co-driver across the street
We all look over to the cross-corner and there’s a blond girl in the gutter with a trash can spilled Everywhere and her scooter in the street…like wtf! A guy from the gas station runs to her aid…I say to the crowd as they just stand there “lets all run to her aid!” (sarcasm included) they all smile and laugh. So I stood there for a moment, the girl is up and takes off her shoes…another guy comes from the station with papertowels…she gets on her cell…the guys are fumbling…I stood there for another 20 secs asking myself where the F are my priorities…I told everyone good luck…and went across the street. I walked up to her side, and asked her if she needed help or a ride…she was on the phone and busted out crying…and with relief told the other on the line that a lady came and will help her…the caller must of asked of me, as the girl then stated “yes she is a very nice lady.” The guys that came on the scene said “you will take care of her?” I said yes, and while she hung up still crying, she starts to put on her shoes…her feet are all f’d up bleeding on the sides from scrapes and already bruising…I told her don’t put your shoes on walk barefoot, and I will get everything for you…my truck was right there…I gathered her things, she held my shoulder, and with her scooter we hobbled to my truck. I sat her in the front seat, and it was hell getting that heavy arse scooter into the back of my truck let me tell you (no one offered to help!) anyways, I get in my truck, and she asked if I could take her to work at Bloomingdales Beverly center…I asked if she was sure she didn’t want to go to the hospital, and she said no that they would help her with first aid etc (that is who she was calling.) I said OK and we were off. I told her a quick story about me falling on my bike as a kid, just learning to ride and going down the steepest hill I could find, and scraping my feet the entire way down. Told her I still had scars. I told her I was thankful I was there to help her, and she said she was so scared of those guys and thankful I was there too. I told her it was OK to cry as I know it hurts, and she busted out…poor babe. Anyways, we get to blomingdales, I dismount her scooter (ugh), take the elevator up to from the park garage, and I take her to the employee rooms and they immed take hold of her. She thanked me over and over, and I said it was ok no big. She asked my name, and I asked hers.
(hello lexi! hope you are all betters!) :xoxo:
Anyways, here is where it gets really good :D so I drive back by cbs and they are all still standing there…im like F it…im going to go see my dad at forest lawn Glendale which I have been meaning to do for months…so I get there, visit for a while…and then as always I like to go to the museum there…they have all this cool stuff…ancient gold and jewels …emeralds and rubies etc…I enjoy seeing through the glass…I get to the museum and there is an exhibit going on…rock & roll album art…im like cool wonder if FM is here…
so I walk around the corner and lo behold there is a 4’ x 4’ piece on the wall of ms nicks (it all comes down to you) :nod:
the piece was labeled stevie nicks, publicity, 1995 guy webster
In summary I stared into her dark pools for a while and felt better about…well…just everything…
Bottom line, when someone needs help DO SOMETHING…
Peace!
PS my fab jacket has oil stains on it now…oh well lol
will catch the show tonight on tv :D
BTFLCHLD
09-14-2005, 06:36 PM
pss the guys at the cbs security gate
did nothing for this woman but point :mad:
wondergirl9847
09-14-2005, 06:50 PM
Just got a jewel for your crown. :angel:
If I have to hear Trees one more time, I'm going to hurl! :nod: Where is the hurl smilie?
BTW, I think Jordis threw it on purpose. She's got a record deal; I just know it. I looked forward to hearing her sing every week, & now I look forward to no one singing.
JD will probably win. He's cocky enough to fit in with this band.
OMG, where is my mute button? He's singing trees again! Who is requesting he sing this song again? :(
Lee :(
gldstwmn
09-14-2005, 11:04 PM
Well, they managed to get rid of the only woman left. I guess we all knew that was coming though. I'm begining to wonder if Mig is indeed a ringer.
golden braid
09-15-2005, 12:06 AM
I'm bummed that Suzie is gone. I really wanted her to make the top 3. I think she did better that Mig last night. His Paint It Black wasn't that great. Mig is a little too goofy for me.
Beachwood Mac
09-15-2005, 03:54 AM
Sorry to see Suzie go tonight but it was her time. She really brought it up a level the last month and should do well.
Of the remaining 3 Jd is a lock. He is getting all the props from the band and his voice and style will blend better with the rest of the band. I'm not a fan but the band will play it safe instead of going in a new direction with Marty and choose JD.
Mig will have a new career as a Chippendale dancer.
Rickypt
09-15-2005, 12:15 PM
If I have to hear Trees one more time, I'm going to hurl! (
You and me both, and it's been in my head all morning. I do thank God for small favors though, at least we didn't have to suffer through the megaphone portion of Pretty Vegas last night.
The show was very lame this week, making us listen to those same songs over and over.
I thought booting Suzie was lame. It proved to me that they were never truly interested in having a woman. Otherwise they'd at least keep her until the finale for one last consideration.
Mig offers nothing more than Suzie; he is suited for touring musicals or maybe an Undergear model. I thought his "What You Need" stunk and he overdid the stage moves. I have no idea why he does so well with the votes; maybe he gets a huge chunk of votes from Australia?
JD is clearly the best person if INXS wants to play it safe. He is the closest to Hutchence--but let's be clear, he is NO Michael Hutchence.
Even though I'm addicted to the show, the whole thing is creepy. These guys should find someone around their own age if they want to continue INXS. If I were one of the top 3, I wouldn't want to be chosen because they'll probably have a better chance of stardom on their own.
The best thing about this show is that it got me to listen to all the old albums again and remember what a fantastic band they were.
BTFLCHLD
09-15-2005, 02:01 PM
mig...his inxs song was a disappointment...he just doesnt have the voice...pretty sure he was slurring through most of it.
suzie...she should not have been removed...she sounds better than mig...
marty...glad he didnt go with acoustic...id rather see him stirke out on his own.
jd...inxs wil choose him as he is the most formable to oldstyle inxs.
brooke has said "this season of rock star"...so i am wondering which band will be next.
Rickypt
09-15-2005, 02:25 PM
brooke has said "this season of rock star"...so i am wondering which band will be next.
Hopefully not FM replacing Christine McVie
gldstwmn
09-15-2005, 04:41 PM
mig...his inxs song was a disappointment...he just doesnt have the voice...pretty sure he was slurring through most of it.
suzie...she should not have been removed...she sounds better than mig...
marty...glad he didnt go with acoustic...id rather see him stirke out on his own.
jd...inxs wil choose him as he is the most formable to oldstyle inxs.
brooke has said "this season of rock star"...so i am wondering which band will be next.
Also, the final three get a car and I would have at least liked to have seen Suzie get a car.
goldie
09-15-2005, 05:54 PM
mig...his inxs song was a disappointment...he just doesnt have the voice...pretty sure he was slurring through most of it.
suzie...she should not have been removed...she sounds better than mig...
marty...glad he didnt go with acoustic...id rather see him stirke out on his own.
jd...inxs wil choose him as he is the most formable to oldstyle inxs.
brooke has said "this season of rock star"...so i am wondering which band will be next.
I agree with you on all of these.
Mig ... ick!!! He's just gross to me. Tearing his shirt open? ok, whatever!
Rickypt
09-15-2005, 06:04 PM
Also, the final three get a car and I would have at least liked to have seen Suzie get a car.
I think Suzie will do a lot better than a car. We'll be hearing from Sweet Suzie McNeil a long time after INXS records one CD with JD Fortune and then realizes not only can't they work with him, but no one is interested once the TV show goes away.
BTFLCHLD
09-15-2005, 06:09 PM
Tearing his shirt open? ok, whatever! as i mentioned in a post early on i was hoping he wouldnt resort to a striptease but alas it seems he has. this ploy may work in early career attempts but hardly professional...i think it cheapened his appeal...at least for me. he does have a hot bod tho :D
gldstwmn
09-15-2005, 07:51 PM
I think Suzie will do a lot better than a car. We'll be hearing from Sweet Suzie McNeil a long time after INXS records one CD with JD Fortune and then realizes not only can't they work with him, but no one is interested once the TV show goes away.
I hope you're right dear. I really like her and was pissed that the boys got the cars. :(
goldie
09-15-2005, 09:32 PM
he does have a hot bod tho :D
That he does! Those pecs were quite scrumptuous despite the fact that he creeps me out. I admit I had my eye on those.
BTFLCHLD
09-16-2005, 06:04 PM
for those interested...this is from mark & brain klos radio show...jd etc plus marty does suicide blonde
http://s18.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=33QBYWHLJUXNO2O1GBXKQNLCDH
Beachwood Mac
09-16-2005, 08:48 PM
for those interested...this is from mark & brain klos radio show...jd etc plus marty does suicide blonde
http://s18.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=33QBYWHLJUXNO2O1GBXKQNLCDH
Thanks BTFLCHLD... JD sounds better when you don't have to look at him. He also seems the most at ease singing the INXS songs. I'll be surprised if he doesn't get picked.
gldstwmn
09-19-2005, 11:20 AM
Did anyone see this on VH1 last night? They got to pick whatever song they wanted for the finale.
The last shots were of them throwing chairs into the pool and walking away with their suitcases.
BTFLCHLD
09-19-2005, 11:28 AM
Did anyone see this on VH1 last night? They got to pick whatever song they wanted for the finale.
The last shots were of them throwing chairs into the pool and walking away with their suitcases. :( no i missed it...do you recall what songs they chose?
gldstwmn
09-19-2005, 03:16 PM
:( no i missed it...do you recall what songs they chose?
SPOILER
JD chose You Can't Always Get What You Want
Mig chose Bohemian Rhapsody
I can't remember what Marty chose. :sorry:
DavidMn
09-19-2005, 03:17 PM
Is it over yet? None too soon for me.
gldstwmn
09-19-2005, 03:35 PM
SPOILER
Marty is singing Wish You Were Here. :)
Rickypt
09-19-2005, 06:16 PM
SPOILER
Mig is a total fool choosing BR. INXS asked the guys to choose a song that most defines them, and he takes a Queen song--thus reminding the band that his background is in rock musicals. I can't believe this guy made the top 3; his pecs are not THAT great.
Suzie, you were ROBBED. :distress:
BTFLCHLD
09-19-2005, 06:20 PM
SPOILER
Mig is a total fool choosing BR. INXS asked the guys to choose a song that most defines them, and he takes a Queen song--thus reminding the band that his background is in rock musicals. I can't believe this guy made the top 3; his pecs are not THAT great.
Suzie, you were ROBBED. :distress: agreed :thumbsup: the only thing i have to add is mig was doing pretty good in the beginning...but due to navarro's weekly egg-on about taking his shirt off...mig fell head on into that. he will see that in hindsight im sure...im disappointed suzie wasnt in the final 3
gldstwmn
09-19-2005, 06:24 PM
SPOILER
Mig is a total fool choosing BR. INXS asked the guys to choose a song that most defines them, and he takes a Queen song--thus reminding the band that his background is in rock musicals. I can't believe this guy made the top 3; his pecs are not THAT great.
Suzie, you were ROBBED. :distress:
I totally agree! You should've seen the look on Marty's face when Mig told him he was doing BR.
BTFLCHLD
09-19-2005, 06:28 PM
I totally agree! You should've seen the look on Marty's face when Mig told him he was doing BR. i was surprised to read that marty's first instinct was to grab JD's pretty vegas! im glad he thought twice on that...that would have looked like he was desperately trying to outdo JD and IMO he doesnt need to do that...im on the edge of my seat for tomorrow night...i feel they will choose JD first, then marty, then mig...marty will either solo or continue with lovehammers which would be best rather than the inxs hookup...imo :wavey:
btw thanks for the info on the song selection :thumbsup:
gldstwmn
09-19-2005, 06:32 PM
i was surprised to read that marty's first instinct was to grab JD's pretty vegas! im glad he thought twice on that...that would have looked like he was desperately trying to outdo JD and IMO he doesnt need to do that...im on the edge of my seat for tomorrow night...i feel they will choose JD first, then marty, then mig...marty will either solo or continue with lovehammers which would be best rather than the inxs hookup...imo :wavey:
btw thanks for the info on the song selection :thumbsup:
You're welcome. :wavey:
I really want to see JD win so Marty can have a career. Mig will survive no matter what happens to him.
Beachwood Mac
09-19-2005, 06:46 PM
Marty is playing to win. According to what I read, he took Pretty Vegas so JD couldn't choose it. He also thought it was a dumb move for Mig to choose BR but when Mig asked him he told him to go for it knowing what INXS would think.
Terry
Rickypt
09-19-2005, 06:53 PM
According to what I read, he took Pretty Vegas so JD couldn't choose it.
I'm not a Marty fan, but I would like to send him some flowers for ensuring that we don't have to hear Pretty Vegas again! At least not until JD wins and it becomes the next INXS single.
Beachwood Mac
09-19-2005, 07:04 PM
I'm not a Marty fan, but I would like to send him some flowers for ensuring that we don't have to hear Pretty Vegas again! At least not until JD wins and it becomes the next INXS single.
I'll chip in on the flowers!
Here's the text from the recap about the song selection:
With all the songs laid out on the floor before them, the three of them decide that they can put a hold on the songs they want. Marty quickly makes a strategic move and grabs "Pretty Vegas," keeping J.D. from his most popular song. J.D. decides on the Rolling Stones' "You Can't Always Get What You Want." The song was a showstopper for Ty a few weeks ago, but J.D. has a personal reason for wanting this tune: It's the song he's requested to be played at his funeral (along with another Stones classic, "Sympathy For The Devil").
J.D. doesn't want to repeat himself: "I'm here to progress, not regress," he says. Marty ends up deciding to reprise his performance of Pink Floyd's "Wish You Were Here," because it's the song with which he found a new voice. MiG's instinct is to take Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody," but he's not sure it's the right move. Privately, Marty says that for MiG, singing that song would be a "shaky decision." It would send the wrong message if he's trying to show INXS that he's moved on from being the lead in a Queen musical. But when MiG asks for advice, with a straight face, Marty tells him, "Go for it."
BTFLCHLD
09-19-2005, 07:53 PM
Marty is playing to win. According to what I read, he took Pretty Vegas so JD couldn't choose it. He also thought it was a dumb move for Mig to choose BR but when Mig asked him he told him to go for it knowing what INXS would think.
Terry yes terry i understand that was his reasoning but it may have looked otherwise...im just glad he decided against it...who knew marty was such the strategist! :D
ontheEdgeof17
09-20-2005, 09:16 PM
I'm so sick of these people singing the same songs over and over and over and over and over. It's worse than American Idol.
gldstwmn
09-20-2005, 11:04 PM
Aaaaand the winner is...JD Fortune. It'll be interesting to see how this works out.
ShangriLaTroubl
09-21-2005, 12:43 AM
Aaaaand the winner is...JD Fortune. It'll be interesting to see how this works out.
AHHH thanks for the spoiler for those of us on the west coast.
Chris
I taped it, but haven't watched it yet. Yeah, it's another anticlimatic show. I knew they didn't want a woman as a lead singer, & I knew it would be JD. He's cocky enough to fit in their band. I really don't like him, so I don't know if I'm going to like the new INXS. :shrug:
Lee :)
gldstwmn
09-21-2005, 10:47 AM
AHHH thanks for the spoiler for those of us on the west coast.
Chris
At 11:45 pm? What time is it out there? :sorry:
hayley
09-21-2005, 11:34 AM
JD sucks. I have to work with that chump now.
I thought Marty's performance with INXS was fantastic, and that JD's was... boring. Then again, I hate "What You Need" and have hated it more every week that goes by where they make some hack sing it.
gldstwmn
09-21-2005, 03:00 PM
JD sucks. I have to work with that chump now.
I thought Marty's performance with INXS was fantastic, and that JD's was... boring. Then again, I hate "What You Need" and have hated it more every week that goes by where they make some hack sing it.
You didn't want to Marty to win anyway though. If you have any JD anecdotes, I'd love to hear them.
mikeschmike
09-21-2005, 03:03 PM
JD sucks. I have to work with that chump now.
I thought Marty's performance with INXS was fantastic, and that JD's was... boring. Then again, I hate "What You Need" and have hated it more every week that goes by where they make some hack sing it.
That's awful! To have to work with that cocky prick. Job search time!
Rickypt
09-21-2005, 03:51 PM
On my deathbed, I know I will ask myself why I wasted 3 hours per week the summer of 2005.
hayley
09-21-2005, 05:37 PM
You didn't want to Marty to win anyway though. If you have any JD anecdotes, I'd love to hear them.
Yeah, that's true. I'd be pissy either way though, as we all know :)
I'm already starting to hear a little bit about the INXS tour in the states... large-ish theatres, $60-$70 top ticket, in January/February or so. It should be... interesting... to see how it does.
I just wonder who they're going to get for the next version of Rock Star. We were joking today in the office that maybe it'll be Rock Star: Blind Melon. "You're just not right for our band, Blind Melon." "Yeah, Contestant #1... we'll need you to sing 'No Rain.' Same goes for you, other two. That's the only song we have."
Etc.
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.