Fav track so far

[DownOnRodeo]

Originally posted by thewhitewingedd
Illume and Goodbye Baby


NOTE:...I can't explain what I felt when I heard Goodbye Baby for the first time...I think it might be a personal best for Stevie vocals...Its just too f#@king amazing to put into words...

Adam

Yeah I guess it's just an unfortunate coincidence that the god-forsaken Lindsey Buckingham had anything to do with it, hey Adam?

[FiercestCalmSea]

Hmm....this is hard...Illume is up there..as is RTTG...I don't care what anyone says...it rocks...Linds and his guitar work And of course Goodbye Baby..

[rianbay1]

EVERYBODY FINDS OUT!!!!

[Mad4stevie]

Without question - Goodbye Baby. I also love Thrown Down and Smile at You. I think Illume will grow on me. Not too crazy about Silver Girl.

[jwd]

"Illume", "Red Rover", "Come", "Say You Will", "Thrown Down", & "Everybody Finds Out". I like Silver Girl...it does have that "I Miss You" or "If I Were You" sound to it.

"Goodbye Baby" is growing on me. They're all really good...not one I don't like.


So much to absorb from this cd. It sounds awesome. I think one of their best if not THE BEST!


Happy Say You Will Eve!



Joe

[estranged4life]

are "Everybody Finds Out", "Say You Will", "Miranda" & my personal fave is "Destiny Rules"...Brian J.

[wondergirl9847]

I'll let ya'll know which song is my favorite tomorrow, but I can pretty much guarantee, it's gonna be Red Rover. I've been in love with this song since I heard it...and it makes me cry like ISA does.

I am so anxious and excited about tomorrow...I've heard so many bad things about Smile At You and Silver Girl, but I'm keeping an open mind to all the songs. I'm gonna listen to it as soon as I can get home with it, RIP that sucker open and stick it in the CD player!! I can't wait to see which songs HIT me right off the bat and which ones are growers.

[darklinensuit]

RTTG, though I agree with the poster who misses the "to CUT DOWN" part. Also, rather than repeating "All the love that I have for your life" so often it should repeat the "Never did I mean to" like on the demo. Still, I love the song, & think it could do well if she explains the Hawthorne connection so people aren't thinking the lyrics are too out there.

I like Goodbye Baby. The very beginning (at least the Mp3) sounds like The Second Time, and I keep thinking that Goodbye Baby is probably what Stevie wanted The Second Time to sound like. It was too much voice for that little guitar, but now she has more control/sense of what this kind of song should do. It doesn't have to belt. It doesn't have to scratch like I Sing for the Things. Less is more.

- Jake

[WelshWitchPMD]

Well, my favorite so far is Destiny Rules. I am only getting to listen to the songs on the crappy AOL stream. I will have to wait until tomorrow until I get the CD to make a fair judgement. I have to say that a few songs that I really did not care for that much are starting to grow on me. Those would be "Red Rover" and "Silver Girl". I still am not used to Stevie's vocal on "Goodbye Baby". I think I like"The Tower"demo better.

[EnchantedStorms]

There isn't one single song on this album that I hate. Goodbye Baby is definitely my favorite. But I can't choose a second fav. TD, EFO, DR, SYHA, BTLH, Peacekeeper, SYW, etc....I love them all. Red Rover is probably my least favorite, I think.


~Angela~

[wondergirl9847]

Stevie: Smile at You and Everybody Finds Out

Lindsey: RED FRICKIN ROVER BABY and COME!!!!!!! I love PK too, it is AWESOME on the CD because Stevie's been toned down.

[Canuck Fan]

I'm in the camp that loves all of them. My order at the moment is:
Illume
Miranda
Say You Will
Thrown Down (takes me back with that awesome guitar)
Smile at You (I wanted that piano intro though)
Peacekeeper
Come
Goodbye Baby
say Goodbye
Murrow
Destiny Rules
silver Girl (love it)
Running through the Garden (the return of that rock a little sound)
Whats the world coming to
Red Rover
Every body finds out
Steel your heart away
bleed to love her

[linsluv]

Come

And Red Rover and Murrow... weeeee

[Sorcerer386]

Running Through the Garden has been running through my head for the past two days. I think I've listened to this song more the past two days than the rest of the songs combined, and I had never heard the demo for it. This needs to be a live song.

I'm surprised that so many people like Come. I wonder what Lindsey was thinking when he made it that way...it sounds like some Nu Metal band song. I can't bear him screaming in my ear on the chorus the way he does. Then again, it's just my opinion, so please let's not turn this thread into an 8 page argument over the validity of my statement.

[blinker12]

I'm surprised that so many people like Come. I wonder what Lindsey was thinking when he made it that way...it sounds like some Nu Metal band song. I can't bear him screaming in my ear on the chorus the way he does.

Yup, I totally agree. Hate "Come."
But I love just about everything else, to varying degrees. "Goodbye Baby" and "Thrown Down" are current favorites.