PDA

View Full Version : rate "Bare Trees"


Hawkeye
05-11-2002, 09:13 PM
Bare Trees is my favorite pre BN album. I LOVE it so hoere's how I'd rate it.

Child of Mine- 9.5
The Ghost- 9.5
Homeward Bound- 10
Sunny Side of Heaven- 8.5
Bare trees- 9
Sentimental Lady- 9
Danny's Chant- 5
Spare Me A Little- 7
Dust- 10

0verall- 8.7

chiliD
05-12-2002, 01:01 AM
Child Of Mine--9.5
The Ghost--7 (down the list of my favorite Bob Welch tunes)
Homeward Bound--8.5
Sunny Side Of Heaven--(on a scale of 1 to 10) 20!!!! (The best thing Danny ever did...with FM or after) :blob2:
Bare Trees---7.5 ("Station Man" rehashed a third time..."Sands Of Time" on Future Games was second)
Sentimental Lady---8.5 (better live as first half of medley with "Future Games"...even better on "French Kiss")
Danny's Chant---8 (the intro makes an expectation the rest of the song doesn't deliver; but it's worth putting up with the rest of the song just for it.)
Spare Me A Little Of Your Love---10
Dust---8
Thoughts On A Grey Day--talk about "wasted space" :nod:

Add 'em up, divide by 9 equals an average score of 9.6

I just wonder what this album would've sounded like had the original mixes not been erased at JFK airport in 1972.

macfan 57
05-12-2002, 06:58 AM
Child Of Mine-7
The Ghost-6
Homeward Bound-9
Sunny Side of Heaven-8
Bare Trees-8
Sentimental Lady-10
Danny's Chant-5
Spare Me A Little Of Your Love-10
Dust-10
I'm not even going to rate that poem at the end. I wish they had put a song on the end instead.
Total-8.1

I really like Bare Trees. It's my second favorite Bob Welch era Fleetwood Mac album, after Mystery To Me. I think Spare Me A Little was Christine's first great song that she wrote-I love it and Dust is my favorite Danny Kirwin song. Sentimental Lady & Hypnotized are my favorite Bob Welch songs. I'd just like to get rid of that poem at the end.

Little Queenie
05-13-2002, 01:45 AM
I love Bare Trees! One of my fave Mac albums!!!


Child Of Mine-10
The Ghost-9.5
Homeward Bound-10 (I love just this song)
Sunny Side of Heaven-10 ( would give it a 20 like chiliD)
Bare Trees-9
Sentimental Lady-10
Danny's Chant-8
Spare Me A Little Of Your Love-10
Dust-10
Thoughts on a Grey Day-5(I don't mind it. Though I do wish they could have put another song at the end)

well the average came out to 9.15 but I say 9.5! I love this album
Why couldn't I be alive to see them live back then??!!!!!!!!

-April:)

jwd
05-14-2002, 10:40 PM
My favorite pre B/N Mac album

Child of Mine- 9
The Ghost- 9
Homeward Bound- 9
Sunny Side of Heaven- 9
Bare trees- 10
Sentimental Lady- 9
Danny's Chant- 7
Spare Me A Little- 9
Dust- 9

I think that works out to about an average of a 9...or one f****** good lp......even Mrs. Scarrott couldn't ruin this one!! :laugh:


Joe

Arizona Ranger
05-18-2002, 12:59 PM
Mystery To Me is the best Welch Era Album !!!!

Every song is a mystical experience !!!!

The average grade I give Bare Trees is an A - !!!!