IYD Press Reviews & Discussion

[Jondalar]

Leave a post.

[Gypsybecca]

This review makes me happy! Wasn't expecting it to be so positive. Maybe a few people will also check out The Other Side of the Mirror too- I love that he called it an 'underrated solo gem!"

[FM77]

Originally Posted by jellyman10

^^^ I will never, ever understand reviews of anything where they say scarcely a single negative thing and then penny-pinch on the star rating. The text of that is a 4-star review in anyone's money, and yet it's 3.5. Why?? And of course most people only glance at the star-ratings.

Up yours, RS.

Yet they will give 4 stars to Yoko Ono crap you can't even LISTEN to. Very annoying...

[Jondalar]

I left them a crappy post. Someone else did too. It's BS. She earned her stars.

[Livia]

I'm surprised David Wild didn't do the RS review.

[Bandon]

If you look at the main RS page, the IYD review is entitled, "Stevie Nicks' Stellar Comeback," which is so true. It just kills me how they can say that but give it 3.5 stars???

So what's better than stellar?

[Jondalar]

Originally Posted by Bandon

If you look at the main RS page, the IYD review is entitled, "Stevie Nicks' Stellar Comeback," which is so true. It just kills me how they can say that but give it 3.5 stars???

So what's better than stellar?

Oh yeah, I know,if Tina Turner would of came out with this album they would of given it 5 stars

[tabruns]

Originally Posted by Gypsybecca

This review makes me happy! Wasn't expecting it to be so positive. Maybe a few people will also check out The Other Side of the Mirror too- I love that he called it an 'underrated solo gem!"

The hilarious thing about that part of the review is that The Other Side of the Mirror was under-rated **by Rolling Stone**. They only gave it 2 1/2 stars when it came out. LOL

The thing about Rolling Stone stars is that one person writes the review while some kind of editorial board assign the star ratings. This is why you will see a hugely positive review that reads like a 4 star - like this one - but then not see a full 4 stars assigned. By Rolling Stone standards though, 3 1/2 stars IS actually a very good rating. I agree though that this should have gotten 4 stars.

[Jondalar]

people keep screwing up on their website forgetting to leave the album any stars, dropping the customer review rating for the album, uggg

[GavinBrown]

Short, sweet, but a rave!

http://www.usmagazine.com/moviestvmu...dreams-2011254

[mezzoforte]

Woot! My soon-to-be employers, btw. Makes me love them all the more! I love that they call it the finest album of her solo career--I completely agree!

[Jondalar]

yay! 4 stars

[StandbackStevie]

yes very awesome reviews and I do think Mama has a grammy with the new cd she deserves it she poured her heart and soul into it like she does with everything else. Polish up that Grammy for Ms. Nicks she is taken it home next year.

[GavinBrown]

Warners better have their sh*t together to get her some grammy recognition from this album!!!

[HejiraNYC]

This is the same dude who tweeted (bragging, actually) a few months ago about listening to IYD. He's definitely a fan.