American Idol: Season 5

[JazmenFlowers]

just a reminder the show goes live tonight. I think the girls go tonight, guys tomorrow and then an elimination round Thursday.

Seacrest is working overtime.

[skcin]

Yes, it's girls tonight, then boys tomorrow. 2 HOURS each night! Yeah, like I have anything better to do.

[DavidMn]

SO anyway, I really like both Taylor and Kevin the 16 year old. But does either of them have a realistic chance of winning?

[SapphireSister]

WTF is up w/Paula's left eye brow? IT'S ALIVE!

[gldstwmn]

Originally Posted by SapphireSister

WTF is up w/Paula's left eye brow? IT'S ALIVE!

Yeah, there's something going on there. Too much botox maybe?
Little Stevie didn't do so well tonight. That girl that was on at the end it going to win, I think.

[SapphireSister]

Even though he COMPLETELY dissed her wasn't it fabulous to hear Simon keep saying "Stevie"?

I was hoping during her intro she'd say something about being named after La Nicks and our girl being her musical inspiration but instead it's Josh Groban . She's classically trained in opera, I'm not seeing a Nicks connection here. Maybe the mom just liked the name.

[SapphireSister]

Originally Posted by gldstwmn

Yeah, there's something going on there. Too much botox maybe?
Little Stevie didn't do so well tonight. That girl that was on at the end it going to win, I think.

Too bad though, you just can't help but want to root for the girl named Stevie.

[SapphireSister]

My favorite is Lisa, the 16 year old. She is phenomenal!

[Mageboy25]

Madisa, is that spelled right?? Well she out sang Ann Wilson on Never. Like it or not, she sang the song better than Ann ever has, or overdid it even more ever.

Ofourse no one agreed with me on the Heart board. Its against the Bible over there to post anything that’s negative and non ass kissing about Heart. People think deep down inside posting such honest thoughts might jeopardize their slim chances of meeting Ann & Nancy at a summer Meet & Greet. I love The Ledge! You do not get bashed for being honest. I love the Heart board to and all, but everyone is more honest and jovial over here.

Now im not just saying Never was awesome to be nice. I always thought Carrie Underwoods Alone was good, but nothing to get too excited about. She could never outdo Ann. I love Kelly Pickler to death, she’s my 2nd favorite. However she’s milking the "please feel sorry for me, my family life has always sucked card". But you know what, it will probably work. My family life has SUCKED for years. However I keep that to myself. I do not like people feeling sorry for me about personal matters. To each their own, go Kelly!

I can not stand that one stupid ass African American girl that was posing. She thinks that she is so funny for being a Diva, I CANT WAIT to see her go!!!!!! I have a feeling it wont be long either, maybe Thursday night if were lucky! Her performance of that Stevie Wonder song SUCKED!! Anyone could of duplicated what she did tonight.

I wish they would put the best 2 through each week, instead of sending the bottom 2 home. Im scared some people, as its been done in the past, may not vote for their favorites bc they think everyone else already has. Hopefully none of the good people will fall through the cracks.

[ThePenguin]

OK-- my thoughts..

Mandisa kicked *ss. what a powerful voice.

Lisa the 16 yr old is amazing.

Paris is such a pip squeak, her speaking voice compared to her singing voice is a hoot. She's a good performer but her voice isn't as good as the two above.

Catherine also did really well; my daughter loves her.

I didn't like that dusky voiced chick, the one the judges seemed to rave about....what the heck was her name. Melissa? i thought she hit a lot of bad notes.

Kinnik reminded me of a drag queen....

Kelly Pickler was okay but not stunning. and everyone else sort of was so so IMO. Stevie was sort of pathetic. and Brenna sucked big time LOL, pose all you want sister, that doesn't make you sing any better.


I am rooting for Taylor tonight, and of course Ace, he is a hottie LOL.
-Lis

[cliffdweller]

Originally Posted by Mageboy25

Madisa, is that spelled right?? Well she out sang Ann Wilson on Never. Like it or not, she sang the song better than Ann ever has, or overdid it even more ever.

EEEEEEEEH Wrong. But she WAS good, and I give mad props to any singer that attempts a Heart song. It is hard to top (or even equal) Ann Wilson. I thought Carrie Underwood sang the sh*t out of Alone last year.

[cliffdweller]

Originally Posted by ThePenguin

OK-- my thoughts..

Mandisa kicked *ss. what a powerful voice.

Lisa the 16 yr old is amazing.

Paris is such a pip squeak, her speaking voice compared to her singing voice is a hoot. She's a good performer but her voice isn't as good as the two above.

Catherine also did really well; my daughter loves her.

I didn't like that dusky voiced chick, the one the judges seemed to rave about....what the heck was her name. Melissa? i thought she hit a lot of bad notes.

Kinnik reminded me of a drag queen....

Kelly Pickler was okay but not stunning. and everyone else sort of was so so IMO. Stevie was sort of pathetic. and Brenna sucked big time LOL, pose all you want sister, that doesn't make you sing any better.


I am rooting for Taylor tonight, and of course Ace, he is a hottie LOL.
-Lis

I can't stand Paris and yes, Kinnik was very, erm, masculine in the face, but I thought she sounded pretty good. Simon shouldn't have made those comments about her age. What an idiot.

[JazmenFlowers]

well I enjoyed Mandisa, Kinnik, Kelly and Paris. They are my favorites, but I have to say I am really pulling for Mandisa and Paris.

That poor Stevie girl...what was she thinking?

[skcin]

Once again, a bunch of the girls blend together for me at the start of the season. Ayla, Heather, Stevie were all blah, I can tell them apart.

Becky - sounded like she was pretending to sing. Did that just make sense to anyone? It was like me, belting something out in my car even though I have no clue how to actually sing. Ya know? But she's hot, so she'll probably make it through this week.

Brenna - she can just go away now. Are you kidding me? "You Are the Sunshine of My Life?" Seriously? First of all, you want to WOW people, especially your first week & she did NOT. Secondly, that song kind of blows. Thirdly, her voice kind of blows. Fourthly, I just don't like the bitch.

Kinnik - Strange - I thought she was good at first, then I thought she wasn't, then I thought she was good again. She's OK, she can stay for a while.

My favorites:

Mandisa - kicked the **** out of "Never." I was so excited when she said that's what she'd be singing. Fantastic.

Pickler - brave for trying Martina, and I think she was great except those high notes: "How faaaaaar, do I have to go to make you understand..." That little lift in "understand" was funky every time.

Lisa - it appears this chick will be able to sing anything. Love her.

Melissa - She sang Faith, which is risky, but I thought she did really well. I was actually moved by her performance. I hope she doesn't get lost in the sea of "which girl with the long brown hair? There's like 4 of them."

Paris - what a little spitfire, what a performer, what a VOICE! "Midnight Train to Georgia" is one of my favorite songs ever, and she nailed it.

Katherine - Might be my favorite of the night along with Paris, I liked her a lot. Again, hope she doesn't get lost.

I voted for my 6 faves, the only ones I couldn't get through for by 10:40pm were Paris & Pickler.

[BTFLCHLD]

paris and lisa

beckysucks imo