Rock A Little Face Off: Round 5

[Enchanted_Stevi]

Vote for your LEAST favorite song

Round 5 will end Saturday(Oct. 18) @ 12midnight est.

~I Can't Wait
~Rock a Little (Go Ahead Lily)
~Some Become Strangers
~Talk to Me
~If I were You
~No Spoken Word
~Has Anyone Ever Written Anything for You

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Those voted off

Round 1 ~I Sing for the Things
Round 2 ~The Nightmare
Round 3 ~Imperial Hotel
Round 4 ~Sister Honey

[Phoenix]

Woah, woah, wait, someone please explain the hate for some become strangers.

[Enchanted_Stevi]

Originally Posted by Phoenix

Woah, woah, wait, someone please explain the hate for some become strangers.

Someone needs to explain why Sister Honey had so many votes and got voted off cause that song rocks...lol

[fleetwoodtrick]

How The Heck Can Imperial Hotel Be Gone!?

[macpai]

Originally Posted by Enchanted_Stevi

Someone needs to explain why Sister Honey had so many votes and got voted off cause that song rocks...lol

Don't look at me, I like Sister Honey.

[galestreet]

I am going to listen to RAL today and see what song to vote for. I like this album and remember having the cassette at one time. It's sort of nostalgic for me, kind of want to vote those songs back and start over. Hope everyone is having a great Saturday!!

[Enchanted_Stevi]

Originally Posted by macpai

Don't look at me, I like Sister Honey.

I know I was just saying in general./..lol

[macpai]

Originally Posted by Enchanted_Stevi

I know I was just saying in general./..lol

Haha, I know. Just offering my support.

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by Enchanted_Stevi

Someone needs to explain why Sister Honey had so many votes and got voted off cause that song rocks...lol

Well, I can tell you that ordinarily I would vote against it just because it has an outside writer. But it's the one song I make an exception for. I would vote against Blue Letter, Seven Wonders and Talk To Me immediately, because they didn't write it. With strong songwriters, I just think its sacrilege to have a song voted "favorite" that they didn't write.

However, I make an exception for SBS, because it's so evocative and special. Some people, however, may make it an early casualty, because it's not Stevie's. It may be easier to let go than one of hers.

Michele

[macpai]

Originally Posted by michelej1

Well, I can tell you that ordinarily I would vote against it just because it has an outside writer. But it's the one song I make an exception for. I would vote against Blue Letter, Seven Wonders and Talk To Me immediately, because they didn't write it. With strong songwriters, I just think its sacrilege to have a song voted "favorite" that they didn't write.

However, I make an exception for SBS, because it's so evocative and special. Some people, however, may make it an early casualty, because it's not Stevie's. It may be easier to let go than one of hers.

Michele

I understand your point. But I don't think it's sacrilege. If you like a song, you like it. That's all it's meant to do and be. If someone really makes a song their own, that can be as powerful as writing it themselves. Didn't Bob Dylan like Hendrix's All Along the Watchtower more than his own?

[michelej1]

Originally Posted by macpai

I understand your point. But I don't think it's sacrilege. If you like a song, you like it. That's all it's meant to do and be. If someone really makes a song their own, that can be as powerful as writing it themselves. Didn't Bob Dylan like Hendrix's All Along the Watchtower more than his own?

I wouldn't really know.

I'm just offering an explanation as to why SBS may have been getting early votes, even though it's a great song. Normally, I would have voted a song like that off straight away without even thinking about it.

With that one exception, when it comes to LB, SN, and CM, I don't really like a song as much as if they didn't write it. It's a mental thing, but it's there. I would say that SBS is the only exception. Try for the Sun, I am Waiting, Love Minus Zero/No Limit, Blue Letter, Seven Wonders, Reconsider Me -- not to mention the dreadful Talk To Me and all of Lindsey's Rolling Stones covers. . . I just can't feel the same way about them, whether they're good songs or not.

Michele

[baboles]

Originally Posted by Phoenix

Woah, woah, wait, someone please explain the hate for some become strangers.

I know right! What is going on here?

[Musicman408]

Dude, I love SBS. How in the world is it getting voted off sooo early?