Categorizing FM Songs / Your Personal Taste

[bluecalmsea]

How would you personally categorize the songs of the Rumours lineup band? (I did not include SYW since there is no Christine on the album, but feel free to add it to yours) My categories are:

• Perfection & Almost Perfection (would never skip these songs)
  
• Likes (great, but not always interested in hearing)
  
• Neutrals (no strong feelings of love or hate, just exists)
  
• Cheesy (one could still like or dislike a cheesy song)
  
• Why does this exist (cringe/ hate)

In total, I have

19 Perfect, 19 likes, 15 neutral, 10 cheesy, 8 cringe out of 71 songs

So, I think:
27% of the songs are perfect
27% of the songs are likeable
21% are okay/no strong feelings
14% are cheesy (love them or like them
11% are cringey

My ratings:

From the Fleetwood Mac album, 11 songs:

Perfect: Crystal
Like: Monday Morning, Rhiannon, Over My Head, Say You Love Me, World Turning, I'm So Afraid
Neutral: Blue Letter, Landslide
Cheesy: Warm Ways (like), Sugar Daddy (like)
Cringe:

So 1 perfect, 6 likes, 2 neutral, 2 cheesy, 0 cringe

Rumours Album, 11 songs:

Perfect: NGBA, Go Your Own Way, The Chain
Like: Second Hand News, Dreams, Gold Dust Woman, You Make Loving Fun
Neutral: Songbird
Cheesy: Don't Stop (slightly disklike cheesy), IDWK (like)
Cringe: Oh Daddy

So 3 perfect, 4 likes, 1 neutral, 2 cheesy, 1 cringe

Tusk Album, 20 songs:

Perfect: Sara, Storms, Sisters of the Moon, Angel, Tusk, Think About Me
Like: Over and Over, Honey Hi, Walk a Thin Line, Never Forget
Neutral: Save Me a Place, What Makes You Think You're the One, That's All for Everyone, That's Enough for Me, Brown Eyes
Cheesy: Beautiful Child (like), Never Make Me Cry (dislike), IKINW
Cringe: Not that Funny, The Ledge

So 6 perfect, 4 likes, 5 neutrals, 3 cheesy, 2 cringe

Mirage Album, 12 songs:

Perfect: That's Alright, Book of Love, Gypsy, Straight Back
Like: Love in Store, Can't Go Back, Only Over You
Neutral: Eyes of the World, Wish You Were Here
Cheesy: Hold Me (like)
Cringe: Empire State, Oh Diane

So 4 perfect, 3 likes, 2 neutral, 1 cheesy, 2 cringe

Tango in the Night Album, 12 songs:

Perfect: Seven Wonders, Caroline, Tango in the Night, Isn't it Midnight
Like: Big Love, Mystified
Neutral: Welcome to the Room Sara, When I See You Again
Cheesy: Everywhere (like), Little Lies (like)
Cringe: Family Man, You and I, Part II

So 4 perfect, 2 likes, 2 neutral, 2 cheesy, 2 cringe

The Dance DVD, 5 songs:

Perfect: Silver Springs
Like:
Neutral: Temporary One, Sweet Girl, Bleed to Love Her
Cheesy:
Cringe: My Little Demon

So 1 perfect, 3 neutral, 1 cringe

How would you rank their songs?

For reference:
Fleetwood Mac:
Monday Morning
Warm Ways
Blue Letter
Rhiannon
Over My Head
Crystal
Say You Love Me
Landslide
World Turning
Sugar Daddy
I'm So Afraid

Rumours
Second Hand News
Dreams
Never Going Back Again
Don't Stop
Go Your Own Way
Songbird
The Chain
You Make Loving Fun
I Don't Want to Know
Oh Daddy
Gold Dust Woman

Tusk
Over & Over
The Ledge
Think About Me
Save Me a Place
Sara
What Makes You Think You're the One
Storms
That's All for Everyone
Not That Funny
Sisters of the Moon
Angel
That's Enough for Me
Brown Eyes
Never Make Me Cry
I Know I'm Not Wrong
Honey Hi
Beautiful Child
Walk a Thin Line
Tusk
Never Forget

Mirage
Love in Store
Can't Go Back
That's Alright
Book of Love
Gypsy
Only Over You
Empire State
Straight Back
Hold Me
Oh Diane
Eyes of the World
Wish You Were Here

Tango in the Night
Big Love
Seven Wonders
Everywhere
Caroline
Tango in the Night
Mystified
Little Lies
Family Man
Welcome to the Room...Sara
Isn't It Midnight
When I See You Again
You and I, Part II

The Dance
Temporary One
Bleed to Love Her
My Little Demon
Silver Springs
Sweet Girl

[WildHearted]

Fleetwood Mac:
Perfection: Monday Morning, Blue Letter, Rhiannon, Over My Head, Crystal, Say You Love Me, Landslide, World Turning
Like: I'm So Afraid (love the song, not the album version particularly)
Neutral/cheesy: Warm Ways, Sugar Daddy


Rumours
Perfection: Second Hand News, Dreams, Never Going Back Again, Go Your Own Way, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, I Don't Want to Know, Gold Dust Woman
Like: Songbird, Oh Daddy
Cheesy: Don't Stop

Tusk
Perfection: The Ledge, Think About Me, Sara, What Makes You Think You're The One, Storms, Not That Funny, Sisters of the Moon, Beautiful Child
Like: Save Me a Place, That's All For Everyone, I Know I'm Not Wrong, Tusk, Angel
Neutral: Walk a Thin Line, Never Make Me Cry, Over and Over
Dislike (I don't cringe, I just never ever listen to them): Honey Hi, Brown Eyes, That's Enough For Me, Never Forget


Mirage
Perfection: Love in Store, Can't Go Back, That's Alright, Gypsy, Hold Me, Oh Diane
Like: Straight Back, Eyes of the World, Wish You Were Here
Neutral: Only Over You, Book of Love
Why does this exist: Empire State


Tango in the Night
Perfection: Big Love, Seven Wonders, Everywhere, Tango in the Night, Little Lies, When I See You Again (shoot me)
Like: Isn't it Midnight, Caroline
Neutral: Mystified
Why does this exist: Family Man, Welcome to the Room... Sara, You and I Part II


The Dance
Perfection: Bleed to Love Her, Silver Springs
Like: Sweet Girl, Temporary One
Why does this exist: My Little Demon

[cantgoback]

Fleetwood Mac:
Perfection: Warm Ways (I don't get way everyone hates it!), Over My Head, Landslide
Like: Rhiannon (if it was like the live version it'd be under perfect), Blue Letter, Crystal, World Turning (same with Rhiannon), I'm So Afraid
Neutral: Say You Love Me
Cheesy: Monday Morning (debatable between this and neutral), Sugar Daddy

Rumours:
Perfection: Gold Dust Woman, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, Go Your Own Way, Songbird
Like: Second Hand News, Dreams, Oh Daddy, Never Going Back Again
Neutral/Cheesy: I Don't Want To Know, Don't Stop (I still love the song)
Cringe: None

Tusk:
Perfection: Sara, Storms, Over and Over, Sisters of the Moon, Never Forget (the title is ironic cause it's one of their most forgettable songs), Tusk, Brown Eyes, Think About Me (Christine's songs are very strong on this album)
Like: Beautiful Child, Never Make me Cry, Honey Hi, Angel, The Ledge, I Know I'm Not Wrong, That's Enough for Me, Walk a Thin Line
Neutral: Not that Funny, Save Me a Place
Cringe: That's All For Everyone, What Makes You Think You're the One (ugh)

Mirage:
Perfection: Gypsy, That's Alright, Love in Store, Wish You Were Here
Like: Straight Back, Eyes of the World, Hold Me, Can't Go Back
Neutral: Only Over You, Book of Love
Cheesy: Oh Diane
Cringe: Empire State

Tango In The Night:
Perfection: Seven Wonders, Little Lies, Tango In the Night, Everywhere
Like:Big Love, Caroline (not all of it is great), Isn't it Midnight (it sorta sounds like the B-52's and I love them so)
Neutral: Mystified, You and I, Pt. II
Cheesy: Welcome to the Room... Sara
Cringe: Family Man, When I see you Again

The Dance:
Perfection: Bleed to Love Her, Silver Springs
Like: Temporary One
Neutral Sweet Girl
CheesyMy Little Demon

[moon]

FLEETWOOD MAC
Perfection: Monday Morning, Over my Head
Like: Warm Ways, Rhiannon, Landslide, Blue Letter, Say you love me
Neutral: Crystal, World Turning
Dislike: Sugar Daddy, I'm So Afraid

RUMOURS
Perfection: Second Hand News, Go Your Own Way, Never Going Back Again
Like: Don't Stop, The Chain, Gold Dust Woman, Dreams, You make loving fun, Songbird
Dislike: Oh Daddy, I don't want to know

TUSK
Perfection: Brown Eyes, Over & Over, Tusk, What Makes You Think You're The One, Sara, Sisters of the Moon
Like: Think about me, Save me a place, That's all for everyone, Not That Funny
Neutral: Angel, Never make me cry, I know I'm not wrong, Walk a Thin Line, Never forget, The Ledge
Dislike: Storms, Beautiful Child
Why does this exist: Honey Hi, That's enough for me

LIVE
Perfection: Oh Well
Neutral: Don't let me down again, One more night
Dislike: Fireflies, The Farmer's Daughter

MIRAGE
Perfection: Love In Store, Can't Go Back, Book of Love, Gypsy, Straight Back, Oh Diane, Wish You Were Here
Like: That's Alright, Only Over You, Empire State, Eyes of the World, Hold Me

TANGO IN THE NIGHT
Perfection: Big Love, Tango in the Night, Everywhere
Like: Seven Wonders, Little Lies, Isn't it midnight, Welcome to the Room...Sara, Family Man, You & I (Part II)
Neutral: Caroline, Mystified, When I see you again

THE DANCE:
Perfection: Bleed to Love Her, Silver Springs, Sweet Girl
Like: Temporary One, My Little Demon

Well, I really wanted to put the complete setlist of The Dance! I think there's lot of performances that are "perfection" too.
Regards and thanks!

[FierySequences]

wow, what an extensive list...but good topic/thread. Wild Hearted, I pretty much cut/paste alot of your answers. Is it any wonder why almost ALL of Tusk is Perfect?

Fleetwood Mac:
Perfection: Rhiannon, Crystal, Say You Love Me, World Turning
Like: Blue Letter, I'm So Afraid, MM, Sugar Daddy, OMH
Neutral/cheesy: Landslide, Warm Ways


Rumours
Perfection: Dreams, Go Your Own Way, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, Gold Dust Woman
Like: I Don't Want to Know, Second Hand News
Cheesy: Never Going Back Again, Don't Stop, Songbird, Oh Daddy (like the live version much better)

Tusk
Perfection: Over and Over, The Ledge, Think About Me, Sara, What Makes You Think You're The One, Storms, Not That Funny, Sisters of the Moon, Beautiful Child, I Know I'm Not Wrong, Never Forget, Tusk, Angel, Brown Eyes
Like: Honey Hi, That's Enough For Me
Neutral: Never Make Me Cry
Dislike: Save Me a Place, Walk a Thin Line, That's All For Everyone

Live:
Perfection: Fireflies, Farmers Daughter
Like: DLMDA, Oh Well
Neutral: One More Night

Mirage
Perfection: Love in Store, Can't Go Back, That's Alright, Gypsy, Hold Me, Oh Diane
Like: Straight Back, Eyes of the World, Wish You Were Here, Book of Love, Empire State
Neutral/ Cheesy: Only Over You



Tango in the Night
Perfection: Big Love, Tango in the Night, Little Lies, Isn't it Midnight
Like: Seven Wonders, Everywhere, Caroline, Family Man, When I See You Again
Neutral: Welcome to the Room... Sara, You and I Part II
Cheesy: Mystified


The Dance
Perfection: My Little Demon, Sweet Girl, Silver Springs
Like: Bleed to Love Her
Neutral: Temporary One

[MacShadowsBall]

Fleetwood Mac

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Say You Love Me, World Turning, Monday Morning

Likes - Sugar Daddy

Neutrals - I'm So Afraid, Landslide, Crystal, Blue Letter, Over My Head

Cheesy - Warm Ways

Why does this exist - Rhiannon

Rumours

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Don't Stop, Go Your Own Way, Dreams

Likes - Go Your Own Way, Second Hand News, Oh Daddy, The Chain, Gold Dust Woman

Neutrals - Never Going Back Again, Songbird,

Cheesy - I Don't Want to Know

Why does this exist - none

Tusk

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Sisters of the Moon

Likes - Angel, Save Me a Place

Neutrals - everything else except Lindsey's songs

Cheesy/Why does this exist - the rest of Lindsey' songs!

Mirage

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Gypsy, Wish You Were Here

Likes - Hold Me, Oh Diane, Straight Back

Neutrals - Eyes of the World, Only Over You, That's Alright, Love in Store

Cheesy - Empire State

Why does this exist - Can't Go Back, Book of Love

Tango in the Night

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Isn't It Midnight, Seven Wonders

Likes - Welcome to the Room...Sara, Little Lies

Neutrals - Mystfied, Tango in the Night, You and I , Everywhere

Cheesy - Family Man, Big Love

Why does this exist - Caroline, When I See You Again

The Dance

Perfection & Almost Perfection - Silver Springs

Likes - Temporary One, Sweet Girl

Neutrals - Bleed to Love Her

Cheesy - none

Why does this exist - My Little Demon

[Nickingham]

Fleetwood Mac

Perfect: Over My Head,I'm So Afraid,World Turning

Like: Monday Morning,Rhiannon,Blue Letter

Neutral: Say You Love Me,Landslide,Warm Ways

Cheesy: Sugar Daddy,Crystal

Cringe:

Rumours

Perfect: Dreams,You Make Loving Fun

Like: Second Hand News,The Chain,Gold Dust Woman

Neutral: Oh Daddy,Go Your Own Way,Songbird,Don't Stop,I Don't Want to Know

Cheesy: Never Going Back Again

Cringe:

Tusk

Perfect: Sisters of the Moon,Tusk,Never Forget

Like: What Makes You Think You're the One,Sara,Angel,I Know I'm Not Wrong

Neutral: Over & Over,The Ledge,Think About Me,Save Me a Place,That's Enough for Me,Brown Eyes

Cheesy: Storms,That's All for Everyone,Not That Funny,Never Make Me Cry,Honey Hi,Beautiful Child,Walk a Thin Line

Cringe:

Mirage

Perfect: Hold Me,Straight Back,Only Over You,Gypsy

Like: Love in Store,Can't Go Back,That's Alright

Neutral: Eyes of the World

Cheesy: Book of Love,Wish You Were Here,Oh Diane

Cringe:Empire State

Tango in the Night

Perfect: Big Love,Tango in the Night,Family Man(Almost perfect)

Like: Everywhere,Seven Wonders,Caroline,Little Lies,Isn't It Midnight

Neutral: Mystified

Cheesy: Welcome to the Room...Sara,When I See You Again(Cheesy/Cringe)

Cringe:You and I, Part II

The Dance

Perfect: Bleed to Love Her

Like: Silver Springs

Neutral: My Little Demon,Temporary One

Cheesy: Sweet Girl

Cringe:

[Blueletter18]

FLEETWOOD MAC
Perfection: Rhiannon, Over My Head, Crystal, Landslide
Like: Warm Ways, Blue Letter, Monday Morning (BL and MM pale in comparison to the Buckingham Nicks live versions! Devastating, really...), I'm So Afraid, Say You Love Me
Neutral: World Turning
Cheesy: Sugar Daddy

RUMOURS
Perfection: Dreams, Go Your Own Way, Songbird, The Chain, I Don't Want to Know
Like: Gold Dust Woman, Second Hand News, Oh Daddy
Neutral: Never Going Back Again, You Make Loving Fun
Cheesy: Don't Stop

TUSK
Perfection: Sara, Storms, Beautiful Child, Think About Me, The Ledge, What Makes You Think You're the One, Walk a Thin Line, I Know I'm Not Wrong, Never Forget
Like: Angel (only because I feel like it could have been produced in a more exciting way, but I looooveee the song), Over and Over, Save Me a Place, Not That Funny, Sisters of the Moon, Brown Eyes, Honey Hi, Never Make Me Cry
Neutral: That's Enough For Me, Tusk

MIRAGE
Perfection: Straight Back, Gypsy, Hold Me, Oh Diane, Wish You Were Here
Like: That's Alright, Love in Store, Can't Go Back, Book of Love
Neutral: Only Over You, Eyes of the World
Dislike: Empire State

TANGO IN THE NIGHT
Perfection: Seven Wonders, Tango in the Night, When I See You Again (heartbreaker!), Everywhere
Like: Little Lies, Caroline, Isn't it Midnight, You and I Part II
Neutral: Big Love, Welcome to the Room Sara
Dislike: Mystified, Family Man

THE DANCE
Perfection: Silver Springs
Like: Bleed to Love Her, Temporary One, Sweet Girl
Dislike: My Little Demon

[redbird]

FLEETWOOD MAC (7/2/2/0)
Perfection: Blue Letter, Rhiannon, Over My Head, Landslide, Say You Love Me, World Turning, I'm So Afraid
Like: Monday Morning, Sugar Daddy
Neutral: Warm Ways, Crystal (moderate like)
Dislike: ----

RUMOURS (8/2/1/0)
Perfection: Second Hand News, Dreams, Never Going Back Again, Go Your Own Way, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, Oh Daddy, Gold Dust Woman
Like: Songbird, I Don't Wanna Know
Neutral: Don't Stop (sometimes I love it though, it's complicated)
Dislike: ----

TUSK (9/6/4/1)
Perfection: The Ledge, Sara, WMYTYTO, Storms, Not That Funny, Sisters of the Moon, Angel, Beautiful Child, Tusk
Like: Think About Me, That's All For Everyone, That's Enough For Me, I Know I'm Not Wrong, Honey Hi, Never Forget
Neutral: Over and Over (moderate like), Brown Eyes, Never Make Me Cry, Walk a Thin Line
Dislike: Save Me A Place

LIVE (2/1/2/0)
Perfection: Oh Well, Fireflies
Like: The Farmer's Daughter
Neutral: Don't Let Me Down Again, One More Night
Dislike: ----

MIRAGE (2/6/1/3)
Perfection: Gypsy, That's Alright
Like: Can't Go Back, Book of Love, Straight Back (strong like), Oh Diane, Empire State, Eyes of the World
Neutral: Love In Store
Dislike: Only Over You, Hold Me, Wish You Were Here

TANGO IN THE NIGHT (2/2/5/3)
Almost Perfection: Big Love, Little Lies
Like: Seven Wonders, Mystified
Neutral/Ambivalent: Everywhere, Tango In the Night, Isn't It Midnight, When I See You Again, You & I (Part II)
Dislike: Caroline (but I like the chorus lyrics), Family Man, Welcome to the Room…Sara

THE DANCE: (2/2/1/0)
Perfection: Bleed to Love Her, Silver Springs
Like: Temporary One, My Little Demon
Neutral: Sweet Girl
Dislike: ----


TOTAL 32/21/16/7


Funny for me that Lindsey wrote my most and least favorite Mac songs (Go You Own Way and Family Man resp). Christine had the most hits but scores the least often for me in the perfect area, especially in the 80s. I guess I'm not an 80s kid even in spirit, I love her earthier stuff. Stevie was the most consistently great for me until she totally drops off during TITN.

[TheSorcerer]

Fleetwood Mac

Perfect: Rhiannon, World Turning, Crystal, Monday Morning, I'm So Afraid, Blue Letter
Like: Landslide (I prefer the live version), Say You Love Me
Neutral: Over My Head
Dislike: Warm Ways, Sugar Daddy


Rumours

Perfect: - The Chain, Go Your Own Way, Songbird, Dreams, Gold Dust Woman, Oh Daddy
Like: Second Hand News, I Don't Want to Know
Neutral: You Make Loving Fun, Never Going Back Again, Don't Stop
Dislike: None

Tusk

Perfect: - Sara, Storms, Beautiful Child, Sisters of the Moon, Tusk Brown Eyes, Honey Hi, I Know I'm Not Wrong
Like: - Angel, Think About Me, Save Me a Place, Over & Over, That's Enough for Me
Neutral: - That's All for Everyone, Not That Funny, The Ledge
Dislike: Never Forget, Never Make Me Cry, Walk a Thin Line, What Makes You Think You're the One

Mirage


Perfect: Gypsy, That's Alright
Like: Empire State, Hold Me, Love In Store
Neutral: Eyes of the World, Only Over You, Straight Back, Wish You Were Here, Oh Diane
Dislike: Can't Go Back, Book of Love


Tango in the Night


Perfect: Isn't It Midnight, Big Love, Family Man, Caroline, Little Lies, Tango in the Night, Seven Wonders
Like: Everywhere, You and I Pt. 2
Neutral: Welcome to the Room...Sara, Mystified
Dislike: When I See You Again


The Dance


Perfect: Silver Springs
Like: Temporary One
Neutral: Sweet Girl, Bleed to Love Her
Dislike: My Little Demon

[gypsy-sara]

Fleetwood Mac

Perfection: I'm So Afraid, Landslide, Crystal, Monday Morning, World Turning

Likes: Rhiannon, Blue Letter, Say You Love Me

Neutrals: Warm Ways, Over My Head, Sugar Daddy



Rumours

Perfection: Dreams, The Chain, You Make Loving Fun, Gold Dust Woman, Second Hand News, Oh Daddy, Never Going Back Again, Don't Stop, Songbird

Likes: Go Your Own Way, I Don't Want To Know



Tusk

Perfection: Sara, Over And Over, Storms, Sisters Of The Moon, Beautiful Child, Tusk, Never Forget, I Know I'm Not Wrong, That's All For Everyone

Likes: Brown Eyes, Think About Me, Save Me A Place, What Makes You Think You're The One

Neutrals: The Ledge, Not That Funny, Angel, That's Enough For Me

Cheesy: Honey Hi, Never Make Me Cry, Walk A Thin Line



Mirage

Perfection: Gypsy

Likes: Eyes Of The World, Can't Go Back, Love In Store, Empire State, Straight Back, Wish You Were Here, Only Over You

Neutrals: Hold Me, Book Of Love

Cheesy: That's alright

Why does this even exist: Oh Diane



Tango in the Night

Perfection: Isn't It Midnight, Tango In The Night, Big Love, Seven Wonders, When I See You Again, Welcome To The Room... Sara, Caroline, Family Man, You And I Part II

Likes: Everywhere, Mystified, Little Lies



The Dance

Perfection: Silver Springs, Sweet Girl

Likes: Temporary One, Bleed to Love Her, My Little Demon

[SteveMacD]

Originally Posted by WildHearted

Tango in the Night
Perfection:...When I See You Again (shoot me)

Alright then...